Realignment, playoff latest; more mail (cont.)
What team that missed a bowl last year is poised for a breakout season? Secondly, what bowl team from last year do you expect to tank this year?
-- Johnny D., Strongsville, Ohio
Wow. A question about actual football. Those still exist?
Breakout team: Washington State. The Cougars haven't posted a winning record since 2003 and went 4-8 last year, but as you may have heard, they recently hired a well-known coach prolific at both winning shootouts and shooting bears. With a choice of talented quarterbacks in Jeff Tuel or Connor Halliday and an overlooked receiving corps led by Marquess Wilson (82 catches, 1,388 yards, 12 touchdowns in 2011), the pieces are in place for Mike Leach's team to shred largely mediocre Pac-12 defenses. The Cougars themselves may have the worst defense in the league, but they'll pull out enough 48-44 games to get to at least seven wins.
A more under-the-radar pick: San Jose State, which improved from 1-12 to 5-7 last season under coach Mike MacIntyre and is now one of the better teams left in the depleted WAC.
As for which team I expect to "tank," that depends on the parameters. If the sole criterion is a team that went to a bowl game last season and may have a losing record this year, I'll go with Penn State. New coach Bill O'Brien is saying all the right things, but there's no way a program can go through everything the Nittany Lions have and not take a significant step back. O'Brien doesn't have a quarterback on the roster capable of becoming his new Tom Brady, and the defense, long Penn State's bedrock under coordinator Tom Bradley, is undergoing both a schematic and personnel overhaul, particularly in the secondary. A slide from 9-4 to 5-7 (or worse) is entirely conceivable.
As a Tennessee alum it has been a tough four years since Phillip Fulmer was let go in 2008. I don't think most can fully understand the difficult rebuilding job Derek Dooley has been tasked with, given the recruiting failures of late in Fulmer's career and the player attrition under Lane Kiffin. Derek Dooley had two heartbreaking loses to LSU and UNC in 2010 and injuries decimated the roster in 2011. However, the Kentucky loss at the end of the season and coaching changes in the offseason really changed the perspective on him. What are your expectations for Tennessee this year and do you think Derek Dooley will be the Vols' coach next year?
-- Matt, Atlanta
It seems Dooley is to Tennessee what Ron Zook was to Florida and Rich Rodriguez to Michigan: a guy who's already lost too much support to ever recover. For all the reasons you mentioned, I've tried not to rush to judgment on Dooley after just two seasons, but the guy simply hasn't done anything to engender confidence. He's a Nick Saban disciple who shares his mentor's control-freak tendencies, but all it's gotten him so far is a 28-34 record at two schools. He's got a Les Miles-like oddball personality, but that tends to go over better with the fans when a team is winning 11-12 games, not five-six. And losing seven assistants in one offseason, including several in seemingly lateral moves (defensive coordinator Justin Wilcox left for the same job at Washington), is not a ringing endorsement of the boss.
It's possible Dooley will still be the coach next year, just because the return of a healthy Tyler Bray and Justin Hunter along with Da'Rick Rogers gives the Vols a powerful passing attack that should get them back into the 7-5 or 8-4 realm. But I highly doubt Dooley will be the guy to lead Tennessee back to national glory. That will be up to the program's Urban Meyer or Brady Hoke, who comes in and reaps the benefit of Dooley's recruiting.
Within this wave of Mailbag nostalgia, where does putting Minnesota No. 9 in your 2004 preseason poll rank in your tenure? Even as a 20-year season ticket holder, I thought you were nuts.
-- John, Bemidji, Minn.
Deluding America into believing the Gophers were a top 10 team is on me. But going 7-5 with Marion Barber and Laurence Maroney in the same backfield is on Glen Mason.
With the second season of the Al Golden-coached Hurricanes drawing near, how do you think the program is progressing from the Randy Shannon era, and will the U ever return to becoming an annual top 10 team? Is the program heading in the right direction, or will it continue to be stuck in mediocrity?
-- Ken, Miami
Golden is doing all the right things, but this coming year could be pretty unseemly. In fact, the 'Canes would have been my answer to the earlier "tank" question if they hadn't banned themselves from a bowl last year. Golden inherited a roster thin in certain areas and it only got worse when six of his best underclassmen (led by running back Lamar Miller, receiver Tommy Streeter and defensive lineman Olivier Vernon) declared for the draft. Golden is left with a team that could still be OK on defense but has almost no experience at the offensive skill positions, a mildly accomplished quarterback in Stephen Morris and a woefully thin line. This isn't nearly the rebuilding job Golden took on at Temple, but by Miami standards it is.
The good news is that Golden just brought in a terrific recruiting class and got an early look at nine enrollees this spring. Expect Golden to go with a full-on youth movement and play many of these guys right away. But then there's the Nevin Shapiro cloud. No matter how well Golden recruits and develops, the NCAA could come in at any time and drop crippling sanctions that slow the process even further. I do think Miami can become a top 10 team again -- kids still want to play there because they know the legacy of the 'Canes getting guys to the NFL -- but it could be quite a few years before it gets there.
Love the Mailbag. Quick question: Every time I see talk about Big East teams leaving for either the Big 12 or the ACC the only two mentioned are Louisville and UConn. Being an alum of Cincinnati, which has had three 10-win seasons in four years plus made the Sweet Sixteen in basketball, I was wondering why neither of those conferences seem to look at Cincinnati. Are we closer to Memphis in stature than Pitt?
-- Randy Adams, Fort Thomas, Ky.
The same thing that limits Boise State's possibilities in realignment hurts the Bearcats as well: their stadium. Nippert is a cool place to watch a game, but it only seats 35,000. Good luck convincing Texas to play there every other year. And while the program has enjoyed great fan support over the last four or five years, there was a long history of apathy before that. As a former resident I remember well the days of forcing basketball season ticket holders to buy football tickets and buy-one-get-one-free promos at Skyline. It will probably take a more sustained track record of success and support before a league like the Big 12 gives UC a look.
If the ACC implosion many are already predicting does occur, I could see that conference tapping Cincinnati as a replacement, but by then, who knows whether the Big East or ACC would be more appealing. I'll leave that to all you 16-team superconference enthusiasts to figure out.
"Program Pecking Order" was easily my favorite Mailbag answer, and I doubt I'm alone. Can you revisit this answer and let us know what five years and numerous realignments have done to your list of Kings, Barons, Knights and Peasants?
-- Chris C., Forest Hills, N.Y.
This isn't the first request of this nature. I've gotten more e-mails over the past few years asking me to revisit that column than any Mailbag I've ever written. So yes, I will be doing a 2012 update, but I'm waiting for things to slow down a bit first. Which of course means it might not happen until 2015...
Speaking of figures from Mailbags past, former West Virginia coach Bill Stewart took his share of criticism in this space, but he was without a doubt the sunniest person I've ever encountered on this beat. Both when I met him for the first time in August 2008 and in subsequent conversations, it seemed like I'd happened to catch him on the happiest day of his life -- which may well have been true, since he was living a lifelong dream coaching the Mountaineers.
On Monday, Stewart, 59, died from a heart attack suffered while playing golf, an incredibly sad and unfair ending for a man who so thoroughly enjoyed every day. Please join me in offering condolences to his family and the West Virginia community.
College Football Championship Week roundup: Michigan State spoils Ohio State's BCS hopes
Spartans spoil Ohio State's BCS title hopes