Preseason perceptions (cont.)

Shaun Hill threw for 209 yards and a touchdown in the Niners' win over the Cards. Getty Images Don Banks's Mailbag Submit a comment or question to Don Banks. Name: Email: Hometown: Question: SEND Follow Don Banks on Twitter

• They are no gimmes in Arizona. In the past two seasons under Ken Whisenhunt, the Cardinals have gone 14-4 at home and 9-3 in the NFC West, convincing some that those two pillars of dominance afforded them a clear-cut advantage over the rest of the division for the foreseeable future.

But that argument took a hit Sunday when San Francisco laid a 20-16 defeat on the Cardinals in Glendale, puncturing Arizona's air of invincibility at home and in the NFC West. And given the Cardinals don't host another division opponent until a Week 10 visit from Seattle, that's a perception they won't be able to pump back up right away.

• The Dolphins play the smart-ball that Tony Sparano demands. We have crafted an image of the Dolphins as a heady and resourceful team that knows how to take care of the football and doesn't beat itself. Miami turned the ball over just 13 times last season, tying an NFL record for fewest in a regular season. So naturally the Fish go out and cough it up four times in their 19-7 loss at Atlanta in Week 1 (three fumbles and one interception), proving, as Titans head coach Jeff Fisher likes to say, that you can't escrow any previous success in the NFL. You've got to prove everything anew each and every year.

I've made this point before, but Miami has a much tougher schedule this time around than it did in its Cinderella season of 2008, and that's why improving on its surprising 11-5 record of last year seems out of the question. With a Monday nighter at home against the Colts and a trip to San Diego waiting in Week 3, the Dolphins could be staring at a deflating 0-3 start if they don't start reverting to last season's form on the turnover front.

• It's actually way past time to put to rest the idea that the Steelers are a great running team. The truth is they're not even a good one. Pittsburgh's 105.6 rushing yards per game ranked a middling 23rd last season, and the Steelers won that sixth Super Bowl ring on the strength of Ben Roethlisberger's right arm and their defense.

So why were we all that shocked last Thursday night when the Steelers beat Tennessee 13-10 in overtime despite running for just 36 yards on 23 carries (1.6 average) with one first down on the ground? It's Roethlisberger's team now, and he might have plenty more games this season where it's necessary for him to complete 33 of 43 for 363 yards for Pittsburgh to win.

• Familiarity isn't breeding success just yet in Washington. The notion that Jason Campbell would be markedly better this season because he's finally getting the chance to play in the same offense for a second consecutive season got a lot of play this summer. How's that one going so far? Not so good, if you're a Redskins fan.

Campbell looked a lot like Campbell in that 23-17, not-as-close-as-it-sounds loss to the Giants opening day. He was good in spots, and a bit shaky in spots, but never really put Washington into position to win the game. I wish I could say the Redskins can put this Genie back into the bottle in regards to Campbell and their obvious lack of confidence in him, but I just don't see it happening.

• Other quick-hit perceptions that got either disproved or re-enforced in Week 1 include:

-- The Lions defense, with all those veteran leaders now on hand, is noticeably improved. Not against the Saints in the Superdome on Sunday. Any way you cut it, giving up 45 points, 515 yards of offense, and 28 first downs is not a step forward.

-- The Dallas passing game is going to miss Terrell Owens' big-play ability. Not yet. The Cowboys were a veritable big play depot against the Bucs, with scoring passes of 42, 66 and 80 yards from Tony Romo to three Dallas receivers.

-- San Francisco quarterback Shaun Hill beat out Alex Smith and retained his starting job because all he does is win games. Can't really quibble with that premise after the 49ers upset at Arizona. Hill is now 8-3 when he opens a game for San Francisco since arriving in 2007. That's roughly the same amount of wins owned by all other 49ers quarterbacks combined since Jeff Garcia left town.

-- The Packers re-built offensive line, with its goal of getting bigger and more physically imposing, will be a big plus for Green Bay. It wasn't Sunday night against the faster, quicker Bears defensive front. New right tackle Allen Barbre got beat like a mule off the edge by Chicago defensive ends Adewale Ogunleye and Mark Anderson. There's no way the Packers' Super Bowl hopes can survive if quarterback Aaron Rodgers is getting sacked four times a game, and hit six more. Green Bay has to get that issue fixed right now.

****

Here are more observations about Week 1....

• As it turns out, Richard Seymour was definitely worth waiting for in Oakland. The ex-Patriots defensive lineman was a force at times against the Chargers Monday night, and just his presence in the lineup seemed to give the Raiders defense a much-needed dose of attitude, physicality and a bit of that old Oakland swagger. And his two sacks didn't hurt a bit.

• It's beyond belief that Leodis McKelvin can actually defend his decision to bring that game-changing kickoff out of the Buffalo end zone at New England, claiming he didn't know exactly where he was in relation to the goal line. With the game on the line, it's his job to know. It's also inexcusable that having not taken a knee in the end zone, he kept fighting for a meaningless extra yard once he had been wrapped up by Patriots defenders who had but one goal in mind: To stand him up and strip him of the ball.

"I chose to bring it out because that's me, no matter what it is,'' McKelvin was quoted as saying. "If I had that choice, probably 100 times, I'd do it again.''

That's just you, huh, Leodis? Perfect. One guy single-handedly ruins the winning effort put forth by his other 45 teammates in what would have been a huge upset, and all he can say for himself is it's about his individuality. You want to be an individual, go play golf or tennis, where it's all on you, win or lose. In football, it's not all about you. And when the game was in his hands, McKelvin dropped the ball in so many different ways.

• The Patriots pulled it out, and so all is well in the end, I guess. But in the first game of the post-Pioli, post-McDaniels, post-Bruschi, post-Vrabel, post-Harrison, post-Seymour era in New England, I wouldn't say things went smoothly. Would you?

• From my vantage point, JaMarcus Russell still looks just good enough to get you beat.

• Some mind-numbingly questionable calls in the Monday night double dip. The Louis Murphy touchdown catch being overturned by replay in Oakland, the Vince Wilfork quarterback hit in New England, and the Adalius Thomas quarterback wrap-up-and-sling job against the Bills were all dubious in my book. But I did love those creamsicle-colored AFL referee throwbacks.

Seriously, Murphy did everything but count three Mississippi's out loud after catching that ball, and I, as well as all three announcers in the Monday Night Football booth, thought there wasn't a chance in the world it would be reversed by replay. The naked eye told you he had it long enough, and sometimes you've got to stop splitting these hairs on what constitutes a catch. It's the old John Madden line about if three guys in a bar all think it's a catch, it's a catch.

As for the two roughing the passer calls against Wilfork and Thomas, for me both of them fall under the heading of how the over-protection instincts of the league towards quarterbacks has become a case of good intentions gone overboard. True, Thomas brought some level of violence to his sack of Trent Edwards, but, and this is critical, it looked worse than it actually was because Thomas let up slightly just before he finished slinging the Bills quarterback to the turf. It's football, folks. Hitting the quarterback hard has to be a part of the game.

• Speaking of the 50th anniversary AFL uniforms that were on display Monday night, a shaky Tom Brady in the first half looked more like Tony Eason in the Pats old unis. I kept thinking he'd play better if he had the Flying Elvis logos back on his helmet.

• Did you notice it took a guy named Brett to save the Packers once again the other night at Lambeau? If receiver Brett Swain doesn't stay home and do his job on that inexplicable fake punt call by the Bears in the fourth quarter, tackling Garrett Wolfe after a four-yard gain, Wolfe would have rumbled for a huge first down.

• Speaking of Favre, I did applaud him for getting with the program in Minnesota and being content to hand off to Adrian Peterson in the Vikings win at Cleveland. But seriously, why pay a guy $12 million for throwing for 110 yards and managing the game? Couldn't Sage Rosenfels be doing that for a heck of a lot less money and fanfare?

• There was precious little buzz generated by the draft's three first-round running backs in Week 1. Denver's Knowshon Moreno gained 19 yards on eight carries in a win at Cincinnati. Indy's Donald Brown had 33 yards rushing on 11 attempts. And Arizona's Beanie Wells gained just 29 yards on seven runs.

Maybe the breakouts are coming in Week 2.