CNN/SI

The New York Yankees Greatest Hits
Main page
Poll
Which team is the Yankees' greatest of all time?
1998 (114-48)
1996 (92-70)
1978 (100-63)
1961 (109-53)
1953 (99-52)
1927 (110-44)

View Results

Photo galleries
Flashback
Multimedia
Your Turn

CNN/SI Links
Baseball main page
NYY team page
NYY batting stats
NYY pitching stats

 
1927 vs 1998 1978 vs 1998 1996 vs 1998 alltime.html winningcombo.html baberuth.html covers.html

  
Your Turn

Why do you hate the Yankees?

We asked CNN/SI users for reasons to hate the A.L. champs, and the replies rained down like batteries from the bleachers at Yankee Stadium. And we found out that there is a huge need for a Red Sox support group.

Posted: Fri October 16, 1998

 
Other Your Turn features:
Who is your favorite Yankee?
Send a letter to the Boss
Why I hate the Yankees

Your Turn responses:
Thanks, Boss
CNN/SI users' favorite Yankees

You ruptured the innocence of every 13-year-old Red Sox fan from 1977-'78, including this one. For that, I forever despise you and your heathen fans!
—Bill Grady, Nashua, N.H.

They are from New York. If the same team played in Kansas City or Tampa Bay they would only be remembered as a good team, not the greatest team of all time. Also they have all of the east coast media fueling the fire of their greatness. George Steinbrenner might as well have said it, the smaller markets can't compete with New York.
—Scott Carter, Palatka, Fla.

The baseball gods were either on vacation or on crack in 1996 because pixie dust and Cinderella slippers smell like dog-doo when they're put on high-priced mercenaries in pinstripes. The Yankees are way overdue for a massive kharmic rebate, and I just hope I'm around long enough to see the reckoning.
—J. Lanier, Atlanta

Do you remember that kid [Jeffrey Maier] who robbed the game from the Orioles in '96, who completely changed the momentum of the postseason? Well, that kid embodies the essence of New York, the greed of Wall Street, the pushing to the front of the line at the subway, and the holier-than-thou attitude those Yankees fans feed on. The Yankees have had the great good fortune of signing some of the great players of all time—Reggie, Joe, Mickey, etc—but baseball is not about singular players; it is American myth, unfolding legend. And those legends are not born out of the cold, drab, self-absorbed world of New Yorkers, in the ruthless dictatorship of George Steinbrenner—the same loser who fired Billy Martin about two million times. I hate the Yankees and I don't need to justify it, just as I don't need to justify breathing. It is simply innate.
—Adil Haq, McLean, Va.

Oh, let me count the ways: Derek Jeter - one of the cockiest players around. He thinks he's the greatest, and he's not even the third best at his position in the American League!!! Then of course there's Paul O'Neill (Mr. Happy) — Paul, if it's not fun, then sell cars or something. Joe Torre — the most overrated manager, next to Bobby Cox, that has ever been. Let's see what he could do without George feeding him free-agents. Andy Pettitte - overrated. GEORGE - I've got an idea - build a team, don't buy one. Hell, now George is waiting along the beaches for the rafts to wash up the defecting Cubans so he can sign them!
—Gary Tomko, Glasgow

How can you not?
—Moses Tatman, Salem, Ore.

To root for the Yankees is to root for man's worst instincts to triumph: It's to wish for the rich to triumph over the poor, powerful corporations to crush entrepreneurs, Goliath over David....rooting for the Yankees is like rooting against the Joads in The Grapes of Wrath.
—Bill Hatton, Philadelphia

1. Bucky Dent
2. "No No Nanette"
3. A city whose leading newspaper has a sports section as weak as The New York Times doesn't deserve a good team.
4. They're New Yorkers, for heaven's sake.
5. Tedious Seinfeld plots
—Jacob T. Levy, Portsmouth, N.H.

Because when Steinbrenner made Dave Winfield the first $1 million man, he started what has become the downfall of modern sports. Because Ted Williams should have been named MVP in 1941, not Joe DiMaggio. Because Mickey Rivers gave Bucky Dent a corked bat. Because we didn't get anything in return for Babe Ruth.
—Matt Lotspeich, York Beach, Maine

They need 12-year-olds to help them win the pennant.
—Regina Edwards, Burke, Va.

One reason? How about 114 reasons?
—Stuart Spencer, Scranton, N.C.

Two Words: Bucky Dent
—Chris Miller, Boston, Mass.

Steinbrenner
Jeter
Knoblauch
O'Neill
Williams
Martinez
Posada
Girardi
Spencer
Brosius
Strawberry
Curtis
Ledee
and don't forget
Cone
Pettitte
Irabu
Wells
Hernandez
Mendoza
and of course
George Steinbrenner again.
—Patrick Watson, Columbus, Ohio

Other Your Turn features:
Who is your favorite Yankee of all time?
Why I hate the Yankees
Send a letter to the Boss



Back to the top

Copyright © 1999 CNN/SI. A Time Warner Company.
All Rights Reserved.

Terms under which this service is provided to you.
Read our privacy guidelines.