Posted: Friday May 25, 2012 2:06PM ; Updated: Friday May 25, 2012 2:06PM
Eric Mack

Early bullpen shakeups bring drastic changes to closer rankings

Story Highlights

Craig Kimbrel is No. 1, but he's joined in the top 10 by out-of-nowhere names

Carlos Zambrano, Shaun Marcum and Matt Moore are solid two-start options

Daniel Bard, Jake Arrieta and Aaron Harang are best to avoid using next week

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Fernando Rodney
Fernando Rodney gave up one earned run in his first 22 innings this season.
J. Meric/Getty Images

You hear that? Yeah, me neither. It is the sound, or the silence, of Closer Gate 2012. It seems the roller-coaster first weeks' dust might have finally settled at the unsettled position. (Knocking on wood, not the retired Kerry Wood.)

Naturally, after Aroldis Chapman has taken his rightful place at the closer's throne in Cincy and Kenley Jansen and Addison Reed are in the stopper roles where they belong -- perhaps for years -- we have to sort through the wreckage. Fernando Rodney and Jim Johnson cannot possibly be the best closers in fantasy, although their numbers to date say otherwise.

Rodney and Johnson just haven't had their market corrections (read: implosions) yet. They will come and knock them down a peg, or 10.

We take a breath -- like the anxious one baseball's managers take every time to go to the bullpen -- cross our fingers it doesn't change drastically yet again (it certainly will) and re-rank the closers of fantasy baseball for the rest of the season.

Things look different almost all the way through, most notably with Chapman near the top. Heck, he can make a case for No. 1, if not for some uncertainty with manager Dusty Baker on his usage. Only the Braves' Craig Kimbrel and the Phillies' Jonathan Papelbon have held their elite value. Chapman, Jansen, the Giants' Santiago Casilla and the Yankees' Rafael Soriano (for now) are top-10 fantasy options.

Even if all these closers pitch perfectly -- yeah, right, dream on -- we are still going to see some significant adjustments in the closer landscape.

With a few more weeks of steadiness, previously struggling John Axford, Heath Bell and Jose Valverde can return to their once lofty status. Then, over the next couple of months, Drew Storen (elbow), Sergio Santos (shoulder), David Robertson (ribs), Huston Street (lat), Andrew Bailey (thumb), Kyle Farnsworth (elbow), Carlos Marmol (hamstring) and even Brad Lidge (abdomen) can come off the DL to strengthen the position's depth, yet complicate things for fantasy owners.

It is not an easy science, this closer roulette, but it at least seems to be calming down and making something a tad closer to making sense.

Here is how we would rank the top 40 relievers in fantasy right now (with their preseason rank in the right-hand column):

Rank Reliever Team March Rank
1 Craig Kimbrel ATL 1
2 Aroldis Chapman CIN 40
3 Jonathan Papelbon PHI 3
4 Kenley Jansen LAD 30
5 Jim Johnson BAL 32
6 Rafael Soriano NYY 41+
7 Chris Perez CLE 18
8 Fernando Rodney TB 41+
9 Santiago Casilla SF 41+
10 J.J. Putz ARI 10
11 Joe Nathan TEX 16
12 Jason Motte STL 19
13 John Axford MIL 2
14 Heath Bell FLA 7
15 Jose Valverde DET 8
16 Brett Myers HOU NR
17 Joel Hanrahan PIT 23
18 Addison Reed CHW 38
19 Brandon League SEA 22
20 Drew Storen WAS 6
21 Jonathan Broxton KC 41+
22 Alfredo Aceves BOS 41+
23 Brian Fuentes OAK 41+
24 Scott Downs LAA 41+
25 Sergio Santos TOR 25
26 Tyler Clippard WAS 41+
27 Dale Thayer SD 41+
28 Rafael Betancourt COL 27
29 Andrew Bailey BOS 9
30 Carlos Marmol CHC 12
31 Huston Street SD 20
32 David Robertson NYY 41+
33 Jonny Venters ATL 24
34 Matt Capps MIN 35
35 Frank Francisco NYM 36
36 Ernesto Frieri LAA 41+
37 Casey Janssen TOR 41+
38 Henry Rodriguez WAS 41+
39 Jordan Walden LAA 15
40 Alexi Ogando TEX 41+

Now, to next week's starters ...

Two-starters to use

1. Carlos Zambrano, Marlins (61 percent active) -- After a remarkable run of quality starts, Big Z pitched like his 2011 self last time out. We should fully expect him to come through in divisional play next week (Nationals and Phillies).

2. Shaun Marcum, Brewers (58 percent active) -- He had his worst outing of the season, but fantasy owners shouldn't really be worried about this steady veteran arm. After facing the Dodgers early in the week, he gets the Pirates on the weekend.

3. Matt Moore, Rays (47 percent active) -- He has been a frustrating first-year starter thus far, but the strikeout numbers are good. Stick with him.

4. Matt Harrison, Rangers (42 percent active) -- He has had some rough starts this season, but the Mariners and Angels (despite a mild Albert Pujols awakening) should not scare you off Harrison.

5. Trevor Cahill, Diamondbacks (41 percent active) -- He hasn't been a worldbeater with his new team yet, but the Giants and Padres in two very good pitcher parks has the makings of a great week.

Two-starters to avoid

1. Daniel Bard, Red Sox (45 percent owned) -- The transition to the rotation hasn't gone that poorly for Bard, but the numbers suggest he is not right. He is walking a lot of batters and surprisingly has stopped striking them out, too. His strikeout-to-walk ratio in his past four starts is a ghastly 8-to-17.

2. Jake Arrieta, Orioles (45 percent owned) -- You are justified liking Arrieta as a sleeper, perhaps, but he has had some stinkers of late. Facing the Blue Jays and Rays on the road might not be a great time to use him in mixed formats.

3. Aaron Harang, Dodgers (34 percent owned) -- He has had some great outings for fantasy owners this season, but he is coming off his worst start and faces a pair of teams (Brewers, Rockies) that aren't going well, but they have some thumpers that are due.

4. Kevin Millwood, Mariners (seven percent owned) -- We have seen stretches like this from Millwood before. We have also seen him blow up our fantasy teams when we try to trust him. A week that opens with a start at Texas is a bad time to jump on board.

5. Zach McAllister, Indians (six percent owned) -- He hasn't pitched poorly to date, but don't let the lure of the Royals and lowly Twins suck you in. He is still dangerous.

Eric Mack writes fantasy for If you miss his Monday baseball trends, Wednesday prospect report or Friday pitching review, you can also find him on Twitter, where you can mock him, rip him and (doubtful) praise him before asking him for fantasy advice @EricMackFantasy. He reads all the messages there (guaranteed) and takes them very, very personally (not really).
Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs Chris Johnson Jameis Winston NFL Draft Michael Sam Aldon Smith
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines, your California privacy rights, and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint