| Presidents' Trophy |
| Year |
Winner |
Runner-Up |
| 2004 |
Detroit Red Wings |
Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2003 |
Ottawa Senators |
Dallas Stars |
| 2002 |
Detroit Red Wings |
Boston Bruins |
| 2001 |
Colorado Avalanche |
Detroit Red Wings |
| 2000 |
St. Louis Blues |
Detroit Red Wings |
| 1999 |
Dallas Stars |
Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1998 |
Dallas Stars |
New Jersey Devils |
| 1997 |
Colorado Avalanche |
Dallas Stars |
| 1996 |
Detroit Red Wings |
Colorado Avalanche |
| 1995 |
Detroit Red Wings |
Quebec Nordiques |
| 1994 |
New York Rangers |
New Jersey Devils |
| 1993 |
Pittsburgh Penguins |
Boston Bruins |
| 1992 |
New York Rangers |
Washington Capitals |
| 1991 |
Chicago Blackhawks |
St. Louis Blues |
| 1990 |
Boston Bruins |
Calgary Flames |
| 1989 |
Calgary Flames |
Montreal Canadiens |
| 1988 |
Calgary Flames |
Montreal Canadiens |
| 1987 |
Edmonton Oilers |
Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1986 |
Edmonton Oilers |
Philadelphia Flyers |
| Awarded to the team with the most points in the regular season |
|
|
|
|
|
