Posted: Monday May 21, 2012 3:29PM ; Updated: Monday May 21, 2012 5:48PM
Avi Creditor

MLS Week 11 Power Rankings: Big-name trades the talking point

Story Highlights

Major trades saw U.S. stars Danny Califf, Heath Pearce and Juan Agudelo move

The star-studded and defending champions L.A. Galaxy are greatly struggling

Brek Shea's MLS suspension factored into his omittance from U.S. squad

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Danny Califf
Danny Califf (left) was a standout on the back line in his Chivas debut.
Victor Decolongon/Getty Images

The first returns on Thursday's blockbuster trades, a title favorite continuing to underachieve and more from Week 11 in MLS:

1. First returns on the major trades. Thursday's blockbuster trades had some big names changing home locker rooms, with Juan Agudelo and Danny Califf going cross-country to Chivas USA, and the Goats sending Heath Pearce and Michael Lahoud back east to the New York Red Bulls and Philadelphia Union, respectively. All four players debuted for their new clubs over the weekend, and the early returns would suggest that Chivas are poised for improvement, the Red Bulls plugged a major hole and the Union helped facilitate the steps forward for both sides while confusing their supporters even further.

Califf was an absolute rock in his Chivas USA debut, playing as inspired at center back as he has all season and showing no lingering effects from any supposed injuries that kept him out of the Union lineup over the last few weeks. Most importantly, he provided stable play in front of Dan Kennedy down the stretch to help Chivas avoid another late-game collapse and hold on for three points against his other former club, the Los Angeles Galaxy.

Like Califf, Agudelo was freed from an unfavorable scenario, and he opened his Chivas career with an energetic, active shift. With the revelation that Luke Rodgers could return to the Red Bulls from Lillestrom in Norway as soon as next month, Agudelo became more expendable in New York, and the club was able to grant his wish to get out of town and into a more nurturing atmosphere. Although Agudelo did not mark his debut with a goal, he was an integral part of the sequence that led to Chivas earning the decisive penalty in their first win over the Galaxy since 2007.

In Los Angeles, the rising U.S. star forward has starter's minutes there for the taking, and he is reunited with one-time mentor Juan Pablo Angel. With that, there is no reason Agudelo can't blossom over the next few months, and with the California-based Jurgen Klinsmann nearby, the move should do wonders for his international status. Klinsmann's approval of the deal was evident through Agudelo's call-up to this week's U.S. camp -- one that prevents him from playing in Chivas' coincidentally timed match at Red Bull Arena this week -- despite his early-season struggles and battle through injury.

"He has an opportunity now, and we want him to grab it and make clear to everyone that he deserves to be a starter no matter where he plays," Klinsmann said on U.S. Soccer's official website.

Chivas general manager Jose Domene hasn't drawn rave reviews in his brief time in charge of the club's personnel, but he deserves plenty of credit for showing the ambition to orchestrate two high-profile moves to improve his franchise in addition to plucking a young Colombian talent like Jose Erick Correa from his native country. Chivas USA has a suddenly intriguing strike force. For him to make those moves he had to part with a valuable asset in Pearce, who is versatile enough to play anywhere across the back and has been a consistent performer since joining MLS in 2009.

Pearce provides reinforcement and versatility to the New York Red Bulls back line, and he appeared to have a seamless transition to his new club despite a mentally grueling couple of days with word of the trade. His performance in Montreal with the Red Bulls down a man earned passing grades, and even though New York's unheralded defenders were getting the job done, Pearce is a proven commodity that can hold things down over the long haul. Even more, the allocation money that the club received from Chivas in addition to Pearce can go a long way in helping the club be a major player during the summer transfer window.

As for the Union, who perhaps unknowingly helped rival New York strengthen its back line by sending Califf to Chivas and allowing the Goats to part ways with Pearce, it is unclear how they will benefit from Thursday's trade. Califf is the third face of the franchise to depart in the last five months, following in the footsteps of Faryd Mondragon and Sebastien Le Toux. Lahoud is a physical, hardworking talent and a nice complementary piece for a team that might be a player or two away from being a contender, but on the Union, he's a player who could easily get lost in the shuffle in an already-crowded midfield. His debut for the Union was marked by using his physicality in a reckless manner, and he was fortunate to have not been sent off in Philadelphia's 1-1 draw with FC Dallas.

Compounding matters for the Union, the club was already down to just two natural center backs on the roster, and with Califf shipped out of town and Carlos Valdes suffering another head injury this weekend, the back line is far from being defined. At one point Saturday night against FC Dallas, Philadelphia was playing a makeshift back four made up of a midfielder and three fullbacks in front of a hobbled, journeyman, backup goalkeeper. There's plenty of symbolism in that for a team that seems lost after being so close to having it figured out a season ago.

2. Galaxy far, far away from meeting expectations. The Los Angeles Galaxy-Chivas USA encounter was neither super nor a clasico, but the rivalry match provided a very telling 90 minutes about two Home Depot Center-based franchises going in opposite directions this season.

Chivas USA is an energized side, one that is eager to prove themselves following two major trades and show that it is no longer the punching bag at the HDC. The defending champion Galaxy, meanwhile, continue to be in free-fall mode and are lacking answers. At the White House last Tuesday, David Beckham and Landon Donovan both spoke of how their trip would be used as a rallying point and a springboard to getting back to the way things were. That was hardly the case Saturday, when the club's showing was more of the same from a team that, on paper, should be among the contenders in the Western Conference but in actuality is underachieving more than any team in league history.

Entering the season, it was imperative that the Galaxy bankrolled points early on in anticipation of being without Donovan, Beckham and Robbie Keane for their respective spells of international duty this summer. Instead, the club sits dead last in the West, has not won it is last five matches and faces the unenviable task of climbing from the bottom up without its superstars just to position itself for a place in the postseason.

It does not get any easier this week, with the Galaxy facing the San Jose Earthquakes in a California Clasico and the Houston Dynamo in an MLS Cup rematch in a four-day span. With Donovan and Keane already departed and Beckham typically rested when two games are played in such quick succession, the Galaxy need their non-DP performers to rally together and rebuild the foundation and the club's identity before the its futile title and Supporters' Shield defense reaches even newer lows.

3. Klinsmann does Shea, FC Dallas a favor. Brek Shea's omission from the U.S. national team roster came as a surprise to some who would have thought the highly touted FC Dallas winger was a shoo-in. Despite his uneven season, no player had been a more prevalent part of Klinsmann's camps and rosters since last summer than Shea.

Shea, like FC Dallas, has struggled to find consistency at his top level, and his frustrations boiled over last week against Columbus with his deliberate kick of a ball at an assistant referee that somehow went unpunished in the match but caught the ire of the MLS Disciplinary Committee. The three game-suspension undoubtedly sent Shea a message, but it also made Klinsmann's decision to leave the left winger off the U.S. roster a bit simpler. Between the lack of maturity that Shea showed on the play (he did own up to everything in comments made following the suspension) and the fact that a call-up would have prevented Shea from serving the suspension until later, Klinsmann elected to pass.

"We have watched Brek during the last few months, and given his performances and some of the other issues we felt he should be on the standby list," Klinsmann said. "He's still a young player with a lot of talent, and also a lot to learn."

Klinsmann did Shea and FC Dallas a favor by leaving him out of this camp. Shea would not have been able to serve his suspension while away on U.S. duty, so instead of being out of MLS action until July 4, which would have been the case had he been tabbed by Klinsmann, Shea is due to miss the next two matches and return on June 16 for Dallas' first foray into BBVA Compass Stadium against Texas rival Houston. Expect a well-rested and motivated Shea to turn next month.

4. The pre-break push. With the international break giving most MLS teams 2-to-3 weeks off, schedule makers had to cram matches in before national teams take center stage. As a result, the next six days will be a whirlwind around the league.

Between midweek and weekend league games and the final of the Canadian championship between Toronto FC and the Vancouver Whitecaps, nine of the league's 19 teams will play twice between Wednesday and Sunday. TFC, Vancouver, Chivas USA, Chicago Fire, FC Dallas, Seattle Sounders, Columbus Crew, LA Galaxy and San Jose Earthquakes are all on double duty, leaving coaches -- some who are already short-handed by international absences -- with lineup decisions and tactical adjustments to make and players left with no option but to be stretched to the max.

5. Team of the Week

Goalkeeper: Andy Gruenebaum (Columbus Crew)

Defenders: Danny Califf (Chivas USA), Eric Brunner (Portland Timbers), Jermaine Taylor (Houston Dynamo), Alain Rochat (Vancouver Whitecaps)

Midfielders: Dwayne De Rosario (D.C. United), Oswaldo Minda (Chivas USA), Perry Kitchen (D.C. United)

Forwards: Teal Bunbury (Sporting Kansas City), Fredy Montero (Seattle Sounders), Saer Sene (New England Revolution)

Week 11 MLS Power Rankings
New Rank Previous Rank Team
1 1 Real Salt Lake (W/L/T: 8-3-2)
RSL's bye week was highlighted by Nick Rimando and Kyle Beckerman getting called into the U.S. national team. Not to worry -- RSL only has a match against battered, short-handed FC Dallas while its leaders are on international duty.
2 1 San Jose Earthquakes (7-2-3)
Alan Gordon netted a last-minute equalizer for the second-straight game, emerging as the Quakes' improbable clutch performer. With Chris Wondolowski gone on U.S. duty, it will take contributions from others like Gordon to get the Earthquakes through their two-game week and the international break on stable ground.
3 3 Seattle Sounders (7-2-2)
Lifeless in the first half of their Cascadia Cup opener against Vancouver, the Sounders turned it on in the final 45 minutes getting the decisive touches from their three offensive cornerstones -- Mauro Rosales, Eddie Johnson and Fredy Montero. The Sounders will always be in any game they're playing as long as that nucleus remains healthy.
4 4 New York Red Bulls (8-3-1)
Facing more adversity than perhaps any other team in the league, the Red Bulls ran off their fifth win in a row, to mark their longest winning streak in nine years. Heath Pearce's transition to the back line went rather seamless, and Dane Richards' first goal of the season couldn't have come at a better time. Somehow this team continues to produce results with odds not in its favor.
5 7 D.C. United (7-4-3)
Dwayne De Rosario and Hamdi Salihi were supposed to lead D.C.'s attack this year before Maicon Santos and Chris Pontius stepped up to take over up top. With the latter two out injured, the two high-priced attackers did the honors in two more home wins for United, accounting for all five goals in triumphs over Colorado and Toronto. De Rosario is now two goals from reaching the esteemed 100-goal club.
6 5 Sporting Kansas City (7-3-1)
Winless in four matches, Sporting KC blew a two-goal lead in Colorado, getting burned on set pieces by two goal-scoring defenders. That's hardly the result Peter Vermes was looking for, and now the pressure rises for Sunday's home bout with San Jose, a game SKC will have to enter without USMNT-bound Graham Zusi. At the very least, Teal Bunbury showed signs of life with his two early goals that should get him going.
7 6 Vancouver Whitecaps (5-3-3)
Winless in four matches, Sporting KC blew a two-goal lead in Colorado, getting burned on set pieces by two goal-scoring defenders. That's hardly the result Peter Vermes was looking for, and now the pressure rises for Sunday's home bout with San Jose, a game SKC will have to enter without USMNT-bound Graham Zusi. At the very least, Teal Bunbury showed signs of life with his two early goals that should get him going.
8 8 Houston Dynamo (3-3-4)
The task of competing without U.S. call-up Geoff Cameron against the Galaxy this weekend is made a bit easier with LA being without Landon Donovan and Robbie Keane for the 2011 MLS Cup rematch.
9 10 Colorado Rapids (5-6-1)
Matt Pickens was sensational in an otherwise forgettable midweek loss to D.C., but the rest of the Rapids showed plenty of backbone to fight back from two goals down at home against Sporting KC to salvage a point. More important is Conor Casey emerging from more than 120 minutes of action unscathed as he works his way back into full form.
10 9 Chicago Fire (4-3-3)
Set-piece defending let the Fire down in Portland, a place that hasn't been too kind to the club in two seasons. The Fire have a golden chance to make a statement that they are better than the other middle-of-the-pack squads, with winnable games against Dallas and at Columbus on the docket.
11 16 Chivas USA (4-6-1)
The Goats' rise is not just for the cathartic win over the Galaxy, but also for the trades signifying the club's ambition in freeing two supremely capable players from bad situations and bringing them to a place where they can thrive. Chivas improved themselves mightily this week. Now if they can only continue to build on that 1-5-0 home record.
12 13 New England Revolution (4-6-1)
Like Vancouver, the Revs held two one-goal leads at home only to let points slip away. Saer Sene continues to show his quality, though, with two more goals to affirm his place as one of the better offseason signings.
13 11 Montreal Impact (3-6-3)
It's not as if the Impact did not have their chances to put the Red Bulls away, but Montreal was stonewalled by Ryan Meara while carrying a man advantage and got caught on the counterattack to drop home points in disappointing fashion and snap a four-game unbeaten run.
14 11 Los Angeles Galaxy (3-6-2)
The Galaxy continue to preach patience and that the results will start coming, but all evidence continues to point to the contrary. From first to worst: That's currently the position in which the Galaxy find themselves in the Western Conference table after a loss to rival Chivas USA.
15 17 Columbus Crew (3-4-3)
Justin Meram is continue to prove his worth as a first-round selection in the 2011 SuperDraft with another great goal, and Andy Gruenebaum had the performance of the week in goal to silence the Quakes until Gordon's last-ditch effort. After performing so well in a tough place to play, though, Columbus can't be thrilled with only leaving Buck Shaw Stadium with a single point.
16 13 FC Dallas (3-6-1)
With Brek Shea out for the next two games and the revolving door of suspended and injured players continuing to turn -- Colombian defender Hernan Pertuz is the latest injury casualty -- Schellas Hyndman has had perhaps the most difficult task of any manager this season in terms of formulating his lineups for consistent success. On the bright side, nobody else got red carded this week.
17 18 Portland Timbers (3-5-3)
Kris Boyd didn't get credit for either Timbers goal Sunday night, but the under-fire DP created both attempts to deliver a much-needed win to a team in desperate need of production. Troy Perkins deserves a nod too, especially for his heroic midweek performance in Houston to salvage a point for a Timbers side that never threatened to steal road points from the Dynamo.
18 17 Philadelphia Union (2-5-2)
Sure, the Union were without some key components of their own, but Saturday's showing in Dallas against a team missing Shea, Zach Loyd and Ugo Ihemelu was far from inspirational. After all of the wheeling and dealing last week, Union fans must be hoping for a big splash when the summer transfer window opens, otherwise it could be a long summer on the banks of the Delaware River.
19 19 Toronto FC (0-0-0)
It certainly didn't take long for Toronto to show its colors by yielding a first-minute goal to former captain Dwayne De Rosario in the loss at D.C. The oddity in lowly Toronto falling for the ninth straight game is that the Reds are one Canadian championship home result away from qualifying for this summer's CONCACAF Champions League.
Hot Topics: NBA Draft Yasiel Puig NHL Playoffs NBA Playoffs Mark Cuban Jabari Parker
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint