Get SI's Duke Championship Package Free  Subscribe to SI Give the Gift of SI
Posted: Saturday October 17, 2009 4:33PM; Updated: Saturday October 17, 2009 5:10PM
Andy Staples Andy Staples >

Ohio State must figure out how to utilize Pryor's athletic gifts

Story Highlights

This spring, it looked like Terrelle Pryor was ready to take it to the next level

In an upset loss to Purdue today, it was again clear that he hasn't done that

Ohio State must stop forcing Pryor to be something he's not and use his gifts

Purdue (7) Ohio State


Ohio State QB Terrelle Pryor turned the ball over four times and was sacked five times against Purdue.
Ohio State QB Terrelle Pryor turned the ball over four times and was sacked five times against Purdue.

Perhaps it's fitting Ohio State quarterback Terrelle Pryor wrote Michael Vick's name on his eye black earlier this season. Saturday's 26-18 loss to Purdue proved again that, from a strictly football perspective, Pryor and Vick appear to be the same person -- phenomenal athletes who can't control the cannons attached to their shoulders well enough to be effective starting quarterbacks at their given levels.

I realize I'm the same person who wrote after the Ohio State spring game that Pryor was ready to utilize his gifts. Seven games in, I'm willing to admit I was wrong. Against Purdue, a team that probably doesn't have a single player who received a scholarship offer from Ohio State, Pryor completed 17-of-31 passes for 221 yards and a touchdown that came when a Hail Mary landed in DeVier Posey's hands after two Purdue defenders ran into one another. Pryor also threw two interceptions, fumbled three times (two of which were lost) and took five sacks.

Of course, we shouldn't heap all the blame on Pryor. After Ohio State lost to USC in Week 2, Smart Football's Chris Brown wrote a devastating critique of the Buckeyes' offense. Brown's sentiments still ring true. Even though Pryor has his limitations, he's usually the best athlete on the field. Unfortunately, that knowledge hasn't stopped Ohio State coach Jim Tressel from treating Pryor like any other quarterback on a lot of plays.

Ohio State's best play Saturday may have been the two-point conversion after the Posey touchdown. Pryor bootlegged and simply outran the Boilermakers to the pylon. Given the talent gap between the two teams, it stands to reason Ohio State could have dialed up similar plays quite a bit more throughout the game and come away with more than 13 first downs. But as long as Tressel insists on turning Pryor into Craig Krenzel, the offense will suffer.

I wonder if Pryor regrets turning down Rich Rodriguez to go to Columbus. In Rodriguez's offense at Michigan, Pryor would average close to 100 yards a game running zone-read plays. He would be asked to make short, controlled throws that have no chance of being intercepted. Every once in a while, he'd be allowed to uncork a deep ball, but the defense would be so worried about him running that it might fall asleep and allow him to hit an open receiver.

With the exception of Cincinnati coach Brian Kelly, who -- gasp -- changed his entire offensive philosophy during a 15-minute halftime to suit his backup quarterback's skill set in a win Thursday at South Florida, most big-time coaches seem averse to building a scheme around the particular talents of their players.

Pryor may not be the ideal quarterback, but he's still more talented than 99 percent of the players in America. Ohio State coaches need to stop trying to force him to be something he's not and embrace what he is. If they do that, they'll find their jobs, and Ohio State's games, a lot easier.

College Football Week 7
National TV Schedule | Complete Scoreboard | College Football Pick'Em
vs. Andy Staples:
After USC's thrilling win over ND, state of both programs hard to define
vs. Cory McCartney:
Yellow Jackets extend Hokies' Atlanta curse, open door in chaotic ACC
vs. Stewart Mandel:
Red River wasn't pretty, but Texas still controls its BCS destiny
George Schroeder:
Questions linger, but Tim Tebow and Gators survive big scare
vs. George Schroeder:
After big road win, it's time to jump on Hawkeyes bandwagon
Andy Staples:
In upset loss, Ohio State again fails to utilize Pryor's gifts
vs. Andy Staples:
No Pike? No problem. Backup QB Collaros keeps Cincinnati humming
Heisman Award:
Video Film Room | All-Time Greatest Moments | Sweepstakes

Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs Chris Johnson Jameis Winston NFL Draft Michael Sam Aldon Smith
TM & © 2013 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint