Posted: Wednesday December 28, 2011 2:34PM ; Updated: Wednesday December 28, 2011 2:34PM
Frank Deford
Frank Deford>VIEWPOINT

Trends in sports fade out -- why not fighting in hockey?

Story Highlights

Trends such as short basketball shorts and smoking while golfing have faded out

With the New Year, hopefully the trend of fighting in hockey will also fade out

Fighting makes hockey seem hokey, and it isn't necessary for the sport to succeed

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Shawn Thornton, Zenon Konopka
Fighting in hockey, like this fight between Bruins right wing Shawn Thornton (top) and Senators center Zenon Konopka, should go out with 2011.
Brian Snyder/REUTERS

Are you old enough to remember a song most prominently sung by the Four Lads entitled Moments to Remember? Ah yes, and these two particular memories:

"The New Year's Eve we did the town / The day we tore the goal posts down ..."

I mention because, yes, we still do the town on New Year's Eve, and will indeed come Saturday night, but tearing the goal posts down is now verboten -- deemed too dangerous. In fact, as our New Year approaches, it's a good time to look back on several other things in sport that have long since faded away.

Who remembers, for example, that at the end of each inning in the field, baseball players would just chuck their gloves onto the grass behind their position, leaving the field littered with mitts for the entire game.

A lot of basketball courts were surrounded by chain-link fence. That's why basketball players were called "cagers" before they were called "hoopsters."

Tennis players wouldn't put balls in their pockets. They'd hold two balls when they served, so that if the server got the first ball in, he'd carry a ball with him throughout the rest of the point.

Professional golfers smoked as they walked the links. On the green, a golfer -- I remember Arnold Palmer in particular -- would line up his putt, smoking still, then throw the cigarette aside, onto the green, putt, pick up his cigarette, inhale and move onto the next tee. It all seemed very rakish and debonair at the time.

Coeds were called coeds and had corsages pinned on them at football games.

Baseball players wore stirrup socks and basketball players wore short shorts.

So a lot of things in sport which seemed absolutely institutionalized as part of the game did change. Yes, some alterations are merely stylistic. Others, though, are quite substantive. So, will the National Hockey League -- especially Commissioner Gary Bettman -- please take note? Now that we're in the year 2012, it's time to do away with fighting in NHL games. Yes, some fans who grew up with it may like it and think it's a necessary part of the game. But it's anachronistic and idiotic and players get hurt. The idea that you have special goons to battle each other while the game stops completely makes hockey seem hokey. If the NHL really believes that it needs staged fighting to succeed, then the people who run the NHL don't have much belief in the intrinsic worth in their sport as a sport.

Let us hope that one day very soon in the New Year that Commissioner Bettman simply announces that, that's it -- starting tomorrow, fighting in hockey is against the rules -- as it is in every other real sport. Then we could welcome ice hockey into the twenty-first century.

Of course, it would also be nice to get short shorts back, too.

 
SI.com
Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs Golden State Warriors Bryce Harper Paul Pierce Masai Ujiri
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint