Extra MustardSI On CampusFantasyPhoto GalleriesSwimsuitVideoFanNationSI KidsTNT

Fan Value Index

SI.com analyzes which ballparks offer the best value

Posted: Wednesday August 31, 2005 3:37PM; Updated: Tuesday September 20, 2005 5:36PM
Free E-mail AlertsE-mail ThisPrint ThisSave ThisMost PopularRSS Aggregators
Fan Value Index: Final Rankings
Rank Team Stadium
1 Milwaukee Brewers Miller Park
2 Pittsburgh Pirates PNC Park
3 Colorado Rockies Coors Field
4 L.A. Angels of Anaheim Angel Stadium
5 Atlanta Braves Turner Field
6 St. Louis Cardinals Busch Stadium
7 Philadelphia Phillies Citizens Bank Park
8 Cincinnati Reds Great American Ball Park
9 Arizona D'backs Bank One Ballpark
10 Cleveland Indians Jacobs Field
11 Chicago Cubs Wrigley Field
12 Toronto Blue Jays Rogers Centre
13 Boston Red Sox Fenway Park
14 New York Yankees Yankee Stadium
15 Oakland Athletics McAfee Coliseum
16 Chicago White Sox U.S. Cellular Field
17 Texas Rangers Ameriquest Field
18 Baltimore Orioles Camden Yards
19 Seattle Mariners Safeco Field
20 Kansas City Royals Kauffman Stadium
21 Houston Astros Minute Maid Park
22 San Diego Padres PETCO Park
23 Tampa Bay D-Rays Tropicana Field
24 San Francisco Giants SBC Park
25 Los Angeles Dodgers Dodger Stadium
26 Washington Nationals RFK Stadium
27 Detroit Tigers Comerica Park
28 Florida Marlins Dolphins Stadium
29 Minnesota Twins HHH Metrodome
30 New York Mets Shea Stadium
Submit a comment or question for Paul.
Your name:
Your e-mail address:
Your home town:
Enter your question:

By Paul Forrester, SI.com (with additional reporting and writing by Andy Gray)

Part of the beauty of sport lies in its simplicity. Statistics usually are a clear indication of what player or team is better, at least at a particular moment in time. But what about the venues in which those numbers are produced? There are few precise statistics to measure if fans at Wrigley Field are getting the same return on their investment as the fans at PETCO Park.

SI.com decided to take a comprehensive survey of the experiences at each major league ballpark in order to determine where fans are getting the best bang for their buck. We sorted the information into seven categories and rated each park on a 1-10 scale, 10 being best.

The criteria we considered:

Average ticket price

Figures determined by Team Marketing Report's 2005 Fan Cost Index, which represents a weighted average of season ticket prices.

Average cost of concessions/souvenirs

The estimated amount a family of four would spend at a game. The total, based in part on Team Marketing Reports calculations, includes the prices of two small draft beers, four small soft drinks, four regular-size hot dogs, parking for one car, two game programs and two adult-size adjustable caps.


How easy is it to get to the park? Do subways and buses provide quick, cheap service to the front door or is driving the only option? And if you drive, how difficult is it to find parking nearby?


The more, the better. A full complement of restrooms and concession stands means fans won't miss any game action because of long lines. This category also takes into account how well teams accommodate disabled fans with special seating and provide children with options to relieve excess energy (i.e. batting cages or playgrounds).


A measure of the vibe inside the ballpark, taking into account the knowledge of the fans as well as their interest in the happenings on the field.


Entertainment/dining options in the vicinity of the stadium.


The bottom line on the club's performance this year.

This was not merely an exercise to determine baseball's best stadium. Nor was it an attempt to evaluate the best experience in an absolute sense. The Fan Value Index is an effort to find which ballparks offer the best experience for the money.

(In cases of a tie, the team with the better record this season was awarded the higher overall ranking.)

Check out pull-down menu above or click on the links in the chart to read a profile of each park.

Let the arguments begin ...