SI.com MLB College Minor League Baseball Minor League Baseball

 

Top 10 catching prospects

Posted: Sunday January 19, 2003 9:17 PM

 
Top 10 prospects
by position
Right-handed Pitchers
Left-handed Pitchers
First Basemen
Second Basemen
Third Basemen
Shortstops
Outfielders 
 

BOSTON (Ticker) -- Offensive skills for a catcher are usually the last tools to develop. So much emphasis is placed on learning how to call games, handle pitchers and stop opposing team's running games that little time is left for these players to worry about adjusting their swings.

Still, a number of prospects finished the 2002 season among their league's leaders in a number of major offensive categories, including batting average and RBIs.

An offensive stalwart, Cleveland's Victor Martinez led a league in hitting for a second consecutive season. He also displayed the ability to be a solid middle-of-the-order hitter, skills not usually linked with a catcher. As a result, is no surprise that there have been rumors of a position change to lengthen his career.

Astros farmhand John Buck finished third in the Class AA Texas League with 89 RBI, his third straight season with at least 71 RBI. Twins top-pick Joe Mauer ranked eighth in the Class A Midwest League with a .302 average and finished fifth with a .393 on-base percentage.

Despite the difficult task of having to be students of the game from all angles, the following catchers have begun to develop into well-rounded ballplayers and should make an impact in the major leagues within the next couple of seasons.

Top 10 catchers

(Note: Players with less than 200 major league at-bats were considered)

1. Victor Martinez, Indians
Martinez, who was named MVP after leading the Class A Carolina League with a .329 average in 2001, had an even better season in the Double-A Eastern League this past year. He won his second consecutive batting title with a .336 average while displaying increased power, pacing the league with a .576 slugging percentage en route to another MVP honor. The 23-year-old switch-hitter also ranked second in the loop with 62 extra-base hits, posting career-highs in both doubles (40) and home runs (22). Defensively, the native of Venezuela has soft hands and outstanding leadership ability. A weak throwing arm is the one thing keeping him from being labeled as complete.

2. Joe Mauer, Twins
The first overall pick in the 2001 draft, Mauer has quickly exhibited himself as a strong contact hitter who will develop greater power as he matures. Only 19 years old, the Minnesota native hit .302 and posted a 42-62 strikeout-to-walk ratio in his first full season. Mauer also showed his worth as a run producer, driving home 62 runs and posting a .377 average with runners in scoring position. A Florida State quarterback recruit, he has an above-average arm with accuracy and effortless movements behind the plate. Due to inexperience, Mauer still needs to develop the mental aspects of the position.

3. John Buck, Astros
After two outstanding seasons in low Class A, Buck did go through some offensive struggles in the Double-A Texas League last season. Although he did set a career high in RBI, the 6-3, 210-pounder did lose some consistency at the plate. He hit below .240 in two separate months and had a 3-to-1 strikeout-to-walk ratio. Still, Buck finished with a .263 average and flashed tremendous power. Behind the plate, the 22-year-old is as competent as any catcher in the minors. Buck excels at game-calling and handling of pitchers, blocks the plate very well and owns a strong arm.

4. Jeff Mathis, Angels
A surprise first-round pick in the 2001 draft, Mathis has not failed to live up to the organization's lofty expectations so far. Despite missing some playing time in 2001 because of a broken hand, the 19-year-old shined in his first full season in the Class A Midwest League last year. Mathis hit .287, drove in 73 runs and finished second in the circuit with 41 doubles. He has outstanding physical tools that are matched only by his work ethic and leadership. With an above-average arm, Mathis finished fifth in the Midwest by throwing out 37 percent of would-be basestealers.

5. Justin Huber, Mets
A native of Australia, Huber was one of the top offensive players in the lower level Class A South Atlantic League during the first half of last season. His .318 average, 10 home runs and 69 RBI in 73 games earned him a unanimous bid to the league's all-star team and talk of a triple crown. The 20-year-old earned a promotion to the high Class A Florida State in mid-July and finished with a .286 average, 14 homers and 93 RBI. A patient hitter, Huber knows how to take pitches and work the strike zone. Behind the plate, he displays his love of the game with his intelligence. He works hard with pitchers and continuously studies game situations.

6. Kevin Cash, Blue Jays
Despite not playing at the position before signing with Toronto as a non-drafted free agent in 1999, Cash has turned himself into the top defensive receiver in the organization, earning a late-season callup to the majors in just his third season. The Florida native has a very strong arm, a quick release and solid footwork. Last season, the 24-year-old threw out 43 percent of attempted basestealers between the Double-A and Triple-A classes. Offensively, Cash has limited skills, but did reach career highs in both doubles (33) and homers (18) last year. Cash compensates for a high number of strikeouts with a decent walk total.

7. Miguel Olivo, White Sox
Traded by the Oakland Athletics in December of 2000 for relief pitcher Chad Bradford, Olivo put together his second strong season in Double-A and earned a late-season promotion to Comiskey. The 24-year-old has a plus arm and cat-like agility behind the plate. He still needs to improve some of his receiving skills, including the handling of top-notch pitchers. On the offensive side, Olivo has a nice mix of both speed and power. Last season, he stole 29 bases in 42 attempts and led Birmingham with 10 triples. He also had a career-high 24 doubles and finished with a .479 slugging percentage. Olivo displayed improved patience and a good batting eye.

8. Kelly Shoppach, Red Sox
Making his professional debut in the advanced Class A Florida State League last season, Shoppach played extremely well and was named to the league's all-star team. A defensive stalwart, Shoppach threw out 33 percent of attempted basestealers and displayed natural leadership skills. He also blocked balls very well and improved as a game-caller as the season went on. The 22-year-old showed good gap power, finishing with 35 doubles, but struggled with his contact at times. Despite a high strikeout total, Shoppach had good discipline, drawing 59 walks in 414 at-bats. A small tear in his shoulder in September forced him to miss playing in the Arizona Fall League.

9. Josh Bard, Indians
Acquired from Colorado in a mid-season trade in 2001, Bard raised his stock this past season by impressing many in the organization in spring training and putting together a strong showing in the Triple-A International League. Originally a third-round pick of the Rockies in 1999, Bard hit .297 with 53 RBI in 94 games with Buffalo, but it was his defense that got him called up to Cleveland in late August. He threw out 39 percent of basestealers and was a reason for the club ranking near the top in a number of pitching categories. At 6-3 and 200 pounds, Bard has excellent size and does a good job blocking balls. With Einar Diaz traded to Texas, the 24-year-old should be a serious contender for the starting job in Cleveland in 2003.

10. Koyie Hill, Dodgers
Catching in just his second full season, Hill showed solid defensive skills while batting .271 with 64 RBI in 130 games in the Double-A Southern League. A converted third baseman, Hill has strong throwing skills, highlighted by a quick release, and gunned down 33 percent of attempted basestealers. He has also earned praise for his work with the staff in Jacksonville. A fourth-round pick of the Dodgers in 2000, Hill is streaky with the bat. A solid switch-hitter with some occasional pop, the 23-year-old knows how to take pitches, recording nearly as many walks as strikeouts in 2002. He did well in the Arizona Fall League this past fall, hitting .308 with eight RBI in 75 at-bats.

Others to watch: Craig Ansman (Diamondbacks), Dane Sardinha (Reds), David Parrish (Yankees), Jared Abruzzo (Angels), J.D. Closser (Diamondbacks).

 
Related information
Stories
Top 10 prospects by position: RHP | LHP | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | OF
Multimedia
Visit Video Plus for the latest audio and video

© 2003 SportsTicker Enterprises, LP

 


 
CNNSI