• Get the Blackhawks Championship Package
    Get the Blackhawks Championship Package
  • Give the Gift of SI
    Give the Gift of SI
Posted: Monday June 4, 2012 12:54PM ; Updated: Monday June 4, 2012 6:25PM

The 10 biggest busts among No. 1 overall picks in baseball history

Story Highlights

David Clyde was taken first in 1973 just ahead of two future Hall of Famers

The very first No. 1 overall pick, Steve Chilcott, never even made the majors

Matt Bush probably shouldn't have been No. 1 overall in 2004 and he proved it

By Andrew Clark, Special to SI.com

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Brien Taylor
The closest Brien Taylor, the No. 1 pick in 1991, got to wearing a Yankees uniform was in spring training.
AP

The past two times the Houston Astros have selected first overall, the results have been solid, if not spectacular.

In 1976, the Astros selected Floyd Bannister, a lefty out of Arizona State who was coming off a Player of the Year nod. Sixteen years later, the team Cal-State Fullerton third baseman Phil Nevin, also a Player of the Year. Both had decent careers, though mostly with other teams. Bannister won 134 games in 15 seasons, Nevin hit 208 home runs in 12 years; both made one All-Star team Neither became a franchise cornerstone in the mold of Derek Jeter, whom the Yankees famously snagged five spots after Houston took Nevin.

Two decades removed from their last "1-1" pick, the Astros have the fortune (or misfortune) of being able to select at the top of the first round. Sometimes teams have used the pick to help transform their franchise, as the Mets did with Darryl Strawberry in 1980, the Mariners did with Ken Griffey Jr. in 1987 and the Braves did with Chipper Jones in 1990.

Of course, sometimes, the decision backfires completely. Below is a ranking, in reverse order, of the 10 biggest top-pick busts of all-time. A number of factors were considered, including time spent in the majors, the amount of expectations heaped on the player in question and, of course, their career performance.

With some players, deciding whether or not to include them on such an infamous list was rather difficult. For others, it didn't take very long at all.

10. Dave Roberts, 3B, University of Oregon, 1972: After his selection Roberts bypassed the minors and headed straight for The Show. The Padres' first-round pick in 1973 did the exact same thing. That player, Dave Winfield, is one of just two Padres in the Hall of Fame. Roberts never had anywhere close to that success. His best season came in 1973, when he hit .286 with 21 home runs. He never hit more than 10 home runs in any other season and left the game after hitting .182 for the Phillies in 1982.

9. David Clyde, SP, Westchester HS (TX), 1973: A dominant high school ace, the Rangers elected to go with the local product, partly to boost their sagging attendance. Like Roberts, Clyde skipped the minors entirely and made his major league debut at age 18 just three weeks after pitching his last high school game.

Despite his talent, Clyde never caught on in the majors. In his five year career, he went 18-33 with a 4.63 ERA and a 1.53 WHIP. By the time he was 24, Clyde was out of the majors for good. He remains a cautionary tale for not rushing talent to the big leagues.

Making matters worse for the Rangers were the three players taken immediately after Clyde: future All-Star catcher John Stearns went No. 2 overall and future Hall of Famers Robin Yount and the aforementioned Dave Winfield went No. 3 and No. 4, respectively.

8. Matt Anderson, RP, Rice, 1997: In his first season with the Tigers, Anderson showed flashes of dominance. As a 21-year-old rookie in 1998, the right-handed flamethrower had 44 strikeouts in 44 innings of work and a 3.27 ERA.

He stayed in middle relief for the Tigers for a few seasons but in 2002, he tore a muscle in his armpit and was never able to reach the frightening velocity which made him one of the game's top prospects. Some have speculated that Anderson's injury was related to an octopus throwing contest Anderson competed in held by the Tigers. He claims it was related to working out.

After the Tigers let him leave in 2003, Anderson pitched just six more games in the majors, posting a 12.60 ERA for the Rockies in 2005. He played professionally through 2008 and attempted to make a comeback with the Phillies last year but was released in April.

7. Al Chambers, OF, John Harris HS (PA), 1979: Eight years before Seattle made Ken Griffey Jr. the top pick in the draft, the Mariners chose another tools-laden high school outfielder.

Unfortunately for Seattle, the results were far different.

In the minors, Chambers could hit (.288/.382/.466, 85 home runs over nine seasons). In fact, in 1981, the Harrisburg, Penn., native had 20 homers and 77 RBIs. But his success in the minors never translated to the majors. Chambers played just 57 games across three big league seasons, hitting .208 with two home runs and 11 RBIs. He was sent down from Seattle when he was 24 and never made it back to the bigs.

6. Shawn Abner, OF, Mechanicsburg Area HS (PA), 1984: A multi-sport athlete oozing with talent, the Mets took Abner first overall in 1984. Like their top choices in 1980, when New York picked Strawberry and future Oakland A's general manager Billy Beane with first-round picks, Abner fit the mold of an overly athletic high school outfielder with an ostensibly limitless ceiling.

He proved to be anything but.

Abner never reached the majors with the Mets, and in 1985, he was part of a multi-player deal with the Padres. He finally debuted in 1987, and in six major league seasons, Abner would hit .227/.269/.323 with just 11 homers in 840 at-bats. By the time he was 26, Abner was out of the majors with as many career triples as organizations he'd been a part of (four).

5. Bryan Bullington, SP, Ball State, 2002: Bullington's numbers at Ball State were far short of dominant, making him something of a surprise choice for Pittsburgh in a draft that also included B.J. Upton, Zack Greinke, Prince Fielder, Cole Hamels and Matt Cain.

Unlike those players, Bullington never found a home in the majors. He bounced around four different organizations after the Pirates placed him on waivers in 2008.

He last pitched in the majors in 2010, having compiled a career record of 1-9 with a 5.62 ERA and 1.58 WHIP.

After his last stop in the bigs, with Kansas City in 2010, Bullington went over to Japan, where he is still pitching for the Hiroshima Carp.

4. Danny Goodwin, C, Southern, 1971 and 1975: Though there are No. 1 picks with worse career numbers than Goodwin, the former Southern University product earns his ranking for one key reason: He was the top pick twice.

Goodwin never signed with the White Sox after being the top choice in the 1971 draft. Instead he went to college and was taken by the Angels with the first pick in 1975. He went to the majors and embarked on what became an ultimately forgettable career. In seven seasons, Goodwin hit .236 with 13 home runs over 252 games. He left the majors in 1982 and tried to resurrect his career four years later with a stop in Japan. Goodwin would later wind up having a much longer career in the Braves front office.

3. Steve Chilcott, C, Antelope Valley Christian (CA), 1966: In baseball's first amateur draft, the Mets chose Chilcott one spot before the Kansas City A's selected Arizona State prospect Reggie Jackson. While Jackson soon became, it was once said, a "superduperstar" who wound up in the Hall of Fame, Chilcott never even reached the majors and he played just 22 games in Triple-A. He had seemed to be a dream prospect -- a power hitting catcher with a 5'11", 185-pound frame and a hose for an arm. But a chronic shoulder issue and a shin infection, among other maladies, helped prevent him from reaching his potential near his full potential. He retired at 24 after seven seasons (spent mostly in A-ball), during which he hit .248 with 39 home runs for the Mets, Yankees and Expos organizations.

2. Brien Taylor, SP, East Carteret HS (NC), 1991: When he was taken first in the 1991 draft by the Yankees, Taylor was declared by some to be the greatest high school pitching prospect of all-time. He averaged well over two strikeouts per inning and his fastball got up around 100 mph. It took $1.55 million for the Yankees to secure his services.

Early on in his minor league career, Taylor showed those flashes which led to his top selection. In his first two seasons, he struck out 337 in 54 starts between A and AA. However, in the 1993 off-season, Taylor was involved in a fight which ruined his pitching arm and required serious surgery.

He was never the same.

In 1996, Taylor, who had once been Baseball America's top-ranked prospect, posted an 18.73 ERA over nine starts, walking 43 in 16 innings. The next season, he put up a 14.33 ERA with 52 walks in 27 innings. Taylor's career ended in 2000 following an unsuccessful season at A-ball in the Indians organization, making him the second top pick to never reach the majors.

Among the players on Cleveland's roster that year was a hitting star who had also gone in the first round in 1991 and, as a New York native, might have been attractive to the Yankees: Manny Ramirez.

1. Matt Bush, SS/P, Mission Bay HS (CA), 2004: Of the 46 players to be taken first overall in the history of the draft, no one has had as ignominious of a career as Matt Bush.

Bush was a local product who really shouldn't have been drafted so highly to begin with. However, he was cheaper to sign than the alternatives and the two-way prospect gave a hometown discount to the Padres.

Bush's struggles began immediately. He hit just .192 without a home run that year at rookie ball and low-A, and followed it up by hitting .221 at Class A in 2005. He never advanced even to Double-A in the San Diego system and, after being turned into a pitcher in 2007, the Padres finally traded him to Toronto. He didn't play professionally at all in 2008 and 2009 then caught on with the Rays organization, where he pitched in 2010 and 2011, compiling a 4.50 ERA and not ever reaching Triple-A.

While Bush's shortcomings on the field and failure to make the major leagues already make him a strong candidate to earn the distinction of the worst number pick of all-time, it's his long string of transgressions off the field -- starting with his arrest in a bar fight shortly after being drafted -- which cement it.

Oh, and the player the Detroit Tigers took immediately after Bush? Justin Verlander, the reigning American League Cy Young and Most Valuable Player.

 
SI.com
Hot Topics: Sammy Watkins NFL Draft Rick Adelman NFL Questions Aaron Hernandez Donald Trump
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint