Now Verlander will be on the mound in Game 5 of a division series that has been completely turned around by the Oakland Athletics heading into Thursday night's decisive matchup at the O.co Coliseum.
Detroit took a 3-1 lead into the bottom of the ninth inning Wednesday before Oakland scored three times off Jose Valverde to tie this series at two games apiece.
"When we lose a game like this and I need three outs for my team to clinch, it hurts," Valverde said. "This is the toughest moment in my whole career."
The Athletics used 14 walkoff wins in the regular season to capture an improbable AL West title so Wednesday's dramatics didn't come as a surprise."There's a confidence," manager Bob Melvin said. "We've done it so many times so there's always going to be that confidence until we make that last out."
Oakland has now won eight straight at home dating to the regular season to gain a chance to break its Game 5 division series hex when the club dropped decisive contests from 2000-03.
The task won't be easy against Verlander (1-0, 1.29 ERA), who is 3-0 with a 0.90 ERA in three starts against the Athletics this year. That includes his victory in Game 1 on Saturday when he struck out 11 and gave up one run in a 3-1 win.
"I'm going to try to treat it like another start, kind of like the last start as much as I can," Verlander said. "Obviously it's a big game for us. ... We allowed ourselves to be in this position, we know it's not easy to win here. We put ourselves in position to win one."
Game 1 started in promising fashion for Oakland as Crisp led off with a homer and Verlander was forced to throw 61 pitches through three innings. The ace got stronger and needed 60 pitches over the next four including five straight strikeouts in one stretch.
"The problem is that he'll throw 130 pitches in a game," Melvin said. "Even if you get his pitch count up there, it doesn't mean he's going to come out of the game at 100 or 105 pitches, he's a tough customer."
Including the postseason, Verlander has posted a 0.77 ERA in winning five straight starts with 38 strikeouts over 35 innings.
Crisp is probably the biggest threat to him with a .346 average including playoffs. No other Oakland hitter with more than five at-bats against the reigning AL MVP and Cy Young Award winner is hitting better than .222.
Jarrod Parker (0-1, 2.84) is looking forward to a rematch with Verlander after coming up short in Game 1, allowing three runs over 6 1-3 innings.
"It's going to be fun," Parker said. "I think it's what makes this time of year great. We both have a chance to do a lot of special things."
"It's big," Parker said. "Obviously they're going to make that adjustment, as well. As long as I'm one or two pitches ahead of them, I think I'll be all right in terms of going at them."
Triple Crown winner Cabrera is 2 for 8 with no extra-base hits in the last two games for Detroit while Fielder went 2 for 4 with a homer Wednesday after starting the series 1 for 12.
Crisp, meanwhile, continues to be the center of attention in this series. He homered off Verlander to begin it, committed an error in Game 2 that allowed two runs to score in a 5-4 defeat, robbed Fielder of a homer in Tuesday's 2-0 victory and ended Wednesday's contest with his latest clutch hit.
Is he ready to deliver an encore in Game 5?
"Just go out and give it 100 percent," Crisp said. "That's all we can do and that's all we can continue to do. Hopefully it ends in our favor again."
OAKLAND, Calif. (AP) -- Once he finally made his way to the victorious visiting clubhouse, Justin Verlander 's teammates greeted him with chants of " Cy Young !" and sprayed him in the face with bubbly.
Already among baseball's best starters, Verlander showed he sure can finish.
Detroit's ace and MVP bookended the AL division series with 11-strikeout gems, throwing a four-hitter in the decisive fifth game to get the Tigers back to the AL championship series for a second straight year with a 6-0 victory over the Oakland Athletics on Thursday night.
"I thought he might have thrown 300 pitches if he had to," slugger Prince Fielder said. "He wasn't coming out of the game. No way."
Verlander delivered a day after closer Jose Valverde failed to hold a ninth-inning lead as Detroit was pushed to the brink after jumping out to a 2-0 series lead back home at Comerica Park.
Verlander tossed his first career postseason shutout and complete game with a 122-pitch masterpiece.
"He had a look in his eye today," manager Jim Leyland said. "A complete-game look in his eye."
The Tigers will face either the New York Yankees or Baltimore Orioles , tied at two games apiece heading into Game 5 on Friday night in New York. Game 1 of the ALCS is scheduled for Saturday.
Verlander, the reigning AL Cy Young Award winner and MVP, was so sharp nobody in the bullpen ever got up to throw. He struck out 22 in his wins on both ends of this nail-biting series.
After squandering two chances to clinch the series, including blowing a two-run ninth-inning lead in Game 4, Leyland left it all up to Verlander just as he said he would.
"I think it's one of those things I expected to go nine innings," Verlander said. "In this situation, in a Game 5, I wanted to go all the way."
Austin Jackson hit an RBI double in the third and a run-scoring single as the Tigers added on with a four-run seventh. Fielder had an RBI single.
The Tigers are on to another ALCS despite getting just one RBI all series from Triple Crown winner Miguel Cabrera - on a bases-loaded hit by pitch, no less. Booed by the yellow towel-waving sellout crowd of 36,393 each time he stepped into the batter's box. Cabrera finished 5 for 20, and it was his blooper dropped by Coco Crisp in a 5-4 Game 2 victory Sunday that allowed two runs to score.
Leyland all but called Verlander's latest gem.
" Justin Verlander 's a pretty tough chore for anybody," Leyland said.
The Detroit skipper gave the ball to his 17-game winner and said beforehand the Tigers would likely win or lose with the hard-throwing right-hander on the mound.
And, against the A's - or anybody else, for that matter - Verlander usually wins.
"This is where legends are made," catcher Alex Avila said. "Tonight, he basically put us on his back and said, `We're not going to lose."'
Verlander recorded the most strikeouts in a shutout of a winner-take-all postseason game, topping Sandy Koufax 's 10 in the 1965 World Series against Minnesota.
"When you're going into pressure situations like this, there's nobody better to have on the mound than Justin," Jackson said.
Verlander followed up an 11-strikeout outing in Detroit's 3-1 Game 1 win Saturday with another overpowering performance in his 10th postseason start. He improved to 3-0 with a 2.11 ERA in three postseason starts against the A's and upped his career mark to 5-4 with 2.15 ERA in 10 starts at the Coliseum.
Verlander had allowed one earned run with a 0.69 ERA in beating the A's twice during the regular season.
"He's always tough. You go out there and you battle him the best that you can," Crisp said. "Today he had some of his best stuff of the year."
Detroit finally got to party in a visiting clubhouse that for the sixth straight game was prepped for a possible clinch celebration.
The Texas Rangers were in town last week needing one victory to win the AL West but dropped all three to lose the division to the surprising A's in Game No. 162.
On Wednesday night, plastic covering the floor and lockers was torn down in all of about 40 seconds after Valverde allowed three runs in the bottom of the ninth as Oakland won with another walkoff in a season full of them.
This time, the Tigers let loose.
Verlander hollered "Whoo!" when he entered the clubhouse and quickly ran to a table to grab a celebratory bottle before being doused from all directions.
"It was awesome and horrible at the same time because you can't see a thing," he said. "Your eyes are burning and all I want to do is look up and celebrate with my teammates. And all I can do is look down and shut my eyes."
After Seth Smith grounded out to end the game, the A's stayed on the field to greet the fans who were still on their feet chanting "Let's Go Oakland!" Verlander waved toward the Oakland players in a classy acknowledgment.
Detroit's offense did more than enough to give Verlander a cushion on another relatively quiet night by Cabrera and Fielder, the team's $214 million cleanup hitter.
Cabrera went five straight games without an RBI on four different occasions during the regular season, but didn't extend that to the playoffs when Ryan Cook plunked him with the bases loaded in the seventh.
Oakland's miscues on the mound only helped matters.
Omar Infante singled to start the third inning against A's starter Jarrod Parker , then moved to second on a wild pitch. Then, with Cabrera batting after Jackson's double and a sacrifice by Quintin Berry that moved him up a base, Parker threw another wild pitch that allowed Jackson to score.
The upstart A's were attempting to become the ninth team to rally from a 2-0 deficit in a best-of-five series, but couldn't match the cross-bay Giants after San Francisco won at Cincinnati earlier in the day to reach the NLCS.
So much for all that chatter about another Bay Bridge World Series in Northern California like the earthquake-interrupted Series in 1989 swept by the A's.
Oakland struck out 50 times in a series of swings and misses riding high only a week ago after stunning the two-time reigning AL champion Rangers on the regular season's final day to win the AL West. The Ks were the most in A's franchise history for a five-game series.
The A's payroll of $59.5 million is lowest in the majors. But the last game was the only lopsided one.
Detroit eliminated Oakland again after the Tigers pulled off a four-game sweep in the 2006 AL championship series.
"We didn't think it was going to end today, not for a second," A's manager Bob Melvin said. "We knew we were going up against a good pitcher. That didn't mean we didn't think we were going to win. We've gone up against good pitchers this year. And it's a bit of a shock when it finally does end. It was a heck of a story. It was a heck of a run for us."
The Tigers now look to get through another round after falling in six games to the Rangers in last year's ALCS.
NOTES: Josh Reddick , who hit a team-leading 32 homers, struck out 10 times for the most by an A's player in a postseason series. The only person with more Ks than Reddick in a division series was Seattle's Bret Boone with 11 in 2001. ... The A's have lost eight of their last nine postseason series. ... Cabrera has reached base safely in all 16 of his postseason games with the Tigers. ... Verlander is Detroit's all-time postseason leader in strikeouts (70) and wins (5).