Get the Blackhawks Championship Package  Give the Gift of SI Home
Posted: Thursday June 18, 2009 11:54AM; Updated: Thursday June 18, 2009 4:44PM

Romo Roundtable: What will it take for Cowboys to reach next level?

Story Highlights

Jason Garrett recently suggested Tony Romo needed to be in better shape

Coaching staff as much at fault for Cowboys' struggles as any player

A meaningful win late in the season or playoffs would help Romo's psyche

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Tony Romo is 27-12 in three seasons as a starting quarterback, but 0-2 in the playoffs.

Tony Romo recently was back in the news when Cowboys offensive coordinator Jason Garrett suggested the star quarterback was "bottom-heavy" and needed to report to training camp in better shape (which, predictably, Romo says the media blew out of proportion). Will that be the difference-maker for Romo and the Cowboys, who haven't won a playoff game this decade? If not, what is it going to take for Romo to lead the Cowboys to the next level? NFL writers Don Banks, Jim Trotter, John Mullin, Ross Tucker and Andrew Perloff discuss.

• DON BANKS: I'm really not entirely sure what being called "bottom-heavy'' implies for an NFL quarterback, but the way I figure it, Romo's upper torso can't help but be a little lighter this season, given that he won't have Terrell Owens on his back at all times.

Now that we've gotten our gratuitous shot at T.O. and his chemistry-killing karma out of the way, let's delve into the question of whether Romo is just a successful conditioning program away from taking the Cowboys to the next level, as Garrett seemed to suggest recently. (Our working title: "Was Romo rebuilt in a day?'')

While the idea of a lighter Romo automatically translating into a better Romo late in the season sounds like a winning formula, my gut tells me that's over-simplifying the problem of Dallas's near-annual December swoons. To be sure, Romo's play has suffered late in each of his three seasons as the Cowboys' starter, but that's not the whole story of why Dallas is still seeking its first playoff win since the opening round of the 1996 postseason.

In the NFL, you're generally only as good as your starting quarterback. But to lay all the blame for the Cowboys' recent disintegrations on Romo's shoulders is to overlook quite a bit of team-wide failure.

Dallas' defense has melted down at key times -- see last season's galling 44-6 Week 17 loss at Philadelphia, which kept the Cowboys out of the playoffs and put in the Eagles. And the performance of Dallas coaches has been less than stellar, too, as the likes of Bill Parcells, Wade Phillips and Garrett himself have deservedly drawn some of the blame for being unable to end the franchise's string of losing every regular-season finale since 1999.

Improved conditioning might well help Romo end the season stronger than he has the past three years. But learning how to win in the clutch hasn't been solely the problem of the Cowboys' quarterback of late. It's a team game, and from owner Jerry Jones down, Dallas's pattern of defeat and disappointment in December clearly has been a team-wide effort.


• JIM TROTTER: Romo's problem isn't below the waist; it's between the ears. He hasn't been the same in late-season, high-pressure situations since he botched the hold in the playoff loss at Seattle three seasons ago. During make-or-break moments, I see uncertainty instead of defiance. That's not what I want from my quarterback. I want a guy who says failure is not an option, a guy who isn't afraid to demand accountability from his teammates as well as himself.

As for Garrett, he should look in the mirror if he wants to find one of the culprits in the Cowboys' late-season struggles. Some staff members have complained for years that his playcalling is too predictable in December and January. Don't know if that's true, but the fact that colleagues would make such a statement is reason for concern. Garrett's suggestion that Romo's problem is that he's "bottom-heavy" sounds a lot like a coach who is unprepared to consider more plausible explanations for the team's problems: that the QB appears to be psychologically fragile and the play-caller might be professionally stubborn.

• JOHN MULLIN: If there is a less significant issue facing the 2009 Dallas Cowboys than the southern half of Romo...

Garrett observing that Romo appears a little "bottom heavy" says more about Garrett than Romo. A core component of coaches' guiding principles is to put their players in the best positions to succeed. How Garrett figures that adding to public pressure and scrutiny to a linchpin player, who's had too much of both already in his short career, puts Romo in an improved position for success is beyond mysterious. All he has done is load a round into the chambers of critics who already have more than sufficient ammunition primed for Romo.

Romo, in three seasons as the Dallas starter, has never posted a passer rating lower than 91 or been sacked more than 24 times, meaning he has pocket savvy and knows what to do with the extra time his innate athleticism buys him. And of the two, pocket presence is more important than mobility; see also: Marino, Dan; Roethlisberger, Ben; Jurgenson, Sonny.

1 2
Hot Topics: Sammy Watkins NFL Draft Rick Adelman NFL Questions Aaron Hernandez Donald Trump
TM & © 2013 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint