Extra MustardSI On CampusFantasyPhoto GalleriesSwimsuitVideoFanNationSI KidsTNT

Fantasy Preview: Outfielders

Second-tier talent is in abundance in the outfield

Posted: Tuesday March 18, 2008 11:40AM; Updated: Monday March 24, 2008 1:00PM
Free E-mail AlertsE-mail ThisPrint ThisSave ThisMost PopularRSS Aggregators
Position-By-Position Rankings
C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | OF | DH/UT | SP | RP
Projected 2008 Stats
Rank Player BA R HR RBI SB
1 Alfonso Soriano .278 101 39 117 19
2 Chris Young .274 102 31 118 26
3 Matt Holliday .319 114 31 118 14
4 Grady Sizemore .277 111 27 96 21
5 Adam Dunn .261 105 39 105 7
6 Carl Crawford .299 96 13 68 37
7 Corey Hart .288 94 26 83 22
8 Carlos Beltran .276 95 28 96 14
9 Carlos Lee .291 89 26 98 12
10 Hunter Pence .286 91 25 89 14
11 Curtis Granderson .267 93 22 87 16
12 Andruw Jones .257 85 31 99 8
13 Eric Byrnes .279 86 19 73 24
14 Alexis Rios .281 92 21 85 16
15 Lastings Milledge .290 85 19 73 22
SLEEPER
Jeff Francoeur .283 76 22 86 8
BUST
Aaron Rowand .279 66 14 66 7
NOTE: Draft rankings are based on BP's Player Forecast Manager software (PFM), and assume a standard rotisserie 5x5 format with no keepers. Rankings customized to your league's rules, including dollar values for auction-based drafts, are available to Baseball Prospectus subscribers.

These projections account for a player's projected injury risk and playing time, as well as contextual factors such as the strength of his teammates and his position in the batting order. PECOTA is human and its rankings are not always perfect. Well, actually it's a computer. But we have commented when we think its valuations have gone astray.
ADVERTISEMENT

By Rany Jazayerli, BaseballProspectus.com

The talent in the outfield has dropped off from where it was a few years ago, when it seemed you couldn't swing a bat without conking it into an All-Star outfielder, particularly in the National League. In particular, speed is not as easy to come by as it used to be -- only two outfielders are projected for even 30 steals, whereas at shortstop alone there are three such players. Even elite home run hitters are hard to find; only two of the top 11 projected home run totals come in the outfield.

But if you can live with the fact that there are no true category-busters to be had, you'll live well picking from the wide variety of second-tier talent. There are more than 30 outfielders who project for double figures in both homers and steals, guaranteeing that you won't run out of desirable players even as your draft reaches the endgame.

1. Alfonso Soriano

PECOTA stubbornly refuses to believe that a player with Soriano's skill set will continue to lead off. The Cubs stubbornly cling to the idea that he's a leadoff hitter, which will eat into that RBI total but might help in the steals department. No matter where he bats, his freakish ability to make hard contact on bad pitches means he'll contribute across the board.

2. Chris Young

Young made big contributions as a rookie last seasonin homers and stolen bases, but was a disappointment in the other three categories. That changes this year -- young players with this kind of power and speed are not going to hit .237 every year, and Young's RBI total last year was the result of a flukishly-bad performance with runners in scoring position. He's a potential five-category monster, and he's only 24.

3. Matt Holliday

Holliday has increased his batting average, home runs, runs and RBIs every year he's been in the majors. Don't expect that to continue, but expect him to be an MVP candidate again this year. He's projected to have the highest average of any outfielder, and Coors Field assures him of more at-bats than your typical player, which means even more of a boost to your team's batting average.

4. Grady Sizemore

In real life, Sizemore might be the best center fielder in the game, and he's still improving. Last year he drew 101 walks, and all those extra times on first base led to a career-high 33 steals. He's just 25 and might have one big jump left in his development curve -- don't be surprised if he's No. 1 on this list a year from now.

5. Adam Dunn

Make sure you move Dunn down a few slots if you believe that Dusty Baker's blatherings about how Dunn needs to be more aggressive are going to be an issue in Cincinnati. Dunn's walks might not help you, but it's his patient approach that leads to so many of the homers that do.

6. Carl Crawford

Crawford is a fantastic player, but he's reaching the age where his steals totals are likely to slowly erode, and time is running out for him to show the power spike he needs to become a full, five-category player. If the Rays' young offense is as good as a lot of people say it is, he'll crash the century mark in runs scored with ease.

7. Corey Hart

Players this tall -- Hart's listed at 6-6 -- are not supposed to run this fast. But they are supposed to hit for prodigious power, so his home run potential should counteract any potential loss of speed. Don't fool yourself into thinking last year was a fluke -- PECOTA has been projecting a breakout for Hart for a few years now.

8. Carlos Beltran

When he's on his game and completely healthy, Beltran might be the best fantasy outfielder in baseball. But he always seems to be battling minor injuries, and you can't be sure that he won't give you another clunker of a season like 2005 was.

9. Carlos Lee

As much as the Astros overpaid for Lee, he is the perfect fit for their park -- last season he hit .345-17-68 at home, just .262-15-51 on the road. The problem is, as his road numbers show, he's already starting to slip. And the Astros' offense won't be doing him any favors this year.

10. Hunter Pence

Lee's teammate, on the other hand, is on his way up, and Pence hit equally well on the road and at home. Some regression to the mean is inevitable this year, but even so PECOTA forecasts that Lee is worth only 25 cents more than Pence, and that's entirely due to Lee's impressive durability.

11. Curtis Granderson

If your league uses triples as a category, Granderson's a first-rounder. Some of those triples might turn into homers this year, but Granderson's the rare player whose platoon splits might be an issue in fantasy. He's had so little success against left-handed pitching (.202 career average) that opposing managers are going to be sure to send out a steady diet of lefty relievers against him in the later innings. Caveat emptor.

12. Andruw Jones

PECOTA forecasts that the scourge of many a fantasy team last year will bounce back at least a little for the Dodgers -- Hall of Fame talents aren't supposed to be washed up at 30. But his days as one of the game's best center fielders may be over.

13. Eric Byrnes

Raise your hand if you saw 50 stolen bases coming. Yeah, me neither. PECOTA isn't buying it, but projects him to maintain his performance in every other category. The Diamondbacks love him, and at $10 million a year you can rest easy that he won't go back to being a platoon player anytime soon.

14. Alexis Rios

Rios is a five-category player who's still improving. Only in his mid-20s, a breakout season might be coming ... unfortunately, that's what was said about his teammate Vernon Wells a year ago. Unless Fantasy Disappointment Syndrome is a contagious disease, Rios should continue to be a very solid player; consider his projection above to be more of a baseline.

15. Lastings Milledge

No, we don't know what Omar Minaya was thinking either. Nationals GM Jim Bowden loves guys like Milledge who sweat tools out of their pores. PECOTA strongly feels that, playing everyday, he'll live up to the hype.

Sleeper: Jeff Francoeur

Frenchy was a mild disappointment last year as his homers dropped from 29 to 19 -- but his doubles jumped from 24 to 40, and at his age (just 24) that's a very strong indicator that more homers are on their way. His plate discipline also improved significantly last year, and he hasn't missed a game in two years.

Bust: Aaron Rowand

Rowand is 30 years old, coming off a career year, and just left one of the best homer parks in baseball -- where he batted in the middle of one of the game's best offenses. Instead he'll play in San Francisco, where the homers are hard to come by and where he's likely to be sandwiched in the lineup between Randy Winn and Ray Durham -- and that's the heart of the Giants' lineup.

To get more in-depth information on the upcoming season, pick up a copy of the best selling baseball annual, Baseball Prospectus, by clicking here.

divider line
Search