Get SI's Duke Championship Package Free  Subscribe to SI Give the Gift of SI
Posted: Thursday February 11, 2010 11:59AM; Updated: Friday February 12, 2010 11:39AM
Jim Trotter

Offseason burning questions: AFC

Story Highlights

Will the Patriots defense thrive with Bill Belichick calling the shots?

Will the Broncos finally part ways with wideout Brandon Marshall?

Derek Anderson or Brady Quinn? Browns need to settle on a QB

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Linebacker Jerod Mayo is a good foundation for the Patriots to rebuild their defense.

No sooner had the last flake of confetti fallen in Miami that next year's Super Bowl odds were posted. Not surprisingly, the Colts are the favorite to do what they couldn't achieve this season. Everybody of consequence returns for the Colts next season. Linebacker Gary Brackett is scheduled to be a unrestricted free agent and Antoine Bethea is a restricted free agent, but both are expected to return to Indianapolis. With that in mind, here's a look at the biggest questions that need answered this offseason among the AFC teams.



BUFFALO BILLS -- Can new coach Chan Gailey transform Trent Edwards or Ryan Fitzpatrick into a winning quarterback?

Gailey did it with Kordell Stewart in Pittsburgh, but he faces an equally challenging situation in Buffalo. Edwards has had injury and deep-ball issues, while Fitzpatrick has struggled with his accuracy. Both were on the minus side in touchdown-to-interception totals last year, and in eight seasons combined they've had only one year in which either finished with more TDs than INTs: Edwards (11-10) in 2008. The job becomes even tougher if the Bills don't re-sign Terrell Owens and fail to find a complement for Lee Evans.

*And another thing: If Gailey doesn't address the offensive line, it won't matter who takes the snaps. Buffalo never adequately replaced left tackle Jason Peters, who was traded to the Eagles before the season, and the Bills wound up allowing the fourth-most sacks in the league.

MIAMI DOLPHINS -- Can new defensive coordinator Mike Nolan work his magic again?

He did an exemplary job with a largely anonymous front seven in his only season in Denver, but he inherits an aging Miami defense that allowed a league-high 140 points in the fourth quarter -- and 390 points overall, third-most in the conference. Big plays were a problem. The Dolphins surrendered 15 touchdowns of at least 20 yards, more than double the seven they permitted in 2008. Among the other issues confronting them: nose tackle Jason Ferguson, who'll be 36 next season, missed the final seven games with a quadriceps injury; starting linebacker Joey Porter, who led the team with nine sacks, says he won't return in 2010; and No. 2 sacker Jason Taylor is an unrestricted free agent who is looking for a pay increase.

*And another thing: Miami needs a true No. 1 receiver, because Ted Ginn Jr. is not that guy. There have been reports the Dolphins are interested in Arizona veteran Anquan Boldin, a Florida native who would provide playmaking and toughness to the receiving corps. Bottom line: a league-low two TDs of 20 yards or longer on a team that has the No. 4 rushing attack is inexcusable.

NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS -- Will the Patriots' defensive struggles vanish with Bill Belichick calling the plays?

The unit was uncharacteristically porous in losses to quality teams, surrendering 38 to the Saints and 35 to the Colts, who trailed by 17 in the second quarter. The impact players who contributed to three Super Bowl wins are largely gone, and the one who remains, nose tackle Vince Wilfork, is an unrestricted free agent who wants big money or his walking papers. Inside linebacker Jerod Mayo has the potential to be an elite player, but the cupboard is sparse from there. Linebacker Adalius Thomas hasn't lived up to expectations and will probably be released. Carolina free-agent end/linebacker Julius Peppers would cure some ills, but the Patriots' problems on defense run deeper than one player.

*And another thing: New England has to find a running back. It's not a coincidence that they are Super Bowl-less since shifting the offensive emphasis to the passing game. Laurence Maroney clearly is not what they envisioned after drafting him in the first round in 2006, and Fred Taylor turned 34 last month.

NEW YORK JETS -- Can coach Rex Ryan find another cover cornerback to take his defense even higher?

That question might seem strange considering the Jets allowed league-lows in points, passing yards and total yards and have, arguably, the top cover corner in the game, Darrelle Revis. But the reality is Ryan needs a complement for Revis because he's unlikely to find an elite edge rusher who can win one-on-one battles when the team doesn't blitz. If that player were available, the secondary would be less of a concern because it wouldn't have to cover as long. But elite edge rushers are almost as hard to find as franchise quarterbacks, and any players who fit that category in the draft will be long gone by the time the Jets select near the bottom of the first round.

*And another thing: With Thomas Jones a candidate for termination because he's due $5.8 million in salary and bonus, and with Leon Washington returning from a serious leg injury, the Jets would do well to get backup insurance for Shonn Greene, the rookie runner who came on strong down the stretch.


DENVER BRONCOS -- Is it time to trade wide receiver Brandon Marshall?

Coach Josh McDaniels and Marshall have been together for only one season, but there's already plenty of bad blood between them. The chatter out of the locker room late last season was that McDaniels was trying to divide the players into his guys and former coach Mike Shanahan's guys. Marshall is the latter.

The Pro Bowl wide receiver continues to seek a large contract -- and a little respect -- neither of which he got from McDaniels last season. To wit: When McDaniels benched Marshall for the season finale he insinuated during a news conference that Marshall was exaggerating the extent of a hamstring injury, saying, "There's a number of players that are going to play on Sunday with things that are much more difficult to deal with than what he has."

*And another thing: Denver must address the interior of the offensive line. The Broncos used a zone-blocking scheme under Shanahan, but McDaniels wants to get away from that and will need bigger, beefier linemen to run his scheme.

KANSAS CITY CHIEFS -- How can they make good on their $63 million investment in QB Matt Cassel?

The most obvious ways are by upgrading the offensive line and adding a true No. 1 receiver. New GM Scott Pioli was in a tough spot in his first season because there was so much work to do on a team that won a total of six games the previous two seasons. But if you're going to give a quarterback $35.5 million in virtual guarantees, you've got to give him the pieces to be successful. The Chiefs led the league in dropped passes, and their best young receiver, 2007 first-round pick Dwayne Bowe, was No. 1 among wideouts with 11 drops, according to STATS LLC.

*And another thing: The Chiefs ranked 31st among 32 teams in sacks last season and need to find an outside linebacker who can pressure passers. They used the third pick in last year's draft on Tyson Jackson, but ends in a 3-4 scheme are primarily anchors and space-eaters. Kansas City needs a game-changer.

OAKLAND RAIDERS -- Will it be JaMarcus Russell, Bruce Gradkowski or someone else at QB?

Russell was supposed to come into his own in his third season as the fulltime starter. Instead, the former No. 1 overall pick found himself on the bench because of poor production and a suspect work ethic. Insiders say owner Al Davis, who has invested some $31.5 million in guarantees to Russell, wasn't happy about the benching, but the players privately applauded coach Tom Cable's decision. Gradkowski is a restricted free agent, but Oakland is expected to re-sign him so he can compete for the starting job. One plus for whoever wins the job: he will have a bright new offensive coordinator in Hue Jackson, the former quarterbacks coach with Baltimore.

*And another thing: The Raiders acquired defensive lineman Richard Seymour before last season in a trade with New England. Now he's scheduled to become an unrestricted free agent. Oakland must re-sign him, otherwise it will have given up its 2011 first-round pick to rent Seymour for one season. This one bears watching because Seymour's family remained back east last season, and the three-time Super Bowl champion is not accustomed to the losing or dysfunction he experienced last year in Oakland.

SAN DIEGO CHARGERS -- Who will replace running back LaDainian Tomlinson?

Tomlinson has been the face of the franchise pretty much since he was drafted in 2001, but he's expected to be released because the offense now runs through QB Philip Rivers, and Tomlinson has had three consecutive seasons of declining production. Backup Darren Sproles is not physically built to be the fulltime back for 16 games, and journeyman reserve Michael Bennett isn't the answer. GM A.J. Smith doesn't believe in spending big in free agency, so look for help to come from the draft.

*And another thing: Arguably no team will benefit more from an uncapped season than the Chargers, who have a handful of key starters who'll be kept off the open market because they won't have the required six seasons for unrestricted free agency. The list includes Shawne Merriman, Darren Sproles, Vincent Jackson, Marcus McNeill and Malcom Floyd.

1 2


Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs NFL schedule LaMarcus Aldridge Michael Pineda Phil Jackson Tiger Woods
TM & © 2013 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint