Get SI's Duke Championship Package Free  Subscribe to SI Give the Gift of SI
Posted: Wednesday April 1, 2009 1:56PM; Updated: Thursday April 2, 2009 1:17PM
Don Banks Don Banks >

In sizable Cutler market, these 12 teams have highest motivation

Story Highlights

About a third of the NFL's 32 teams could use a quarterback of Jay Cutler's caliber

These 12 teams will be most motivated to deal based on need, available players

Jets have the most incentive to land Cutler, but may need to bring in a third team

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Given the shortage of top-tier quarterbacking in the NFL, plenty of teams will attempt to land Cutler even after his theatrics.
Given the shortage of top-tier quarterbacking talent in the NFL, plenty of teams will attempt to land Cutler, even after his theatrics.
Peter Read Miller/SI
Don Banks's Mailbag
Submit a comment or question to Don Banks.

It's a pity Broncos owner Pat Bowlen didn't delay announcing the team's intention to trade Jay Cutler just a few more hours Tuesday night, because I've never heard of a story that deserves to receive the April Fool's Day treatment more than this one. The Cutler versus the Broncos saga has been a bad joke from Day 1.

Now that the marriage is officially over and divorce inevitable, divining just where the talented but over-sensitive 25-year-old quarterback will land has become America's hottest new sports craze. Not surprisingly, given the dearth of top-tier quarterbacking in the NFL, numerous suitors will line up for Cutler. About one-third of the 32-team league could use him.

But buyer beware. In the past month-plus, Cutler has displayed the immaturity that might have made new Broncos head coach Josh McDaniels a bit wary of him in the first place, and whoever acquires him now does so realizing he is capable of initiating a full-scale public hissy fit under the right set of circumstances (i.e., when his team does not properly account for his ego).

While many teams have been mentioned as potential trade partners with Denver, here are the clubs I think will be most motivated to pursue Cutler in the coming days, either out of need for a quarterback or because of what they have on hand to trade. This is not the same as handicapping his likely landing spots or the teams best positioned to deal for him. This is about discerning the clubs that have the greatest incentive to make such a move:

1. New York Jets

Rex Ryan's made it clear he's confident in his quarterback depth chart (what else could he say?), but despite that, the Jets face going to camp with Kellen Clemens, Brett Ratliff and Erik Ainge as their starting options. 'Nuff said. The problem is, the Jets don't have a quarterback to trade that Denver will likely view as a starting option. That's why a three-way deal with Cleveland (the Browns would move either Brady Quinn or Derek Anderson to the Broncos) may be the Jets' best hope. Yep, that would mean Eric Mangini doing Woody Johnson and Mike Tannenbaum a favor. What are the odds on that one?

Motivation meter: 9.7 (on a scale of 10)

2. Tampa Bay

The Bucs are in a similar situation to the Jets, with only Luke McCown, Brian Griese and Josh Johnson at quarterback. We know they want Cutler because they wanted him a month ago. The Bucs have never been shy about shipping away first-round picks, giving up two No. 1s and two No. 2s for Jon Gruden in 2002, and two No. 1s for Keyshawn Johnson in 2000. So their No. 19 pick this year is likely a given in any deal, but after that, I'd be very careful if I were the Bucs. If the price tag for Cutler ends up being this year's No. 1 and next year's No. 1, that's too steep. It took Tampa Bay a long time to overcome the loss of so many valuable picks after the Gruden deal, and they'd be wise to not re-dig that hole.

Motivation meter: 9.0

3. Cleveland

The Browns aren't desperate for a quarterback, given they've got two starters in Quinn and Anderson. But new head coach Mangini doesn't seem to be crazy about either one of them, and that makes the Browns a player in the Cutler sweepstakes if they want to be. Moving Quinn, who hasn't proven anything yet, and disgruntled defensive tackle Shaun Rogers must look pretty appealing to the Browns about now.

Motivation meter: 8.5

4. Detroit

More than anyone in this year's draft, the Lions have the ammo to come after Cutler, as they own the No. 1, No. 20 and No. 33 picks and five of the top 82 overall. New Lions head coach Jim Schwartz has made ending the team's decades-long nightmare at quarterback a top priority, but I still get the sense he doesn't love his options at that position in this year's draft. Schwartz may be a bit wary of Cutler after seeing the way this melodrama has played out the past five weeks, and if so, he should just stand pat and see what unfolds in the draft. But Detroit could exponentially quicken the pace of its rebuilding program with a proven quarterback in hand, and that might make Cutler irresistible.

Motivation meter: 7.5

1 2
Hot Topics: NBA Draft Yasiel Puig NHL Playoffs NBA Playoffs Mark Cuban Jabari Parker
TM & © 2013 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint