Extra MustardSI On CampusFantasyPhoto GalleriesSwimsuitVideoFanNationSI KidsTNT

Rust belt blues

Extra rest fails to help Tigers; Magglio's big mistake

Posted: Sunday October 22, 2006 12:58AM; Updated: Monday October 23, 2006 1:25AM
Free E-mail AlertsE-mail ThisPrint ThisSave ThisMost PopularRSS Aggregators
Brandon Inge's poor defense hurt the Tigers in Game 1.
Brandon Inge's poor defense hurt the Tigers in Game 1.
Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images
More from Baseball Prospectus


By Nate Silver, BaseballProspectus.com

DETROIT -- The Tigers came into tonight's game with a full six days of inactivity against the Cardinals' one. That five-day differential is the largest ever in a World Series. But three teams had four more off-days than their opponents before playing in the World Series, and they didn't seem to suffer for it:

• The 1996 Yankees lost the first two games of the Series, but then took four straight from the favored Braves, bringing Joe Torre his first of four championships as New York's manager.
• The 1991 Twins won the first two games of the Series, also against the Braves, eventually going on to win in a thrilling, seven-game Series.
• The 1981 Yankees reversed the fate of the 1996 club, winning the first two games of the Series but losing the next four to the Dodgers.

Another trio of teams had three extra days off before the World Series:

• The 2005 White Sox, who swept the Astros.
• The 1995 Braves, who beat the Indians in six, including wins in the first two games of the Series.
• The 1988 A's, who were upset by the Dodgers, losing Game 1 on Kirk Gibson's Roy Hobbs impersonation.

So among the extra-rested clubs, that's a 4-2 record, both in the first game of the series and overall. Now, we should expect the rested clubs to have been favored in those games because it takes a stronger team to beat an LCS opponent in four or five games than in six or seven, which is how you get the extra rest in the first place. But the Rust Belt teams have no clear pattern of difficulty in the historical record. In fact, they've done pretty well for themselves.

The Tigers sure looked rusty, though. Didn't they? Well, perhaps. You can use a lot of adjectives to describe the performance of a team that loses a ballgame 7-2 -- rusty, pathetic, heartbreaking -- and none of them are kind ones. The Tigers certainly didn't look rusty out of the gate, though. Justin Verlander cruised through the first inning looking sharp and relaxed, while Anthony Reyes was lucky to get away with allowing only one run in the bottom of the frame.

After that, the game got away from the Tigers. Slowly at first, on a Scott Rolen home run that ought to remove any lingering doubt about his health -- Rolen really extended on that ball. And then all at once, as the Cardinals put up crooked numbers in the third and sixth innings.

Yes, there were a couple of ugly moments along the way, most obviously Brandon Inge's uncharacteristic defensive miscues. The game got away from the Tigers, however, for one reason and one reason only: they quit taking pitches while the Cardinals kept working to set up good at-bats. In the first inning, Reyes threw 22 pitches: nine balls, and 13 strikes (five of which were put into play). Then, for the next seven innings combined, Reyes threw only 14 balls -- against 53 strikes. That's just 2.4 pitches per Tiger batter in the second through eighth innings, and barely more than one ball for every second at-bat.

Reyes deserves much of the credit for this. His command and pitch selection were spot-on. As I commented in my World Series preview over at BaseballProspectus.com, the ball can be hard to pick up coming out of Reyes' glove, and that can mean rough sledding for a team like the Tigers that is hitting against him for the first time. The Tigers made an awful lot of foul contact tonight, which is a good indication of a team that is not seeing the ball real well.

The Tigers certainly didn't make Reyes' job any harder, however. Perhaps their irrational exuberance at the plate was the result of rust, or at least over-anxiousness. But the Tigers have been doing this all year long. Their hitters finished next-to-last in the American League in both strikeouts and walks this season, a combination that is all but unprecedented for a team that advanced to the World Series. Sometimes, their prodigious power bails them out. Tonight it didn't, as is bound to happen from time to time when you have this undisciplined a plate approach.

Missed Opportunity

Ironically, one of the worst decisions made by a Tiger in this game was the choice to take a pitch. In the bottom of the first inning, the score still nil-nil, Magglio Ordonez faced a 3-0 count with two outs, Craig Monroe on second base, and first base vacant. A walk doesn't do you a whole hell a lot of good there; with two outs, you want a base hit to score Monroe, who can run on any contact. In fact, the manager will sometimes give up, and walk the batter intentionally in that situation. Reyes threw a fat pitch right over the middle on 3-0, just like pitchers usually do. And Ordonez took it, just like hitters always do. The Tigers eventually scored in the inning anyway, but this was a poor decision on Ordonez' part.


1 of 2