Extra MustardSI On CampusFantasyPhoto GalleriesSwimsuitVideoFanNationSI KidsTNT

The bag (cont.)

Posted: Wednesday February 20, 2008 1:25PM; Updated: Wednesday February 20, 2008 3:04PM
Free E-mail AlertsE-mail ThisPrint ThisSave ThisMost PopularRSS Aggregators
ADVERTISEMENT
MAILBAG
Grant Wahl will periodically answer questions from SI.com users in his mailbag.
Your name:
Your e-mail address:
Your home town:
Enter your question:

How about a Players-Who-Deserved-a-Better-Fate team? My poster child is Sean Singletary of Virginia.
--
Dick Friedman, Princeton Junction, N.J.

Let's give this a crack:

Sean Singletary, Virginia (12-12, 2-9 ACC). The Cavaliers have been utterly schizophrenic this season, beating Arizona and Boston College on the road but losing 10 of their last 12 games (including a 31-point loss to Clemson that should never, ever happen on your home court). But Singletary remains a bright spot, averaging 18.8 points a game.

Richard Hendrix, Alabama (14-12, 3-8 SEC). These are tough times in Tuscaloosa, but Hendrix has been terrific, averaging 18.6 points and 10.2 boards a game. Oh, what might have been if Ronnie Steele had his old knees back.

Geoff McDermott, Providence (13-13, 4-10 Big East). The Friars have fallen on hard times in the Big East, but McDermott is one my favorite players and among the best-passing big guys in the country. He does a little bit of everything, averaging 10.3 points, 8.0 rebounds and 4.6 assists.

Ryan Anderson, Cal (15-9, 6-7 Pac-10). The Bears are yet another example of the Pac-10's strength, and Anderson is the best example of the Bears' strength. You can't help but like a 6-10 forward who shoots 46 percent from three-point range (with a high volume, I might add) and averages 22.0 points and 10.2 rebounds a game.

Kentrell Gransberry, South Florida (11-15, 2-11 Big East). You had to feel for Gransberry after the Bulls' 74-73 overtime loss to UConn last Saturday. All the guy did was put up 26 and 15, par for the course for a player who's averaging 17.2 and 11.0.

Everyone talks about Duke's one weakness being the lack of an inside presence, yet Wake Forest beat the Blue Devils with its best post player in foul trouble the entire game. It seemed to me that Wake won because of its superior athletes. With two lightning-quick point guards on the court at the same time, players like Jon Scheyer and Greg Paulus had trouble on both defense and offense. It might sound crazy, but would you consider Duke's overall lack of athleticism (other than Gerald Henderson and DeMarcus Nelson) to be a weakness that could plague them in the NCAA tournament?
--
Joshua Newell, Charlotte

I would caution against taking too much out of one game. Duke played probably its worst game of the year, and the Deacs were inspired all night. (Plus, there was all sorts of strangeness with all five Duke starters fouling out. What are the chances of that happening again?) I don't know if I'd say that Duke has a huge lack of athleticism (I'd add Kyle Singler and Nolan Smith to Henderson and Nelson as the team's most athletic guys), but my concern with the Blue Devils right now is fatigue. We'll see if any of that continues in the coming games or if the Wake loss was a one-night aberration. Right now I'm leaning toward the latter.

Could Kelvin Sampson screw over Washington State again? Almost 15 years ago, Sampson brought WSU to the hallowed ground of the NCAA tournament for the first time in more than a decade. He immediately used his newfound cachet to bolt and land the vacant Oklahoma coaching position, sending WSU's basketball program back into its familiar abyss. Now WSU has arguably the finest young coach in the country in Tony Bennett. Could Sampson's likely firing leave an opening for Bennett that he couldn't refuse?
--
Ster, Dallas

It's certainly possible, though I try not to engage in too much speculation without any hard news (and I have none on Sampson's status at Indiana or his potential successors). Clearly Bennett's first two seasons as the head man in Pullman have been remarkable, and as a Wisconsin native he knows Big Ten country well. It would strike me as a good fit for Indiana. But the same could be true for Dan Dakich or Scott Skiles or Lawrence Frank or Steve Alford or Sean Miller or ... you get my point. (i.e., it's too early. We aren't even sure yet if Sampson's out the door.)

Here's what I do know about Indiana: 1) I've now seen two games at IU after making (strangely) my first trip to Bloomington, and the amount of fan support Hoosiers basketball receives is overwhelming. It's a special place, one that deserves a special coach. 2) The Hoosiers are a genuine Final Four contender. The wins over Michigan State and Purdue only reinforced that notion. Any team that has Eric Gordon and D.J. White can make it to San Antonio, but it certainly helps to have a third significant attacking option (when either Armon Bassett or Jordan Crawford is playing well).

What do you think about Saint Mary's this year?
--
Megan, Lafayette, Calif.

I like what Randy Bennett has done in Moraga by assembling a team that can compete toe-to-toe with Gonzaga (for the last two seasons, at least) and spread you out on the offensive end. Bennett was smart to construct his Australian pipeline, and even better, the Gaels are a young squad that should be dangerous in the seasons to come. Do I think they have the firepower to get to the second week of the NCAA tournament? Probably not. But just winning a game in the tourney would be enough to end this ascendant season on the right note.

What do you think of Stanford's chances in the tournament? The Cardinal team can dominate in the low post with the Lopez twins, but could its weakness in guard play send it out early?
--
Devin Mitchell, South Pasadena, Calif.

You know, the Lopez brothers (especially Brook) are so good I think Stanford might be able to make up for the dropoff on the perimeter -- not for six games in the tournament, but maybe three or four. It all depends on matchups. If I'm Stanford, I wouldn't want to face a high-pressure perimeter-oriented team with reasonably capable post guys (i.e., Texas). The X-factor for me is Lawrence Hill, a swingman who can look really good on some occasions and pretty weak on others. Keep in mind, though, Stanford is a hard-nosed team. You have to be tough to win at Washington State and Arizona.

On Rivals.com Terrelle Pryor is the 28th-ranked recruit ... in basketball! Does he plan to play both football and basketball in college?
--
Nick Sloan Washington, D.C.

Nope. Pryor has said that for now he has no plans to play basketball in college.

Last week you wrote: "But I do think it's a sign of the Pac-10's depth that a team near the bottom of the league standings can take down a national-title contender" when talking about UCLA's loss to Washington. But it seems when a Big Ten team like Michigan State loses to Iowa or Penn State the Spartans are automatically "overrated" and the Big Ten is "down"? I'm not accusing you of that by any means, but that seems to be the national perspective.
--
Chris Mackinder

First, let's be clear: I haven't called Michigan State "overrated." But I was actually talking about the very topic of your question with Spartans coach Tom Izzo the other night in Bloomington. Izzo was lamenting the Big Ten's performance in the ACC-Big Ten Challenge last fall, noting that it set a tone for the negative evaluations of the Big Ten that the conference has yet to escape. Izzo's point was that the Big Ten has a solid record of performance in recent years when it counts (read: the NCAA tournament) and that in three of his four Final Four appearances (1999, 2000, 2001, 2005) there has been another Big Ten team involved.

Ultimately, I think your question comes down less to what people think about the Pac-10 or the Big Ten than what they think of Washington, Penn State and Iowa. Although Washington has had a disappointing season (by its recent standards), you could certainly argue that U-Dub is one of the nation's top 65 teams (even though an NCAA at-large bid seems out of reach). You couldn't make that argument about Iowa or Penn State.

Last week you may recall that a reader cited Kansas' recent win over Baylor, in which the Jayhawks cracked triple-digits but failed to make a single three-pointer, and asked when was the last time that happened. Thankfully, one of our 'Bag Hall of Fame members looked into it:

Last year Eastern Washington scored 100 with no three-pointers (0-5) against Sacramento State. The box score is here.
--
Charlie Hart, Noblesville, Ind.

Which college coach would you want your son to play for in the following situations: One, your son is a one-and-done lottery pick. Two, your son is a good player but won't make the league without a great college career. Finally, your son is a walk-on who will never see significant minutes.
--
Brendan Murtha, San Jose, Calif.

Intriguing question, Brendan. The 'Bag doesn't have any kids, but we'll play hypothetical on this one. If my son was a likely one-and-done, I'd want him to play for a coach who commands respect, who preaches (and teaches) defense, who demands that his players value time management in a way that prepares them for the NBA. To me, nobody does those things better than North Carolina's Roy Williams, Duke's Mike Krzyzewski, UCLA's Ben Howland and Ohio State's Thad Matta (who has more recent experience with one-and-dones than anybody).

If my son is a good player who won't make the NBA without a great college career, I'd be looking for coaches who are the best at player development. I'm not going to repeat names from the first group, but coaches that come to mind here are Texas' Rick Barnes, Louisville's Rick Pitino, Michigan State's Tom Izzo, Gonzaga's Mark Few, UConn's Jim Calhoun and Georgetown's John Thompson III.

Lastly, if my son were a walk-on who'd never see significant minutes, I'd tell him to choose a school for reasons other than basketball. But if we're limiting this to hoops, I'd want him to be at a college with a rich basketball tradition, like North Carolina or Kansas or Kentucky or Indiana. You could list several schools here and wouldn't go wrong.

Continue
2 of 3

Search