Phillies' Manuel keeps everyone guessing with pitching alignment

Charlie Manuel used seven of his eight starting pitchers in the first two games of the NLDS. AP Jon Heyman's Mailbag Got a question or comment for Jon? Name: Email: Hometown: Question: SEND Follow Jon Heyman on Twitter

PHILADELPHIA -- Some say the playoffs are a crapshoot. But what's really a crapshoot these days is Charlie Manuel's pitching alignment.

After Pedro Martinez became the only one of seven Phillies starting pitchers on their playoff roster to remain inactive though Game 2, the Great Pedro opined that he believes he's getting the Game 3 start in Colorado. And why the heck not?

Manuel has managed to use every other starter so far, from ace Cliff Lee to Cole Hamels to Joe Blanton to J.A. Happ to even Antonio Bastardo to Brett Myers and back to Lee again (the multitalented Lee pinch ran Game 2 while the others all pitched in that one game). Manuel certainly appears to be saving the Cooperstown-bound Martinez for something, and it's not a bronzing.

It's a guessing game only Pedro's willing to play so far. The manager himself only suggested it's down to Blanton and Martinez to start in the cold and snow of Colorado after third candidate Happ took a liner off his lower left leg in Game 2 Thursday. Everybody threw in their two cents, though no one was as definitive as the cagey Pedro.

Blanton told reporters he could go, not that he expected to, after throwing 19 pitches Thursday in the Phillies' 5-4 Game 2 loss to the Rockies. And actually so did Happ, who made a special trip to Manuel's office to plead the case that his leg is fine after Manuel noticed it "shake" in warmup tosses following the incident.)

But unlike the veteran Pedro, the others are making no assumptions. And really, why should anyone think they can guess along with Manuel? Beyond the calls to go with Lee to start Game 1 and Hamels to start Game 2, which even surprised folks here (some assumed he'd go with 2008 World Series MVP Hamels), Manuel thus far seems like he's pulling names out of a hat.

Blanton was the early favorite for Game 3, but then he appeared in relief in Game 2. And Happ seemed to be the next most logical candidate, but he too entered the game, only to exit it moments later, after being drilled just below the kneecap.

If the Phillies' rotation is a mystery, their closing situation is a horror show. As for that question, Manuel has basically thrown up his hands. "What the (blank) should I do?" Manuel has been known to ask folks who enter his office after 2008 savior Brad Lidge turned to dust.

In reality, Manuel has been managing like he wants to avoid most of his relievers, and not just the imploding closer Lidge. He managed Game 2 with a desperation to win, perhaps with thoughts of an ice-cold Coors Field to come (not to be confused with an ice-cold Coors). Frost is expected Saturday after a sunny day in Philadelphia on Thursday.

Temperatures in the 30s are expected Saturday. And the weather forecast is a lot more certain than Manuel's unusual pitching machinations.

In Game 2, the mad Manuel went with a succession of rotation guys. Blanton, Happ, Bastardo and Myers are all starters by trade, and Bastardo was pitching in the instructional league within the last week.

"I was making moves out there that if I could have picked some other things to do, I would have probably did it," Manuel said afterward.

Manuel got laughs, but not the victory.

Perhaps there's a method to his managerial madness, as he's keeping the Rockies guessing. Phillies people insist that Manuel wasn't withholding information in an effort to gain an advantage, and that he'll have an answer for Game 3 by today. But Rockies people, citing some playoff scuttlebutt, seemed to believe even before Thursday's game that Manuel would employ Pedro in Game 3.

Follow: @SI_JonHeyman | @SI_24Seven

That seemed illogical at the time since Happ's been arguably their best pitcher this year. Plus, Pedro isn't known as a cold-weather performer. "This is the summer pastime. We are the boys of summer," Pedro said while reminding us all that Boston can be cold. Even some Phillies people were reacting with shock upon hearing Manuel might use Pedro in the snow. But Manuel has his own plan.

Regardless, Pedro seems pretty sure it's him. Whether he has the same source as the Rockies, heard something more definitive from Manuel or is just guessing, he seemed pretty confident his time was coming.

"I've been in this game long enough to understand it's my spot," Pedro said.

If so, Pedro's practically the only one who understands what's going on.