Posted: Tuesday August 22, 2006 3:42PM; Updated: Tuesday August 22, 2006 3:42PM
SI Players Poll
[Based on a survey of 470 MLB players]
Who is the best manager in baseball?
Paul Abell/US Presswire
Bobby Cox.....Braves......30% Jim Leyland.....Tigers.....18% Joe Torre.....Yankees.....12% Tony LaRussa.....Cardinals.....10% Ozzie Guillen.....White Sox.....8% Dusty Baker.....Giants......4% Terry Francona.....Red Sox......2% Mike Scioscia.....Angels......2% Bruce Bochy.....Padres......2% Joe Girardi.....Marlins......2%
The worst?
AP
Frank Robinson.....Nationals......17% Buck Showalter.....Rangers.....15% Mike Hargrove.....Mariners.....8% Clint Hurdle.....Rockies.....7% Eric Wedge.....White Sox.....6% Willie Randolph.....Mets......6% Ozzie Guillen.....White Sox......5% Buddy Bell.....Royals......4% Felipe Alou.....Giants......4% Mike Scioscia.....Angels......3%
FAST FACTS: The White Sox' Ozzie Guillen, 2005's AL Manager of the Year, was fifth in the best vote (7.5%) and seventh in the worst vote (4.8%) .... Robinson, the only current skipper in the Hall of Fame, got 37.7% of the worst vote among NL East players .... Cox led the best vote in last year's SI Players Poll with 37% .... Robinson and Showalter topped last year's worst list, followed by Lloyd McClendon (Pirates), Larry Bowa (Phillies), Lou Piniella (Devil Rays) and Tony Peña (Royals) -- none of whom are still managing in the majors.