Posted: Friday November 18, 2011 11:08AM ; Updated: Friday November 18, 2011 2:03PM
Grant Wahl

Galaxy looking to establish legacy

Story Highlights

L.A. can make a case for being the best team in MLS history

Bruce Arena feels that his '98 D.C. United team was comparable in talent

L.A. has the 3rd-best points-per-game total in MLS history

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
European stars such as Robbie Keane (left) and David Beckham have helped spur the Galaxy to the league's best record.
Adrian Sanchez-Gonzalez/Landov

LOS ANGELES -- It's a question worth posing: If the Los Angeles Galaxy win Sunday's MLS Cup final (9 p.m. ET, ESPN, Galavisión), should L.A. be considered the best team in MLS' 16-year history?

You could certainly make the case. With 67 points from 34 games, L.A. (1.97 points per game) had the third-best regular season in league history if we measure by ppg. The only two teams that have done better were the 1998 Galaxy (2.19 ppg) and the 2005 San Jose Earthquakes (2.00). But neither of those two teams went on to win the MLS Cup final. The '11 Galaxy obviously has the chance to do that and say that no MLS team has ever been more successful in both the regular season and playoffs.

(To make it an apples-to-apples comparison, I went back to the years of the shootout, 1996-99, and gave teams one point for every game that was tied after 90 minutes.)

One argument against the Galaxy would be that it hasn't exactly blown teams away this year. L.A.'s plus-20 regular-season goal differential was only tied for ninth-best in MLS history and far behind the '98 Galaxy (plus-41) and '98 D.C. United (plus-30). In fact, that '98 United team could make its own argument for best in league history. Although it fell to Chicago in the MLS Cup final, D.C. did win the CONCACAF Champions Cup and beat South American champion Vasco da Gama in that year's Inter-American Cup.

Best Points-Per-Game In MLS History
(Regular Season)
Los Angeles 1998 2.19
San Jose 2005 2.00
Los Angeles 2011 1.97
D.C. United 1998 1.91
D.C. United 1999 1.88

How seriously should we take the Inter-American Cup? Hard to say. It was an impressive accomplishment on paper, and I can remember then-MLS Commissioner Doug Logan sitting on the couch of SI's soccer editor and telling him that SI "blew it" by not making a big deal of D.C.'s win. Then again, the Inter-American Cup has never been awarded since. (I guess you could say D.C. United is still the reigning champion.)

In any case, I recently asked Bruce Arena to compare the '11 Galaxy and '98 United teams, not least because he has been the coach of both.

"For me, [D.C.'s] Marco Etcheverry and Jaime Moreno in their prime were as good as any two payers in the history of this league," Arena told me. "You could draw the comparison that [Landon] Donovan and [David] Beckham are like that. I think in the goal we're better than any of the D.C. United teams. In the forward positions, Moreno was different: We don't have a forward of that ability. Our back lines were good. D.C. United's was pretty good with Eddie Pope, Jeff Agoos and Carlos Llamosa. They're kind of comparable. In the midfield, it depends on where Landon is, but the midfields of D.C. United were pretty good."

Best Goal Differentials In MLS History
(Regular Season)
Los Angeles 1998 +41
D.C. United 1998 +30
Salt Lake 2010 +25
D.C. United 1999 +25
D.C. United 2007 +22
San Jose 2005 +22
Miami 2001 +21
D.C. United 2005 +21
Los Angeles 2011 +20
Houston 2007 +20
Chicago 2001 +20
Los Angeles 1999 +19
Chicago 1998 +19

"It's close. The league was different then too, you know."

Is the league better now than in the late '90s?

"I think the American player is much better," Arena said. "I don't think we have the foreign players like the [Carlos] Valderramas and Etcheverrys, but we have a lot of very good international players now. The league's getting younger. Overall it's better. We're playing for the most part on soccer fields, which is better than in the beginning. We have to maybe kind of stay away from as many artificial fields, but the stadiums are being built, there's good support."

"At the commercial end it's getting better. NBC is going to be a real shot in the arm for the league. The refereeing is getting better. It still has to get better. We have to do a better job of scheduling, because it's difficult to do what we're doing with these different competitions. Our rosters are going to have to get better. There's a lot of challenges and it's going to take time, but we're headed in the right direction. When this league gets to 20 teams it'll be pretty impressive."

My take: You play to win the game. If the Galaxy wins on Sunday, it deserves to call itself the best team in MLS history. No team would have combined L.A.'s success in the regular season and playoffs.

The pick: Los Angeles 2, Houston 1.
Hot Topics: Sammy Watkins NFL Draft Rick Adelman NFL Questions Aaron Hernandez Donald Trump
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint