SI.com Home
Get SI's Duke Championship Package Free  Subscribe to SI Give the Gift of SI
  • PRINT PRINT
  • EMAIL EMAIL
  • RSS RSS
  • BOOKMARK SHARE
Posted: Friday June 13, 2008 10:16PM; Updated: Saturday June 14, 2008 10:55PM
Arash Markazi Arash Markazi >
ON THE SCENE

Media rethinks '02 West finals (cont.)

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
The Shaq-Kobe Lakers were a ratings bonanza for NBC and ABC, right up to the duo's bitter parting after the 2004 season.
The Shaq-Kobe Lakers were a ratings bonanza for NBC and ABC, right up to the duo's bitter parting after the 2004 season.
AP

"I wondered, looking back, if we would feel good about how we covered it, feel like we saw that if something wasn't at least wrong going on then something at least unusual was happening or would we be embarrassed and find that we wrote a dozen stories and none of them mentioned refereeing," said Modesti, as he sat in the press room at the Staples Center before Game 4. "Well, of course, anyone who remembers that series, you couldn't watch those games without commenting on the officiating. I went back and looked at the 10 stories we wrote after Game 6 and four of them went heavily into the foul disparity and officiating."

Vincent Bonsignore, who was assigned to cover the Sacramento Kings for the Daily News during the series, wrote that "the Kings never were meant to win Game 6. This had nothing to do with the Lakers or Kings, [Vlade] Divac and his teammates stressed, and everything to do with how the officials called the game."

Throughout the story, he had quotes from Kings players blaming the officials for the loss. "Why don't they just let us know in advance?" said Divac, half-jokingly suggesting the officials knew who would win beforehand. "We didn't have a chance to win." Chris Webber said, "We didn't have a chance tonight ... I'm not going to say what I really feel. I'll get fined. I'll keep my opinions to myself." While Bobby Jackson added, "We hope the officials don't dictate the outcome of the game [7]."

While Bonsignore hadn't looked back at his story since it ran, he vividly remembered the scene in Kings locker room after Game 6 because, as he said, he had never covered a game or a series dominated by talk of officiating as much. "You don't want to be suspicious because you want to believe things are on the up and up," he said. "But the fact that [allegations] have come up now, how can it really be a surprise when everyone was really talking about it back then? To a man, every Kings player felt that [Game 6] had been decided before they even took the floor. It wasn't a question in any of their minds that they got robbed and looking back at it now, maybe they did."

Many of the writers who had covered Game 6 at the Staples Center said they didn't remember the game or the stories they wrote well enough to comment on it six years later, as they prepared to cover Game 4 of the NBA Finals, joking as Daily News columnist Steve Dilbeck did, that they barely remembered what they wrote yesterday.

The question, however, intrigued Los Angeles Times columnist Bill Plaschke enough that he went to the media room, opened up his computer and looked back at the column he wrote after the game, reading passages aloud after he had found it.

"By then, it was simply a matter of the Lakers taking advantage of the sort of liberal officiating that made one wonder: Were the referees attempting to make up for a poorly called Game 5 with a worse job in Game 6?" he read from his computer. "The Kings will talk forever about how the Lakers shot 27 free throws in the fourth quarter, while the Kings shot nine. Viewers everywhere will wonder how basketball's two most exciting teams could be ground to a halt by officials who were decidedly not going to let the players play."

Looking back at the column, Plaschke has a bittersweet feeling. While he says, "thank God I wrote about the officiating," he regrets that it was only a small part of a column headlined, "They Refuse To Lose The Look Of A Champion," which mainly focused on the Lakers keeping alive their bid for a Three-Peat going into Game 7.

"That was the worse game I've ever seen called before or since, but I still didn't want to believe there could ever be a conspiracy. I think maybe I was na´ve," said Plaschke. "As bad as the game was officiated, at that time in my career, and even until a couple days ago, I thought it all evens out. You could tell I didn't want to believe it. I wrote about it, but I didn't want to take that next step to say that it's rigged. But I remember we all talked about and the next day I remember thinking, 'Did I blow it? Should I have been tougher?' But I always thought the calls even out."

Plaschke recalls bringing up the game and the calls the Lakers got in the series to commissioner Stern during the NBA Finals that year.

"He looked at me, pointed his finger and said, 'If you're going to write that there's a conspiracy theory, then you better understand that you're accusing us of committing a felony and if you put that in the paper you better have your facts straight,'" he said. "So I just backed off, I didn't have any facts, just what I saw, but he got very upset at me."

So knowing what he and other writers know now, how would he handle a similarly officiated game in the future?

"It's totally changed, I gave everyone the out back then," he said. "Everyone says its just Tim Donaghy, a shamed ref. Well, Jose Canseco is a shamed baseball player, and everything he said was right. I don't know what to believe now. Honest to god, I don't know what to believe, watching these games, I just don't know what to believe anymore."

 
1 2
  • PRINT PRINT
  • EMAIL EMAIL
  • RSS RSS
  • BOOKMARK SHARE
ADVERTISEMENT
SI.com
Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs Chris Johnson Jameis Winston NFL Draft Michael Sam Aldon Smith
TM & © 2013 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint