• Get the EA Sports PGA 14 Package
    Get the EA Sports PGA 14 Package
  • Give the Gift of SI
    Give the Gift of SI
SI.com Home
FANTASY
Posted: Wednesday July 6, 2011 1:38PM ; Updated: Wednesday July 6, 2011 5:25PM

Fantasy baseball closer report

Story Highlights

With J.J. Putz out indefinitely, David Hernandez may be D'backs closer rest of year

Andrew Bailey has given up only one earned run since return from the DL

Bobby Parnell is worth a speculative add with chance Francisco Rodriguez is traded

By Ben Eagle, SI.com

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
David Hernandez has moved in three years from starter to setup man and now to closer.
David Hernandez has moved in three years from starter to setup man and now to closer.
Cary Edmondson -- US PRESSWIRE

We're nearing the All-Star break, which means some major league players are nearly broken themselves.

In Arizona, the injury bug has bitten J.J. Putz (3.12 ERA, 21 saves). The Diamondbacks placed Putz on the DL on July 1 with right elbow tendinitis, and the injury might help explain Putz's 6.17 ERA in June. Given Putz's injury history, the latest scrape is worrisome. GM Kevin Towers is "hopeful" Putz can return shortly after the All-Star break, but with Putz's age (34), that seems optimistic.

With Putz sidelined indefinitely, the D'backs have turned to David Hernandez (3.46 ERA, four saves, 10.38 K/9) in the ninth inning. A converted starter, Hernandez was shipped from the Orioles to the Diamondbacks last winter and immediately stepped into the setup role in front of Putz. With an arsenal like his, he could stay in the closer role for good, but he needs to cut down on the walks (5.08 BB/9) to remain successful. Hernandez is owned in only 27.4 percent of leagues, and given his long-term potential, that number is way too low.

Farther east, Ryan Madson (2.03 ERA, 15 saves) is just the latest Phillies closer to land on the DL. Before Madson landed on the DL with a bruised hand on June 28, the Phillies had already lost both Jose Contreras and Brad Lidge to various ailments. While the news on Lidge and Contreras isn't great, there's reason for optimism with Madson. The right-hander threw a successful bullpen session on Tuesday, and the Phillies expect him to return immediately after the All-Star break.

In the meantime, those chasing saves should look to Antonio Bastardo (0.87 ERA, five saves, 10.16 K/9), who has filled in admirably since Madson went down, and yet he's still owned in only 74.1 percent of leagues. Bastardo should be owned in all leagues until at least the All-Star break, and even after Madson returns, the left-hander can contribute in strikeouts, ERA and WHIP.

How did the rest of the major league bullpens fare this week? Let's take a look around the league:

First-Class

Heath Bell
Carlos Marmol
Mariano Rivera
Brian Wilson
Joel Hanrahan

It's been a rough week for Rivera. The Yankees' closer blew his fourth save of the season against the crosstown Mets on Sunday, and he's currently nursing a sore right triceps. Rivera said there's no need for concern, but those in need of saves in AL-only leagues should add David Robertson.

Second-Class

Francisco Cordero
Craig Kimbrel
Jonathan Papelbon
Andrew Bailey
Jose Valverde
Brandon League
John Axford
Drew Storen
Huston Street
Joakim Soria

SI Inside Fantasy Podcast
SI.com's fantasy experts Will Carroll and Eric Mack discuss the return of Albert Pujols, players who will benefit most from the All-Star break and closers who may be on the move.


SI Inside Fantasy Archive | Find on

Valverde surrendered three runs in the ninth inning against the Giants on Friday, snapping a 13-game scoreless streak. The Tigers' closer is the proud owner of a 3.00 ERA and 8.75 K/9 and is still one of the top-flight closers in the league. ... Bailey (0.73 ERA, seven saves) has saved seven straight games and given up only one earned run since he was activated from the DL in late May. Needless to say, he's back.

Third-Class

Francisco Rodriguez
Leo Nunez
Chris Perez
Kyle Farnsworth
Jordan Walden
Frank Francisco
Fernando Salas
Neftali Feliz
Antonio Bastardo

The market for K-Rod is heating up and there is speculation Bobby Parnell (2.78 ERA, 10.72 K/9) could step in once the Mets' closer is dealt. Parnell has a closer's arsenal and is worth a speculative add in NL-only leagues. ... Salas (2.54 ERA, 15 saves) rebounded last week, and boy did he need it. After serving up five earned runs in 4.2 innings, Salas followed up with 4.2 scoreless innings. He's not going to lose his job to anyone else on the current roster anytime soon.

Standby

Sergio Santos
Kevin Gregg
Mark Melancon
Matt Capps
David Hernandez
}Javy Guerra

Melancon (3.23 ERA, six saves) is slumping in a big way. He's given up eight earned runs in his last 5.2 innings. The Astros aren't garnering a ton of save opportunities anyway, but they might turn to Wilton Lopez (3.08 ERA, 58.7 ground-ball percentage) soon. Lopez is only worth an add in the deepest of NL-only leagues. ... Capps has given up nine hits and five earned runs in his last 1.2 innings, but manager Ron Gardenhire said he's sticking with Capps in the ninth inning. Look for that to change if Joe Nathan (6.52 ERA, three saves, 8.84 K/9) can resemble anything close to his former self. The former All-Star is owned in only 36.8 percent of leagues.

Infirmary

Brad Lidge
David Aardsma
Vicente Padilla
Jonathan Broxton
Brandon Lyon

Lidge began a rehab assignment this week, but with Madson on the mend and Bastardo holding it down in his stead, Lidge isn't relevant in fantasy leagues right now.

Handcuffs

Backups who will ensure you're banking saves even if your closer goes down:

Team Closer Next In Line
Arizona David Hernandez Sam Demel
Atlanta Craig Kimbrel Jonny Venters
Baltimore Kevin Gregg Koji Uehara
Chicago (AL) Sergio Santos Matt Thornton
Chicago (NL) Carlos Marmol Sean Marshall
Cincinnati Francisco Cordero Nick Masset
Cleveland Chris Perez Rafael Perez
Colorado Huston Street Matt Lindstrom
Detroit Jose Valverde Joaquin Benoit
Florida Leo Nunez Steve Cishek
Houston Mark Melancon Wilton Lopez
Kansas City Joakim Soria Aaron Crow
Los Angeles (AL) Jordan Walden Fernando Rodney
Los Angeles (NL) Javy Guerra Matt Guerrier
Milwaukee John Axford LaTroy Hawkins
Minnesota Matt Capps Joe Nathan
New York (AL) Mariano Rivera David Robertson
New York (NL) Francisco Rodriguez Bobby Parnell
Oakland Andrew Bailey Grant Balfour
Philadelphia Antonio Bastardo Michael Stutes
Pittsburgh Joel Hanrahan Jose Veras
San Diego Heath Bell Mike Adams
San Francisco Brian Wilson Sergio Romo
Seattle Brandon League Jamey Wright
St. Louis Fernando Salas Jason Motte
Tampa Bay Kyle Farnsworth J.P. Howell
Texas Neftali Feliz Darren Oliver
Toronto Frank Francisco Jon Rauch
Washington Drew Storen Tyler Clippard

 
SI.com
Hot Topics: LeBron James Aaron Hernandez U.S. Soccer Stanley Cup Final Zack Wheeler Steve Gleason Celtics-Clippers
TM & © 2013 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint