Posted: Monday September 27, 2010 2:01PM ; Updated: Monday September 27, 2010 2:01PM
Allan Muir

Greatest NHL players by number

Story Highlights

I was asked to update a 2006 effort to choose the best players to wear 00 to 99

Tough choices forced me to leave out luminaries, especially in the case of No. 9

The one stipulation: I not choose a great player who wore a number only briefly

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
If only they were all this easy: One number and player it's hard to argue against.
Steve Babineau/Getty Images

I've got to hand it to the folks at Entertainment Weekly. No one understands as well as those rabble rousers that lists are the greatest form of irritainment known to man. Doesn't matter the subject. It could be TV's Greatest Next Door Neighbors or Freddy Krueger's Smartest Victims or Best Use of the Wilhelm Scream. If there's an order and one item is ranked above or below another (or, heaven forfend, overlooked entirely) then blood pressures will surge and emails questioning the lineage of the authors will start piling up faster than red ink in Phoenix.

So when my editor asked for my take on a solid, but slightly outdated 2006 effort by Brian Cazeneuve to list the greatest hockey players to wear each and every jersey number, I gladly stapled a bull's eye to my forehead and set to it. Hey, I've always enjoyed grabbing a stick and whacking the hornets' nest.

It comes as no surprise that there were plenty of difficult choices and omissions, as in the original ranking. One stipulation I was given: great players could not be shoehorned onto the list with a number they wore only briefly. Thus, no Joe Sakic at 88 -- his rookie number in Quebec (he reportedly took it to raise the ire of Eric Lindros, who had refused to play for the Nordiques) before switching to his more familiar 19 and crafting a superior career.

Terry Sawchuk, who set the career shutout mark of 103 (since broken by Martin Brodeur), still ranks as our No. 1, which brings no shame to the reputations of Georges Vezina, Johnny Bower, Glenn Hall, Turk Broda and Bernie Parent in the process. Apologies to Maurice Richard, Bobby Hull and Johnny Bucyk, but there's only one choice for No. 9. And even with multiple numbers to choose from, there was no room to honor multi-option legends like Andy Bathgate (9, 14), Howie Morenz (7, 12), Jean Beliveau (4, 12) and Tim Horton (2, 3, 7).

Did your favorites make the cut? See for yourself...but before you do, take a deep breath and remember: it's only a list.

GALLERY: Greatest NHL Players by Number
Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs Chris Johnson Jameis Winston NFL Draft Michael Sam Aldon Smith
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint