• Get the Blackhawks Championship Package
    Get the Blackhawks Championship Package
  • Give the Gift of SI
    Give the Gift of SI
Posted: Monday June 11, 2012 12:18PM ; Updated: Monday June 11, 2012 12:44PM

Roundtable: Sizing up the Finals

Story Highlights

Miami and Oklahoma City both were tested on their way to the NBA Finals

Key storylines: LeBron vs. KD; can Heat D cool off OKC?; Westbrook's PG edge

Three writers like the Thunder to win the championship and two pick the Heat

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Kevin Durant and the Thunder have been on an offensive tear in the playoffs, but they've yet to face a defense as good as Miami's.
Kevin Durant and the Thunder have been on an offensive tear in the playoffs, but they've yet to face a defense as good as Miami's.
Layne Murdoch/NBAE via Getty Images
NBA Finals Schedule
GAME 1  at OKC, Tue. June 12, 9 p.m., ABC
GAME 2  at OKC, Thu. June 14, 9 p.m., ABC
GAME 3  at MIA, Sun. June 17, 8 p.m., ABC
GAME 4  at MIA, Tue. June 19, 9 p.m., ABC
GAME 5  at MIA, Thu. June 21, 9 p.m., ABC*
GAME 6  at OKC, Sun. June 24, 8 p.m., ABC*
GAME 7  at OKC, Tue. June 26, 9 p.m., ABC*
*if necessary; all times Eastern

Miami and Oklahoma City will play for the championship in a series that features the MVP, LeBron James, the MVP runner-up and scoring champion, Kevin Durant, and a host of other stars in the Heat's Dwyane Wade and Chris Bosh and the Thunder's Russell Westbrook and Sixth Man Award winner James Harden. The Heat are back in the NBA Finals for the second year in a row as the 27-year-old James seeks his first title to cap his ninth season. Durant, 23, is also looking for his first ring, the five-year veteran having led the franchise to its first Finals appearance since 1996, when the Thunder played in Seattle. What can we expect once Game 1 tips off on Tuesday night in Oklahoma City? Five SI.com NBA writers analyze how each team got this far and what lies ahead in the Finals.

What have you learned about both teams in the playoffs?

Ian Thomsen: The main thing is that both teams have matured based on their experiences over the last postseason. They can both thank Dallas for that. Miami is a much tougher, more galvanized team because LeBron is playing closer to the basket and posting up to draw fouls when his team needs points. Oklahoma City has had a full season to work in Kendrick Perkins, but the main improvement in the Thunder is that Durant is doing -- in his own way -- what Dirk Nowitzki did for the Mavericks last year, which is to make certain his team wins. Both teams are extremely confident because of the faith the players have in their leaders.

Zach Lowe: Both have shown growth. Miami is a more resilient, flexible bunch than lots of experts suggested. But it's also a team that became prone to strange defensive breakdowns against the Celtics that it cannot afford in this series. In the face of a massive injury to Bosh, coach Erik Spoelstra embraced small-ball, changed his playbook and tweaked his rotations. It didn't always work -- remember Dexter Pittman starting and the team's nightly regression into stagnancy in the half-court? -- but the Heat are here. And James, under enormous pressure, responded with perhaps the best, meanest ball of his life. The Thunder have also proved to be an adaptable lot, with coach Scott Brooks making series-changing adjustments after two losses to the Spurs and the team in general sharing the ball much more than usual in that series. Westbrook has grown as a playmaker, Durant can run a nasty high pick-and-roll and the Thunder are (mostly) running honest-to-god plays in crunch time -- some even featuring Harden, once forgotten, as the orchestrator. Their defense hasn't been great by the numbers, but it has been good enough.

Lee Jenkins: Oklahoma City has grown up and Miami has toughened up. The Thunder have been the most talented team in the NBA for almost two years, but in these playoffs, they have trusted each other and shared the ball in a way they didn't all regular season. Their best scorers, Durant and Westbrook, have evolved into adept playmakers, allowing the Thunder to demonstrate their superior depth. The Heat, on the other hand, responded to series deficits against Boston and Indiana with a completely different mentality than they showed a year ago against Dallas in the Finals. If Game 7 against the Celtics was any indication, the Heat's three stars are no longer taking turns late in the fourth quarter. They are attacking in concert, a sign they might have finally figured out how to play together.

Chris Mannix: Oklahoma City is a juggernaut, one very capable of kick-starting a multiple-title run right here, right now. The Thunder are more poised than anyone gave them credit for, and they are so explosive that no lead is safe. The Heat are similar in that they can erase any deficit if James is feeling it. As much grief as we give LeBron, he is playing perhaps the finest basketball of his career and, with a little help, is capable of carrying Miami to four wins.

Sam Amick: One of them will remain title-less by the time this is over, but both have championship mettle. The Thunder were rolling before they went down 2-0 to San Antonio in the Western Conference finals, and nothing can spark panic quite like needing to take four of five against a team that had won 20 in a row at that point. So what did they do? Rattled off four straight. The Heat, meanwhile, pushed back against the playoff pressure on two occasions: their 2-1 deficit against Indiana in the second round and Boston's 3-2 edge in the Eastern Conference finals. That LeBron played like an absolute force on most nights certainly helped; he is averaging an NBA-high 30.8 points on 50.8 percent shooting in this season's playoffs compared to 23.7 points on 46.6 percent shooting last year. There's plenty of fight in both teams here, meaning we've got quite a series on our hands.

What intrigues you the most about this Finals matchup?

Thomsen: I want to see whether the hard times James has gone through will make the difference. He has had to fight his way back over the last two years and now he looks as if he's ready to deal with just about anything that may happen in this Finals. By comparison, Durant has had a smooth ride to the top, and if things start turning against him will he have it in him to force the games to be played his way? I know LeBron can do that because he has been building up to this point for two years, but can Durant do it? I'm asking the question because I don't know the answer, but in two weeks we'll all know for sure.

Lowe: How efficiently the Thunder scoring machine can produce against Miami's top-level defense. Oklahoma City had the second-best offense in the regular season, and, remarkably, it's gotten even better in the playoffs. The Thunder shredded Dallas, the Lakers and San Antonio, putting up historic scoring numbers through three rounds. Their assist rate jumped dramatically against a San Antonio team that forced them to drive and move the ball, just as the Heat will. With just a few exceptions -- down the stretch in Game 5 against the Spurs, for instance -- they've run solid late-game sets incorporating all three of their stairs, rather than the predictable isolations that doomed them last season.

Jenkins: Westbrook is a tough matchup for everyone, but especially Miami. We saw how Rajon Rondo was able to get inside the Heat's defense, even with Miami playing off him, and Westbrook is more explosive than Rondo. If the Heat sag on Westbrook the way they did on Rondo, he could bury them with mid-range jumpers, and if they do any more jogging back on defense, he will beat them down the court. Then again, when Westbrook makes himself the focal point of the offense, the Thunder lose the ball movement that has been so effective in the playoffs. Westbrook must exploit the opportunities presented to him while maintaining his poise and remembering his teammates.

Mannix: That Perkins-Joel Anthony matchup is ... oh, come on. It's Durant vs. James, the three-time scoring champ vs. the three-time MVP,the (Twitter-announced) decision vs. The Decision, the humble star vs. the attention-grabber. This should be an epic battle, and given the age of Durant and James, we could quite possibly see it many times in the years to come.

Amick: I'll take "the-best-two-players-in-basketball-playing-for-it-all" please, Alex. It's NBA theater at its finest, and I'll elaborate on the head-to-head matchup a bit later here. But the most compelling part of that battle is the question of whether James can exorcise those demons from last year's Finals. Forget about the context of The Decision or the "Not one, not two, not three ..." proclamations that have been his PR burden for two years now. I'm talking solely about Miami-Dallas 2011, and the unmistakable fact that James disappeared too often and looked far too rattled in the six-game loss to the Mavericks. Rest assured, James isn't out of the woods just yet in terms of his legacy.

What will be the deciding factor in the series?

Dwyane Wade has been up and down during the playoffs, and he consistenty got off to slow starts in the Eastern Conference finals.
Dwyane Wade has been up and down during the playoffs, and he consistenty got off to slow starts in the Eastern Conference finals.
J. Meric/Getty Images

Thomsen: Apart from the question of which star will seize command, I think it's also going to come down to whether Oklahoma City can play enough possessions in the open floor. Miami's half-court offense has become more effective, and when the pace slows, the Heat's ability to earn free throws via James and Wade figures to be a go-to strength. Can Miami prevent the Thunder from playing in the flow of transition and early offense -- and if so, will the Thunder be able to generate points against Miami's set defense?

Lowe: There are so many possibilities when two top-heavy teams face each other. Fatigue could affect James, who has carried the largest burden of any player in the postseason. There is Wade's on-again, off-again shakiness, and the continued rumblings he may be nursing an injury; he'll spend considerable time guarding both Westbrook and Harden in this series. Turnovers and transition defense could make or break either team, considering the fast-break excellence of each. There is small-ball versus big-ball, and a dozen important rotation decisions for each coach. But if forced to pick one, I'm going with the offensive contributions of the Thunder role players, and the connected issue of whether Durant and Westbrook can continue to make the proper "pass or shoot?" decisions. Miami played Durant to pass and drive in the regular season, pressuring him well beyond the three-point arc and trapping him when he popped off screens. Durant dribbled into a season-high nine turnovers in one game and dished a season-high-tying eight assists in the other. The Heat threw softer traps at Westbrook on the pick-and-roll, containing his drive at the foul line and forcing him into tricky choices. We saw the Thunder passing game evolve against the Spurs. Will that continue against (by far) the best defense Oklahoma City has faced in the playoffs?

Jenkins: Because the Thunder are so much deeper than the Heat, and so much more balanced, James and Wade have to outplay Durant and Westbrook. Wade cannot afford to take off any more first halves. James cannot afford to shrink into the facilitator role. They have to log heavy minutes, and despite difficult defensive matchups, remain as aggressive as they were in closing out the Celtics. The Heat don't have a sixth man like Harden, a rim protector like Serge Ibaka or a bouncer like Perkins. They can win, but James and Wade will have to play their best series yet, and be better than Durant and Westbrook.

Mannix: I've been very high on Westbrook the last few years because inside that erratic, turnover-prone bottle rocket is a superstar waiting to bust out. Westbrook should dominate his matchup with Mario Chalmers. If he plays smart, low-error ball, Oklahoma City can win this series in a rout. If not, he could turn out to be Miami's secret weapon.

Amick: It's not the sexy answer, but it will be the complementary players -- or "others," as TNT's Shaquille O'Neal so respectfully called the Thunder's. For Oklahoma City, it's players such as Ibaka, Perkins and Sefolosha. Their re-emergence in Game 3 against the Spurs started the turnaround, and was aided by Durant's willingness and ability to be more of a playmaker than ever before. The focus this time around will be on their collective ability to contain James, Wade and Bosh to whatever degree that's possible. For Miami, it's players like Battier, Chalmers and Udonis Haslem who need to muck it up defensively while providing some semblance of scoring. I fully expect the stars on both sides to shine, but Westbrook and Bosh are the wild cards of that bunch. Can Westbrook consistently bring that mixture of aggressive scoring and composed floor leading? Will Bosh be an X-factor in this series like he was in Game 7 against Boston, especially if he's able to pull the shot-blocking Ibaka and Perkins outside and open up the lanes for James and Wade? We shall see.

 
SI.com
Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs Golden State Warriors Bryce Harper Paul Pierce Masai Ujiri
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint