Posted: Tuesday October 19, 2010 12:38PM ; Updated: Tuesday October 19, 2010 6:42PM
Peter King

MMQB Mailbag (cont.)

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Browns quarterback Colt McCoy stood tall in the face of constant Steelers pressure in his first NFL start Sunday.
Getty Images

Your e-mails, first on various topics, then on the Deion "I Got Robbed When NFL Films Rated Me The 34th-Best Player Of All-Time'' Sanders topic:

• I WAS NEGLIGENT IN NOT PRAISING MCCOY. "Somewhat surprised that you did not mention Colt McCoy's solid performance against the Steelers, particularly because you noted that Gil Brandt recommended him to Mike Holmgren in one of your columns from the draft period. Although it was only one game, how do you think McCoy looked?''
--Matt, Secaucus, N.J.

Colt McCoy, I believe, was a revelation Sunday in Pittsburgh. I should have spent some words Monday praising him. What impressed me most was his poise on one of the toughest fields in the NFL, against one of the toughest defenses he'll ever face. To go 23 of 33 while being under constant attack is a tribute to all the preparation he's had for this moment over the years, particularly at Texas.

I watched a lot of this game, and what was impressive was how he never flinched in the face of the five sacks or the seven or eight other significant pressures. I wouldn't be surprised to see McCoy start not only against New Orleans this week at the Superdome, but also after the bye, when the Patriots and Jets, in succession, travel to Cleveland. Talk about a tough road to start a career. But yes, I'm high on what I saw in McCoy.

• PLAY THE GAME LIKE RUGBY. "In the violent game of rugby, players are not allowed to hit an opponent above the shoulders during a tackle. The price for violating this rule: ejection and the violator's team plays one man down. The NFL would be significantly less dangerous if it adopted this rule and consequence.''
--Dave P., Albany, N.Y.

I doubt this will ever come to be, but it is really an interesting concept, particularly playing one man down the way it's done in some other sports. I know how big a factor it is on the World Cup stage.

• I LIKE IT. "Regarding the change of pass interference to a 15-yard penalty: Couldn't the NFL create a new penalty to prevent defensive backs from intentionally tackling wide receivers? Make the inadvertent penalties (which would probably be in the vast majority) a 15-yard penalty and make an 'intentional' interference a spot foul?''
--Ryan S., Indianapolis

From your lips to the Competition Committee's ears. It's a great thought.

• OK. I SEE. "I have to disagree with taking Charlie Casserly to task for reporting on the Brett Favre news 20 hours after it happened. I think that readers really don't care about that sort of thing and it's a little too "inside baseball" on the part of the media. It wasn't even a full 24 hours later when he reported on it, and you are criticizing him for doing so too late after the initial report? The media goes too fast in all aspects of reporting and doesn't give proper attention to stories that deserve it, which contributes to our ADHD nation and the inability of people to think about a subject in depth. Criticizing someone for reporting on an event only 20 hours after the first report doesn't help this problem at all.''
--Dave B., San Francisco

Charley and I talked Monday, and there are no hard feelings about this. And Dave, I see your point. I won't harp on this, but in my business, if I report something on national TV and 20 hours later someone else reports the same thing on another national TV outlet without attributing the story properly, that's something I have a problem with.

Now your points about the Deion situation. It's your forum, so I'm just going to print your thoughts here.

• DEION IS RANKED TOO HIGH. "If anything, Deion Sanders is ranked too high on that list. He was the prototypical cover corner and one of the best return men ever, but he was flawed as a cornerback and didn't tackle well until later in his career. Top-50 NFL players don't have major flaws. The Canton (Ohio) Repository did a good job last year ranking its top 50 Hall of Famers of all-time, and while Deion would not have been eligible for that list (neither would Jerry Rice and some others), I would have a hard time putting Deion in the top 40.''
--Joe F., Canton, Ohio

• HE AGREES. "I tend to agree more with you. Compared to other DBs, the only other one higher than him is Rod Woodson. How much higher? We're not sure, but there is clearly an argument for Woodson to be ranked higher than Sanders due to his ability to play multiple positions and he tackled a lot better - points you already mentioned. As compared to the other defensive players, they are all linemen and linebackers - players who are generally more involved on every single play. Similarly to a relief pitcher in baseball (who is generally considered less valuable than a field player) who may only impact the outcome of 45-50% of a team's games, a cornerback may only impact 35-40% of a team's defensive snaps (assuming a 50/50 run/pass split and the normal distribution of passes). In contrast, the defensive line has an impact on every play. For that reason, I have no problem rating the all-time best linemen ahead of Sanders. As for the linebackers, the few who are ahead of Sanders had to be game-planned for every bit as much as Sanders and they probably had an impact on 65-90% of the defensive snaps any given day. I like Deion's energy and his confidence, but he has to consider his position's impact on the game as a whole to see the big picture.''
--Adam S., of Deefield, Ill.

• HE AGREES TOO. " 'Did Deion get jobbed?' Please. Before there ever was a Prime Time, Darrell Green was doing what Deion would later come to be famous for. Sorry to make this sound like a Jimmy Johnson product pitch, but Green did it faster, harder and longer too.''
--Stewart, Phoenix

• DEION IS A COOL DUDE, AND WE HAVE HIM ALL WRONG. "Deion Sanders has mellowed like you said Rodney Harrison has. I never really cared for "PrimeTime" but the more I watch him on NFL network the more I like him. His pouring talcum or baby powder in his hand then fake slapping Steve Mariucci as one of the voters that placed him 34th was both funny and endearing. It showed he has finally accepted he's not playing anymore and values his legacy in the NFL and has a GREAT sense of humor while still being contemporary enough to give a view that is legit.''
--Jon W., of Hernando, Miss.

1 2
Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs NFL schedule LaMarcus Aldridge Michael Pineda Phil Jackson Tiger Woods
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint