It may be time to put that plan in place in the second game.
Cabrera enjoyed success over the previous two seasons against Jeanmar Gomez , who gets the ball Tuesday night with the visiting Pirates unbeaten in his five starts.
Hurdle called the reigning AL MVP the best hitter in baseball Monday before Pittsburgh's 6-5 loss. The manager said he would take his chances with Prince Fielder if he had to walk Cabrera, who entered this series on a 12-game hitting streak while batting .435 with seven homers and 17 RBIs.
"You're going to pass on Cabrera more often that not, and take whatever comes your way with Fielder," Hurdle told the Pirates' official website.
Cabrera went 0 for 4 with three strikeouts, marking the second time over the last three seasons he has struck out that many times. He went 6 for 24 with just one walk last season against the Pirates (31-20).
The slugger is 4 for 9 with two homers and a walk since the start of 2011 against Gomez (2-0, 2.75 ERA), who had been with Cleveland before joining Pittsburgh during the offseason. Gomez is 2-2 in five starts against the Tigers with a 7.82 ERA - his third-highest against any opponent.
The right-hander has yet to last past five innings in five starts since being promoted from the bullpen, but the efforts have been good enough for the Pirates to win all of them. He won his big-league debut in 2010 against Detroit (29-20), but owns a 13.50 ERA in three career starts at Comerica Park.
Jhonny Peralta is 2 for 9 against Gomez, but he's hitting .429 over an eight-game hitting streak after going 4 for 4 on Monday. It was Peralta's first four-hit game since June 4, 2010, for Cleveland.
"He's swinging a magic wand right now," Tigers outfielder Torii Hunter said. "He can poke the bat out and get a hit. He can swing hard and get a hit. It's a lot of fun to play the game like that."
Detroit has won six of seven after handing Pittsburgh just its third loss in 13 games.
Pirates third baseman Brandon Inge , who played for the Tigers for over a decade and received an AL championship ring before Monday's contest, was a late addition to the starting lineup. Outfielder Starling Marte was removed shortly before the game because of migraine-like symptoms, and the ensuing shuffling of the lineup gave Inge his first chance to play at Comerica Park as a member of the visiting team.
Inge went 0 for 4 with three strikeouts as Pittsburgh struck out 15 times - 13 against Justin Verlander .
The Pirates will try to regroup against Rick Porcello (2-2, 6.28), who is 2-0 with a 0.60 ERA in two starts against them.
Porcello is 2-0 with a 3.24 ERA over his last five starts after going 0-2 with a 13.09 mark in his first three.
However, the right-hander may have taken a step back Thursday as he allowed five runs and a season-high 10 hits over five innings, not getting a decision in a 7-6 win over Minnesota. He struck out two after totaling 24 over his previous four outings.
|May 25, 2013||Jose Tabata||15-Day DL||Strained left oblique - out 3-4 weeks|
|May 19, 2013||Andrew McCutchen||Day-to-Day||Sore right knee|
|May 15, 2013||John McDonald||15-Day DL||Lower back discomfort|
|May 01, 2013||James McDonald||15-Day DL||Right shoulder discomfort|
|April 27, 2013||Travis Snider||Day-to-Day||Left side discomfort|
|April 27, 2013||Neil Walker||15-Day DL||Right index finger laceration|
|May 12, 2013||Austin Jackson||15-Day DL||Strained right hamstring|
|April 26, 2013||Phil Coke||15-Day DL||Left groin strain|
|April 26, 2013||Phil Coke||15-Day DL||Left groin strain|
|April 21, 2013||Octavio Dotel||Day-to-Day||Elbow inflammation|
|April 20, 2013||Octavio Dotel||15-Day DL||Right elbow inflammation|
|April 09, 2013||Victor Martinez||Day-to-Day||Lacerated right thumb|
DETROIT (AP) -- Jason Grilli has picked up a lot of saves in his years as a closer, but none tougher than what he had to do against the Detroit Tigers on Tuesday night.
Grilli came into the game in the bottom of the 11th inning with the Pittsburgh Pirates clinging to a 1-0 lead and the heart of Detroit's order - Torii Hunter , Miguel Cabrera and Prince Fielder - awaiting him.
"That's as good as it gets in any lineup in the game," Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said. "That's why you have a closer."
For Grilli, it also meant trying to finish a game at Comerica Park - a stadium where he had been booed relentlessly at the end of his four-season stint with the Tigers.
"I have nothing but great memories of this place," Grilli said. "This is where Jim (Leyland) turned me into a reliever, and despite what the media might think I love coming back here."
If the situation or the setting bothered Grilli, it certainly didn't show. He struck out Hunter, Cabrera and Fielder in order, ending the game as the clock approached 11:30 p.m.
"That's a great offense, and Miguel Cabrera is probably the best hitter in baseball right now," Grilli said. "So I was trying to not make a big mistake, but you can't spend much time thinking about that. You just go out there and win the game."
Grilli certainly impressed the first of his victims while posting his 21st save in as many chances.
"I faced him when I was in Minnesota and he was here in Detroit, and he's a different pitcher now," Hunter said. "He's smart and he's got a little deception going. He jumps out at you, and before you know it, the ball is gone."
Leyland knows just how far Grilli has come since moving to the bullpen in 2006.
"He's found a home and he's found a role and he's been terrific," he said. "That's 21-for-21, and to do that against the heart of our order - that's impressive."
Grilli finished what Jeanmar Gomez had started. Gomez matched a career best with seven shutout innings in a duel with Detroit's Rick Porcello , who worked eight.
"I was just feeling really good today," said Gomez, who threw only 73 pitches. "Every one of my pitches was working, so I was working ahead in the count and down in the zone. That's what made it good."
The game was scoreless until Neil Walker - the brother-in-law of Tigers center fielder Don Kelly - homered off Jose Ortega (0-2) with one out in the top of the 11th.
"I've been swinging the bat really well on this road trip, and I've been getting the barrel on the ball just about every night," Walker said. "That kid throws hard, but he kind of floated a slider into the strike zone and I was able to drive it."
Mark Melanson (1-0) picked up the win with a scoreless 10th inning for Pittsburgh.
Porcello also matched a career best with his eight innings and struck out a career-high 11 batters. Porcello isn't the first Tigers pitcher to dominate Pittsburgh at Comerica Park. Last season, Justin Verlander took a no-hitter into the ninth against the Pirates, two days before Max Scherzer struck out 15 batters in a 4-3 victory.
"Someone said to me today that we seem to strike out a lot in this ballpark," Hurdle said. "I told them to look at Detroit's pitching staff. Everyone strikes out a lot against those guys."
Gomez got some help from center fielder Andrew McCutchen , who made a running catch to rob Andy Dirks of extra bases in the third inning and another to steal a double from Fielder in the seventh.
Pedro Alvarez led off the eighth with a single and took second when Travis Snider walked - the first time either team had put a runner into scoring position - but Porcello got Clint Barmes to ground into an inning-ending double play.
In the bottom of the inning, Omar Infante got to second on a one-out throwing error by Barmes at shortstop. Reliever Justin Wilson retired pinch-hitter Brayan Pena on a ground ball, and struck out Dirks.
Walker singled off Joaquin Benoit in the ninth, stole second and took third on Pena's throwing error, but Garrett Jones flew out to end the threat. Victor Martinez almost ended the deadlock in the bottom of the ninth, but Starling Marte made a running catch of his liner at the fence in left.
Both teams put runners into scoring position in the 10th, but couldn't get a run across until Walker's no-doubt homer in the 11th.
"We had chances in the eighth, ninth and 10th, but we couldn't get the big hit," Hurdle said. "We finally got that in the 11th."
NOTES: The start of the game was delayed 1:13 by rain. ... The Pirates placed Jose Contreras (low back inflammation) on the 15-day disabled list and recalled reliever Bryan Morris from Triple-A Indianapolis. ... The Tigers have struck out 10 or more batters 28 times - the second-highest total in franchise history behind last season's 50. Detroit is currently on pace for 91 double-digit games. ... Porcello pitched into the ninth on July 21, 2012 against the White Sox, but didn't record an out.