Posted: Wednesday March 2, 2011 1:23PM ; Updated: Wednesday March 2, 2011 1:23PM
Frank Deford
Frank Deford>VIEWPOINT

Woods' struggle is good for golf

Story Highlights

Despite his struggles on the course, Tiger Woods remains golf's biggest draw

It's hard to tell if his decline is because he's geting older or the sex scandal

Regardless, the mystery of whether his game will recover continues to reel fans in

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Are Tiger Woods' best years behind him or is he still struggling from last year's sex scandal?
Sam Greenwood/Getty Images

Tiger Woods is a phenomenon.

Only, no, not the golf phenomenon he was once. He is now a instrument of curiosity the likes of which both the public and the media have never dealt with in any sport, ever. Even though Woods' recent performance suggests he is only just another golfer now, when he plays ... until he is undeniably out of contention ... he remains the story.

Tiger Shoots 3-Over

Tiger Closes Gap

Tiger Trails by 8 Strokes

Whatshisname Wins as Tiger Finishes 14th And so on.

In a way, he holds golf hostage. Oh sure, dyed-in-the-wool golfers follow their whole sport closely, but the fringe fans, the type that really determines a sport's popularity, are fixated on Tiger. This week, he's not playing, so golf doesn't exist. Ladies and gentlemen, golf will officially resume again next Thursday when Mr. Woods tees off at the Doral.

It was understandable that he was the absolute focal point when he was the greatest golfer, maybe ever. We always follow the superstars and he was super-duper. But what is so bizarre, is that the interest in Woods remains so high. It's almost as if we cannot believe that he is diminished. Phil Mickelson, Retief Goosen, Martin Kaymer barely exist. Tomorrow the drive will surely be straight. Tomorrow he can't possibly land again in the rough. Tomorrow he will sink the putt, guaranteed.

I'm convinced that this unusual intrigue is caused by the fact that we -- and maybe even he, too -- can't be sure why he's no longer great. Is it because of the notorious sex scandal, what that did to his reputation, his psyche, his confidence and ultimately his game? Or is he diminished just like other human athletes, simply because he's older -- no different from Roger Federer in tennis, Tim Duncan in basketball?

I think for many people -- even those who detest him personally -- what sustains the mystery is the belief that he was so fantastic, that age simply cannot be the issue, that Tiger Woods will get his mind straight and be the lord of the links once more. And, yes, of course, he could win again. Woods is 35 now, and it is not unusual for players to even win a major when they're older that that. But, it tends to be a catch-lightning-in-a-bottle kind of thing. Sure, older golfers can win one big one, but they don't win very often. But Tiger must be different. Certainly. Isn't he? Maybe ...?

You know what he reminds me of? The Broadway musical Spider-Man. It sells out to the curious, even though the critics hate it and it's always a tease, always a work in progress. And there's a dark side that draws us in. Maybe Spidey will find itself. But maybe it'll only be always not ... quite ... there. We watch Tiger Woods with the same almost morbid fascination, afraid to look away because if we do, we'll miss it if he miraculously returns to greatness, as if age doesn't matter with majesty, and what changed his life was all just a bump in the road.
Hot Topics: NBA Draft Yasiel Puig NHL Playoffs NBA Playoffs Mark Cuban Jabari Parker
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint