CNN/SI

The New York Yankees Greatest Hits
Main page
Poll
Which team is the Yankees' greatest of all time?
1998 (114-48)
1996 (92-70)
1978 (100-63)
1961 (109-53)
1953 (99-52)
1927 (110-44)

View Results

Photo galleries
Flashback
Multimedia
Your Turn

CNN/SI Links
Baseball main page
NYY team page
NYY batting stats
NYY pitching stats

 
1927 vs 1998 1978 vs 1998 1996 vs 1998 alltime.html winningcombo.html baberuth.html covers.html

  
Your Turn

Your Favorite Yankees

CNN/SI asked for your favorite Yankees players of alltime. Chuck Knoblauch wasn't mentioned, but here's a selection of some who were. Click here to submit your own favorite Yankee.

Posted: Mon October 12, 1998

 
Other Your Turn features:
Who is your favorite Yankee?
Send a letter to the Boss
Why I hate the Yankees

Your Turn responses:
Why I hate the Yankees
Thanks, Boss

First of all, I have the utmost respect for this team. In my eyes, this is a little part of my East Coast life. I grew up in Connecticut and frequently went to Yankees games at a young age. When I moved to Boston, I still watched, but moving to Phoenix limited my viewing. I love the Yankees! I am completely inspired by this team, Joe Torre's managing skills, and especially by Derek Jeter. I am 19 years old, and Derek showed me that dreams can come true, even at a young age. To me, this is the best team of all time and I know Derek's strength, agility, power, and teamwork will bring home the win in the World Series. Thank you for inspiration.
—Aileen Julianna Crowley, Phoenix

Phil Rizzuto—When I was in grade school during the late '40s and early '50s the nuns allowed us to listen to the Series on the P.A. system and the Yanks were always in the Series! I would run home for lunch and my mother would have my lunch ready on a TV tray in front of the black-and-white TV. Once my parents took my brother and I to St. Louis to see the Browns and the Yankees play and we got to stay at the same hotel (The Chase Park Plaza) as "MY" Yankees—I later found out that they had to sacrifice in order to pay for staying there. Coming down on the elevator I whispered to my dad that Allie Reynolds and Phil Rizzuto were on the elevator with us and I got their autographs ... and they are framed today in my study!
—Tom Ernst, Vincennes, Ind.

Paul O'Neill is one of the class acts in all of baseball. He has the ability to step up and make the big play whether it be with the bat, the glove or his underrated throwing arm. He has a passion that is not found in many other professional athletes. He is what Yankee Baseball is all about.
—Erik Kurtenbach, Kansas City, Kan.

Thurman Munson was my favorite alltime Yankee. He was not the best athlete, but he made use of the tools that he had. He did his job quietly, well, and challenged The Boss when he needed to. One of the biggest tragedies in Yankee history is that we never got to see him fill out his career. I was about 10 years old when he died, but I think if I was 30, I would've cried just as hard.
—Brian Olson, Greenbelt, Md.

Roger Maris is still my favorite Yankee. Actually he is the only Yankee that I will ever like. Most of this stems from the fact that he is a North Dakota boy, and the reason that I hate all other Yankees is for the way that his teammates and the organization treated him. All the while he was bringing attention to the Yankees, the players and management we all treating him with disrespect behind his back. Without him the Yankees would not have won the World Series that year since everyone's god-child Mantle was unable to handle the pressure of the home run race and pulled a fake injury. It was Maris who carried that team for the years that he was there. Do you really think that Mantle would have had those great years without Maris behind him to protect him? I don't think so. As far as I am concerned I hope the Yankees fail big in the playoffs and never reach the World Series again.
—Justin Fast, Minot, N.D.

Joe Torre.

He is a leader with character, and a picture of calm, a giver of compassion, who manages with canny calculation, yet comprehends that it's far more important for a patient with cancer to be the conqueror, than it is for a team to lay claim to the title of champions.
—Jim Carver, Ephrata, Pa.

Mickey Mantle.

I grew up in northern Maine, where everyone was a Red Sox fan. Something drew me to the Yankees. To me they represented class, confidence and success. When I was nine years old, my father took me to my first major league game, the Yankees vs. the Red Sox at Fenway Park. I can still see the Mick's mammoth home run disappearing into the right field seats. Yankees 8, Red Sox 0. I was hooked for life as a Yankees fan, despite more than a decade of futility. To me, Mickey Mantle was strength and speed, everything a baseball player was supposed to be. He wasn't a perfect human being, but he made a little boy very happy. To me he'll always be "the man". I'm still a Yankee fan in Red Sox territory, and proud of it.
—Bill Boynton, Concord, N.H.

Sorry guys, it's a tie...

Dave Winfield: he used to live in Teaneck and paid for renovations of parks and was consistently kind to children (example: Halloween trick-or-treaters at his house)

Paul O'Neill: Mr. Intensity. Plus, he's consistent and a realist. O'Neill surely could have signed for more than he did, but comments, "How much can I spend?" at his press conference. He loves N.Y. and the city loves him.
—Ken Kotkin, Teaneck, N.J.

Don Mattingly.

Never was there a player who truly embodied the spirit of what it meant to be a New York Yankee as did Donnie Baseball. Although he'll probably never be enshrined in Cooperstown since his post-'88 numbers don't match up with those of most Hall of Famers, #23 will be immortalized in the hearts of all Yankee fans who saw him play. His character and leadership carried us through the dismal early-'90s seasons to the renaissance we are experiencing now. The only shame is that he didn't get to play in the World Series in '96. But in the hearts of the Yankee faithful, there was never a greater champion. His work ethic and determination, even in his worst seasons, made him a perfect role model for New York-area kids. The President of the United States could learn a few things about integrity from the Hitman.
—Chris Kivlehan, Ridgewood, N.J.

Reggie Jackson. Although he caused a lot of turmoil in the Bronx, nothing meant more to him than winning and nothing less was accepted by him. I admired his style as well!
—Tom Munzer, New York City

Lou Gehrig stands above others as what a Yankee should be. A native of New York himself, he embodied all that was New York (the son of immigrants) and the Yankees (an unmatched record of greatness over a very long time) by playing hard and doing it day-in and day-out. And when it was time for him to leave, he did so with perhaps the greatest speech in sports history.
—Anthony Fashana, Walnut Creek, Calif.

It's tough to pick a favorite, but I sure did enjoy watching Goose Gossage pitch, and Graig Nettles play third, especially in the the late '70s. The bottom line is I love the Yanks because they embrace tradition, style and class (especially as of late). They manage to succeed in one of the toughest towns in which to play professional sports. The '80s and early '90s were certainly no joy ride, but it was worth the wait.
—Jonathan Danz, Glen Rock, Pa.

Willie Randolph is my favorite Yankee of all-time. Willie was my childhood idol because he represented, to me, what the game is all about. He played hard everyday and was a true sportsman, showing class on and off the field. Willie personifies what being a Yankee really means.
—Craig Sabatello, Medford, Mass.

My favorite Yankee of all time is George Steinbrenner. What a shocker, but George is a great man who is misunderstood. All he wants to do is win..No matter who he alienates or fires, he'll always bring them back to the Bronx. He continues to go out and spend big money for big-time players. He may have made mistakes (Jay Buhner) but always learns from them (David Cone, Chuck Knoblauch, Reggie Jackson and El Duque). George goes for talent and has a win-now attitude. To hell with planning for the future ... win now!
—Erik Swanson, Point Pleasant Beach, N.J.

Bobby Richardson is my favorite Yankee of all time. He was an exceptionally fine defensive player and a consummate professional. Richardson's contributions were lost in the lineup of great Yankee players in the 1960s. Bobby Richardson was a positive role model long before America realized that we needed them.
—Richard Mikula, Middletown, N.J.

Yogi Berra.

He was baseball. No flash, just a baseball man on a team of superstars. He played with grit and never never quit. He never cried and at least appeared to love the Yankees. I think he hit more homers on balls than strikes. His life was baseball and his love was baseball. Baseball never had a better role model for any walk of life. If we all put the effort in our lives that Yogi put in baseball, it would truly be a better world.
—Ed Woodall, Rockwood, Tenn.

Mickey Rivers—He was hard to get out. You didn't know if he was hitting away or bunting. His lightning speed on the bases made pitchers terribly nervous. A routine ground ball had to be fielded clean or Mickey was legging out a single.
—Troy Porter, Savage, Minn.

Joe DiMaggio, the Yankee Clipper. My grandpa used to take me to see the Norfolk Tars play. His favorite was Phil "Scooter" Rizzuto. Now this was back in the early '30s, around '33 or '34. I was five at the time. Many of the great Yankees played for the Norfolk Tars, however, Joe DiMaggio came through their West Coast farm system. When the Yankees played the Tars in the spring on their way north, I first saw Joe play. He was my idol. His swing was so beautiful. His power was amazing. Thru his years with the Yankees, his was what baseball was all about. A class Yankee and a class gentleman who was a role model for a little boy who now is an old man with fond memories of my Yankees and Joe DiMaggio.
—Harry Thompson, Emerald Isle, N.C.

Whitey Ford—He always seemed to pitch well enough to win, whether he needed to shut down the competition or could give up six or seven runs. I saw many times when he gave up two hits in an inning and would then shut out the other batters.
—Joe Sime, Lake Havasu City, Ariz.

Pasqual Perez and Melido Perez. They were never were able to truly demonstrate their abilities.
—Stan Dempsey, Boulder, Colo.

Babe Ruth made baseball "America's Pastime" back in the '20s and has to be considered one of the top baseball players of all time, probably the greatest. Combined with a larger-than-life personality, his fan-friendliness, and impact on American sports and culture (especially at a time when baseball needed it)—he's the best!!
—Mark Sierra, Menlo Park, Calif.

My favorite Yankee ever was Ricky Henderson. He is the best leadoff man to ever play the game and best base-stealer. Growing up I imitated everything this guy did on the field. Things like my batting stance, taking my lead at first, and even perfecting the infamous "Ricky snatch" in the outfield. He is a nice guy overall, and is guaranteed a spot in Cooperstown.
—Jason Merryman, Princeton, N.J.

Bucky Dent is my favourite Yankee of alltime. His image at shortstop at Yankee Stadium will indelibly be etched in my memory. Why? For one, he was a Yankee shortstop; my favourite team and my favorite position. Secondly, his name—Bucky —has got to be one of the quintessential baseball names. Although not flashy, he played shortstop as consistently well and reliably as any Yankee ever. And finally, I will never forget seeing him hit the home run to beat the Red Sox in that one-game playoff.
—David Ballam, Toronto

Other Your Turn features:
Who is your favorite Yankee of all time?
Why I hate the Yankees



Back to the top

Copyright © 1999 CNN/SI. A Time Warner Company.
All Rights Reserved.

Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines.