Extra MustardSI On CampusFantasyPhoto GalleriesSwimsuitVideoFanNationSI KidsTNT

Too hot to handle

Will Stewart's simmering anger sabotage his season?

Posted: Tuesday May 1, 2007 12:12PM; Updated: Tuesday May 1, 2007 5:32PM
Print ThisE-mail ThisFree E-mail AlertsSave ThisMost PopularRSS Aggregators

He's been fined and placed on probation after avoiding a post-race media session in Phoenix. He's accused NASCAR of manipulating races as if it were professional wrestling. And he's angrily accused driver David Gilliland of having little talent following a crash at Talladega. Is Tony Stewart's anger getting the best of him this season? SI.com's Lars Anderson and Tim Tuttle each offer their opinions.

Head2Head
Is Tony Stewart his own worst enemy this year?
Read both sides, then let us know what you think.
No
Despite a season's worth of bad luck already, Tony Stewart still finds himself in sixth place in the points standings.
AP

By Lars Anderson

No. Tony Stewart's worst enemy this season? Try horrific luck

Let's review:

• At the season opening Daytona 500, Stewart clearly had the fastest car in the field until ... he was wrecked.

• Three races later at Atlanta and he again had the elite car for much of the race and he would have won going away, but a late caution came out, the field was tightened, and Jimmie Johnson passed him in the final laps; Stewart finished second.

• The next week at Bristol Stewart was hands-down the quickest on the track until ... his fuel pump gave out and he wound up 35th.

• A month later, at Phoenix, his Home Depot Chevy was one of the two fastest racecars in the field, and he came in second. Then last week at Talladega he had a car capable of finishing in the top-three, but was wrecked on the last lap and wound up 28th.

These near misses and wrecks have clearly frustrated Stewart, and who can blame him? By my count he should have at least three wins this season if he hadn't been wrecked, or if the caution flags fell in his favor, or if his equipment had held up. But these things happen in racing, and when they do, they tend to occur in bunches.

True, Stewart shouldn't have ripped NASCAR on his Sirius satellite radio show last week and he shouldn't have compared the sport to pro wrestling, but Stewart is simply incapable of sugarcoating what he's feeling, which is why I've always found him to be one of the most compelling personalities in NASCAR.

Stewart will be just fine this season, and I still think he's one of five drivers who has a legitimate shot at the championship; the others being Jeff Gordon, Johnson, Matt Kenseth and Jeff Burton. Over the next month you can expect two things from Stewart: One, he'll assume a lower profile; and two, he'll reach Victory Lane -- maybe multiple times.

Yes
Tony Stewart's simmering anger over his rocky start appears to becoming a bigger distraction each week.
AP

By Tim Tuttle

Tony Stewart had a bona fide reason for being angry following Sunday's race at Talladega. He went from a chance to win and, at minimum, a top-five finish to 28th with a wrecked car after David Gilliland bashed into the No. 20 from behind.

You also can understand a little finger-pointing at the driver Stewart initially thought caused the crash, Jamie McMurray, and some critical words directed at Gilliland's driving talent.

But Stewart needs to get over it and get back to business. Often in his Nextel Cup career, Stewart has allowed the frustrations of racing to carry over from week to week, continually forcing him in front of the media. That becomes a serious distraction as he goes through race weekend preparations for the race. With the state of competition in Cup, even a driver of Stewart's greatness can't afford it; he's hurting his chances to win races and score more points.

This season has seen a string of disappointments for Stewart. Each week something seems to go wrong, a pattern that has seemingly sent Stewart boiling over the last three weeks. After contact and spinning out twice sent him to tumbling to a 25th-place finish at Texas, Stewart talked of retirement. Second place at Phoenix the next week didn't do his disposition any good, either. Stewart didn't speak to the media following the race, but blasted NASCAR for throwing cautions for debris on his radio show the next Tuesday. He thought the yellows cost him victory.

Stewart's accusation the story last Friday at Talladega, where NASCAR summoned him to its transporter for a 6 a.m. meeting. The Powers That Be fined him $10,000 and put him on probation, but worse was Stewart having to go to the media center to explain himself when he should have been focusing on his race car.

Stewart, obviously, is unhappy with how this season has gone. If he wants to get it turned around, Stewart needs to get over it.

React: Tell us if you think Tony Stewart is his own worst enemy?
Your name:
Your E-mail:
Your Hometown:
Make your case:

Reader responses: Is Stewart his own worst enemy?

Here's a sampling of your responses:

Shawn of Dallas: "Stewart is one of the most talented crybabies on the circuit and is serious need of an attitude adjustment. There is such parity within NASCAR these days that driver skill, team chemistry and good equipment often take a back seat to luck. Tony is suffering a down period JUST LIKE EVERY OTHER DRIVER ON THE CIRCUIT GOES THROUGH! But his problem is that he won't admit as much and instead blames everyone but himself for his problems."

Ken Masters of Buffalo, N.Y.: "Tony Stewart is an immature spoiled brat and a professional victim. He's clearly a talented driver, but someone most love to hate as evidenced by the cheers eminating from the stands at California Motor Speedway during the 2006 Auto Club 500 when he blew an engine after leading the race.

"I hope he doesn't get over it, because its great entertainment from week to week to see what little Tony will cry about this time."

Ben of Providence: "Lot's of bad racing luck for Tony this year. I have had the honor of meeting face-to-face with Tony several times and have found him to be down to earth, but driven, funny, and self-deprecating. He is also highly competitive. I think NASCAR desperately needs more drivers like Tony who are in-your-face honest, not afraid to say what's on their minds and most of all, have some personality! If Dale Earnhardt Sr. were alive, and he had the racing luck that Tony has had this year and done/said what Tony has (I suspect that he may even have done/said a lot more than Tony), I suspect that everyone would be saying that it is great for the sport -- after all he did exactly that for years!

"Go get 'em Tony; don't change who you are!"

Jason M. of San Antonio, Texas: "Stewart is his own worst enemy. He's too quick to point fingers and bad talk other drivers for accidents. He should know wrecks are sometimes unavoidable. How much reaction time does a driver have at 190 plus miles per hour? Not much. So how are they to avoid hitting someone in a mass of confusion during a crash? Stewart reminds me of Rusty Wallace about ten years ago; always blaming the other guy and not taking responsibility for his own actions."

Judy Baldoni of Ocala, Fla.: "If everyone would just leave Tony alone, he would get back to the sweet Tony we all know and love. NASCAR would be so boring without someone like Tony, who knows how to wake up the sport. Everything he says is not always correct, but he brings up a lot of questions a lot of drivers want to know and are too CHICKEN to say or ask. He was wrong to compare NASCAR to wrestling, but he always gives us fans a good race day. Love that SMOKE."

Lynn of Pasadena, Md.: "Tony Stewart is an old school drivers. It's a shame that NASCAR has turned this sport into ballet. You can't do ANYTHING or say ANYTHING without getting fined. Why can't they let the drivers just drive and stop nit-picking about the smallest things. No. 3 would be livid if he was here today to see this."

DC DeCastro of Virginia Beach, Va.: "No This is just another item for you journalists to create additional stories and commentaries about.

"On the track, Tony Stewart is still a dang good driver. Heck, as Lars Anderson accurately pointed out, he's still No. 6 overall in the current points leaderboard. He just wears his heart on his sleeve, and by forcing him to be something he's not, it would just make him worse.

"To me, I think he was too quiet last year and not aggressive enough. Personally, I believe the old Stewart is back and it won't be long before he goes on a tear and start finishing first a few times."

Billie Virginian of Livermore, Calif.:"He's always been his own worst enemy. Folks have given him a pass for a long time saying "he tells it like it is" Wrong. He has told like HE sees it (usually after a bad day and he is behaving like a two-year-old) and that isn't the same thing. Grow up, Tony or get outta the way! There are numerous young drivers ready to step up to the plate and enjoy the experience of NASCAR racing. You don't get to make the rules at your job any more than the rest of us do at ours ..."

ADVERTISEMENT

Search