Get the Blackhawks Championship Package  Give the Gift of SI
SI.com Home
2000s: The Decade in Sports
Posted: Monday December 14, 2009 11:14AM; Updated: Monday December 14, 2009 11:16AM

NHL: Highlights and lowlights

Story Highlights

Defenseman Nicklas Lidstrom kept shining even as the NHL emphasized scoring

The Red Wings' organization-wide excellence made them the NHL's best franchise

Alexander Ovechkin's highlight reel goal of January 2006 was beyond dazzling

By Michael Farber, SI.com

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
nicklas-lidstrom.jpg
Nicklas Lidstrom's six Norris Trophies this decade left him behind only Hall of Famers Doug Harvey (7) and Bobby Orr (8).
Graig Abel/NHLI vis Getty Images
2000s: NHL
ARTICLES
Farber: Highlights and lowlights
Farber: All-Decade team
Muir: 10 signature moments
Muir: Trades, free agency and the draft
GALLERIES
 

PLAYER OF THE DECADE: Nicklas Lidstrom, Red Wings
He's a man for his era, a defenseman who is practically perfect in every way. With post-lockout rule changes making the off-the-glass, crease-clearing blueline behemoth practically obsolete, the ability to play positional hockey and move the puck became paramount. Lidstrom, a Swede, was the most accomplished at the refined art, winning six Norris Trophies in the decade and becoming the first European to captain a Stanley Cup champion.

BEST COACH: Mike Babcock, Ducks and Red Wings
Canada's 2010 Olympic coach took teams to three Stanley Cup Finals, winning with Detroit in 2008 and losing Game 7s with the middling Ducks in 2003 and the defending champion Red Wings last June. Babcock is relentless and fanatical about details, figuring if the small stuff is perfect, the big picture will take care of itself. He knows the game and -- as important -- the makeup of his teams and character of his players as well as any coach in the post-expansion era.

BEST GM: Ken Holland, Red Wings
Without the gaudy top draft picks that have helped turn teams into champions - Pittsburgh is Exhibit A -- the Red Wings under Holland simply go about their annual exercise of excellence. The result: Stanley Cups in 2002 and 2008 and a trip to the 2009 final. Holland has had fewer salary-cap problems than the estimable Lou Lamoriello of New Jersey, demonstrating a remarkable ability to navigate his franchise no matter what the economic system. Of course, Holland has the NHL's best support group, which included Scotty Bowman (until he left for Chicago in 2008) and still boasts assistant GM Jim Nill and European scouting director Hakan Andersson.

Click here for Michael Farber's complete All-Decade team

BEST FRANCHISE: Red Wings
Sure, they won two Cups and an NHL-best 15 playoff rounds during the decade, but the following explains why the Red Wings are the franchise of the 2000s: Hakan Andersson, their eyes in Europe, suggested that Holland select a lanky center from Sweden named Jonathan Ericsson with the 291st, and last, pick of the 2002 draft. After the draft, Andersson went to Ericsson's coach and told him he would be better off putting the lanky kid on defense. Ericsson is now in Detroit's top six, a defenseman with star potential.

WORST FRANCHISE: Thrashers
Sorry to pick on them, but they edge the Blue Jackets for this dubious on-ice distinction. Both made the playoffs once in the decade. Both were swept in four games, mostly because you can't be eliminated in three. The difference is that Atlanta goalie Kari Lehtonen colored his hair a Thrashers shade of blue to help, ahem, inspire the team. (So much for dyeing and going to heaven.) The Jackets look like they have a firmer foundation heading into the next decade than Atlanta, which, if it can't re-sign potential unrestricted free agent Ilya Kovalchuk, might as well padlock Philips Arena. (Off the ice, of course, the bankrupt Phoenix Coyotes, currently wards of the league, are the runaway winner.)

BEST SINGLE-SEASON TEAM: 2001-02 Red Wings
Their fourth line in the 2002 Stanley Cup finals featured Igor Larionov centering Luc Robitaille and Tomas Holmstrom. Larionov and Robitaille are now in the Hall of Fame. (Holmstrom will also be going if the Hall establishes a wing for players who set up shop on the edge of the crease during power plays and talk trash.) While Detroit's 116 regular-season points fell two shy of Colorado's team of all-stars the previous year, the Wings' credentials were impeccable. Robitaille and Larionov represent just a sliver of slam-dunk Hall of Famers on that team, which included Steve Yzerman and Brett Hull (already enshrined), Dominik Hasek, Chris Chelios, Brendan Shanahan, Lidstrom and Sergei Fedorov.

WORST SINGLE-SEASON TEAM: 1999-00 Thrashers
Like molten lava from a volcano, the natural disaster of the expansion Thrashers started in one decade and ran downhill into the next. This 14-win team would make anybody want to spew. The estimable Ray Ferraro, a respected forward, was minus-33 that season, which didn't even win the green jacket on the team. (Yannick Tremblay was 45 under.) GM Don Waddell made a grave miscalculation by choosing Damian Rhodes to be his No. 1 goalie. Rhodes was emotionally and temperamentally unsuited to face the amount of rubber that is the lot of all expansion-team goalies.

MOST DRAMATIC REGULAR-SEASON GAMES: Maple Leafs-Canadiens; April 7, 2007; Islanders-Devils; April 8, 2007
This is a two-fer, a pair of games that were as inelegant as they were riveting. On the ultimate Saturday night of the season, in an emotional match between two heritage franchises, the Maple Leafs rallied to defeat Montreal 6-5 and eliminate the Canadiens from the final Eastern Conference playoff spot. To earn that last berth, all the Maple Leafs needed the following day was a New Jersey win over a team that was missing injured goalie Rick DiPietro. In the 17th game of his NHL career, Islanders third-stringer Wade Dubielewicz, a stumpy, balding Everyman, beat the Devils 3-2 in a shootout, knocking out the Leafs and giving New York the eighth spot. Woe, Canada.

BEST POSTSEASON GAME: Flyers-Penguins; May 4-5, 2000
Surely length matters -- and Game 4 of Eastern Conference semifinals took precisely seven hours from the time the first puck was dropped. But it was the delightful manner in which Flyers forward Keith Primeau ended this titanic five-overtime match between intrastate rivals that makes it a keeper in the hard drive of memory. With the score 1-1 and the players almost in a trance-like state from exhaustion, Primeau drove down the right wing, went backhand to forehand to beat a defender and fired a shot over the shoulder of Penguins goalie Ron Tugnutt, ending the match after 92:01 of extra play -- more than an additional game and a half.

Click here for a gallery of our top 10 games of the decade

BIGGEST TRADE: Joe Thornton from the Bruins to the Sharks for Brad Stuart, Marco Sturm and Wayne Primeau; Nov. 30, 2005
Although it lacked the emotional pull of the other big Bruins trade -- Raymond Bourque shipped to Colorado in 2000, where he would win his only Stanley Cup a year later -- Jumbo Joe's deal was Brobdingnagian. This was a classic case of buyer's remorse. Three months earlier, the Bruins had signed Thornton to a three-year, $20 million contract. But with the memories of the 2004 playoffs still fresh (playing with injured ribs, he had no points in seven games in a first-round loss to Montreal), Boston shockingly dumped its captain. Thornton wound up with 92 points in 53 games after going to San Jose, winning the Hart Trophy.

BEST FREE-AGENT SIGNING: Scott Niedermayer, Ducks; Aug. 5, 2005
Brian Burke, whose bombast occasionally camouflages his wiles, is among the most prescient of GMs. He desperately wanted the slick Niedermayer, who had played his entire career with New Jersey. What could Burke offer the free-agent defenseman, other than money? Unlike 29 other teams, he could give Niedermayer the chance to play with his own brother, Rob, a sturdy winger. Following the lockout, Burke got his man, for four years at $27 million. Anaheim won the Cup in 2007 with Scott capturing the Conn Smythe Trophy. (Rob played a critical role on the shutdown line with Sami Pahlsson and Travis Moen.)

WORST FREE-AGENT SIGNING: Wade Redden, Rangers; July 1, 2008
The Blackhawks have multiple entries -- defenseman Brian Campbell, goalie Cristobal Huet, etc. -- but the Rangers edge them in this dubious area. Prior to the salary-cap era, there could not be a "worst" free agent because no matter how ill-advised the signing -- think Bobby Holik's $45 million deal with the Rangers in 2002 -- wealthy teams could bury mistakes. Now a toxic contract is the gift that keeps on giving, and Redden's six-year, $39 million deal in 2008 was Chernobyl. Although his play had dipped noticeably while he was in Ottawa, the Rangers still bestowed riches upon him. Unless coach John Tortorella can extract more than the faint glimmer of life that Redden showed in the 2009 playoffs, this will weigh heavily on the team (and GM Glen Sather's curriculum vitae) for another four-plus seasons.

henrik-lundqvist.jpg
Henrik Lundqvist has looked sharp on and off the ice since the Rangers drafted him in 2000.

BIGGEST DRAFT STEAL: Henrik Lundqvist, seventh-round pick (205th overall), by the Rangers in 2000
Notable players have been chosen lower -- 2009 Game 7 Stanley Cup hero Max Talbot by Pittsburgh at No. 234 in 2002; first-pair Islanders defenseman Mark Streit at No. 262 by Montreal in 2004 -- but there was no better late pick than Lundqvist. Generally teams don't find a No. 1 goalie deep in the draft, but New York got one who is now among the best five in the NHL. The King backstopped Sweden to the 2006 Olympic gold medal. He was also included in a People magazine list of the 100 Most Beautiful, although shockingly, his identical twin -- Stars defenseman Joel Lundqvist, picked 68th overall by Dallas the same year -- was not. (Bet that got Joel's zygote.)

BIGGEST DRAFT BUSTS: Alexander Svitov, third overall pick by Lightning in 2001; Stanislav Chistov, fifth overall pick by Ducks in 2001
They go as an entry, these two not-so-Wizards of Ovs. Not that 2001 necessarily was a lights-out draft -- the Kings, at No. 18, probably would like a do-over on Jens Karlsson -- but this pair of feckless Russians was an utter disaster for two scuffling franchises. Svitov had 13 goals in 179 NHL games while Chistov scored 19 in 196. At least Tampa Bay was able to wheel Svitov to Columbus for veteran defenseman Darryl Sydor, who would play on the their 2004 Cup winner. Svitov and Chistov both currently haunt the KHL in Russia.

Click here for Allan Muir's views on the decade in trades, free agency and the draft

CINDERELLA: Martin St. Louis, 2003-04
He's officially listed as 5-foot-9 but is maybe 5-6 -- short enough that when he met his future wife at the University of Vermont, she felt obliged to wear flats. (If this is a Cinderella story, it must involve shoes, no?) St. Louis was undrafted out of Vermont and spent the 1997-98 season in the IHL and AHL before joining the Calgary Flames as a free agent and scoring four goals in 69 games over two seasons. Tampa Bay signed him as a free agent in 2000. Four years later, St. Louis would lead the NHL in assists and points and win the Hart and Lester B. Pearson MVP trophies for the Stanley Cup champions.

1 2
ADVERTISEMENT
YES, I WILL TAKE THE SURVEY

MAYBE LATER

NO THANKS
SI.com
Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs Golden State Warriors Bryce Harper Paul Pierce Masai Ujiri
TM & © 2013 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint