Check your Mail!

CNN Time Free Email US Sports Baseball Pro Football College Football 1999 NBA Playoffs College Basketball Hockey Golf Plus Tennis Soccer Motorsports Womens More Inside Game Scoreboards World
EVENTS
MLB Playoffs
Rugby World Cup
Century's Best
Swimsuit '99

CENTERS
 Fantasy Central
 Inside Game
 Multimedia Central
 Statitudes
 Your Turn
 Teams
 Cities

AD PARTNERS

  Power of Caring
  presented by CIGNA


SPORTS ILLUSTRATED
 This Week's Issue
 Previous Issues
 Special Features
 Life of Reilly
 Frank Deford
 Subscriber Services
 SI for Women

FEATURES
 Trivia Blitz
 Free Email

TELEVISION
 CNN/SI - TV
 Turner Sports

SHOPPING
 CNN/SI Travel
 Golf Pro Shop
 MLB Gear Store
 NFL Gear Store

SI FOR KIDS
 Sports Parents
 Games
 Buzz World
 Shorter Reporter

SITE RESOURCES
 About Us
 myCNN
 
baseball

Baseball Scoreboards Schedules Standings Stats Teams Players All-Time Stats Minors College

Baseball Notebook

Picking an All-Star team no easy chore

Click here for more on this story

Posted: Saturday July 03, 1999 04:48 PM

  Jim Thome is such a likable guy that Cleveland fans will likely make him an All Star starter, without considering his unimpressive stats. AP

NEW YORK (AP) -- Before all the bickering begins about who gets picked for the All-Star team and who does not, blame the whole thing on Terry Steinbach.

Sure, he's a nice enough catcher. In fact, he was the MVP of the 1988 All-Star Game.

But because of the rule that every team in the majors must have one representative, Steinbach (.298, 3 HRs, 21 RBIs going into the weekend) might wind up as Minnesota's participant.

And that could start a series of shifts as Yankees manager Joe Torre and AL president Gene Budig try to assemble their team for the event July 13 at Fenway Park.

Of course, it's easy to point the finger at fans, particularly the ones in Cleveland. They're about to elect hometown hero Jim Thome (.266, 11, 39) at first base over Rafael Palmeiro (.362, 20, 70), and that will certainly cause even more headaches for Torre and Budig.

Now, go ahead and try to pick 28-man rosters for each league. Oh, and just a few guidelines before getting started:

  • All 30 teams must have one player.
  • Torre talked this week about having nine pitchers; the NL usually takes 10. Of course, a couple of starters may deserve the honor but may not be able to pitch because of short rest.
  • It's a good idea to have a backup at every position; All-Star managers often take heat if they use a player from another team for the whole game. That means at least six outfielders, maybe more because there's a DH, too.
  • The injury factor. Some perennial stars, like Barry Bonds, have been hurt.
  • The pride factor. Some players, such as Juan Gonzalez, do not want to play unless they are elected to start.
  • The first-half factor. Always a tough call -- is the All-Star Game for 80-game wonders such as Sean Casey or for established stars or a popularity contest?
  • The first-time factor. Torre recently spoke about giving deserving guys -- perhaps B.J. Surhoff -- their first chance to play in an All-Star Game.
  • The Fenway factor. Sure would be fun to see former Red Sox stars Roger Clemens and Mo Vaughn return to Boston.
  • The favor factor. Managers have earned the right to pick players from the own teams. On the other hand, they may have favorites -- Torre likes former Yankees closer John Wetteland, for example -- on other clubs.

    OK, pretty simple, huh? No wonder managers and league presidents never like this job, especially once the griping starts.

    That said, here's a try at it before the real picks come out in a few days (x-leaders in latest fan vote):

    American League

    Anaheim: P Troy Percival. Baltimore: x-3B Cal Ripken, P Mike Mussina, OF B.J. Surhoff. Boston: P Pedro Martinez, SS Nomar Garciaparra. Chicago: OF Magglio Ordonez. Cleveland: x-1B Jim Thome, x-2B Roberto Alomar, x-OF Manny Ramirez, x-OF Kenny Lofton, P Charles Nagy. Detroit: 3B Dean Palmer. Kansas City: 2B Carlos Febles. Minnesota: C Terry Steinbach. New York: x-SS Derek Jeter, P David Cone, P Mariano Rivera, OF Bernie Williams. Oakland: P Billy Taylor. Seattle: x-OF Ken Griffey Jr. Tampa Bay: x-DH Jose Canseco. Texas: x-C Ivan Rodriguez, 1B Rafael Palmeiro, P John Wetteland, P Jeff Zimmerman. Toronto: 3B Tony Fernandez, OF Shawn Green.

    Quick Comments: Juan Gonzalez is certainly worthy, but gets left off because he only wants to start. Alex Rodriguez is deserving, but has been hurt and would not play much because Garciaparra is the hometown favorite. Roger Clemens wants to spend time with his family, and does not seem overly enthused about this game at Fenway. Ordonez gets the nod ahead of Frank Thomas, and Roberto Hernandez just misses.

    National League

    Arizona: x-3B Matt Williams, P Randy Johnson, OF Luis Gonzalez, 2B Jay Bell. Atlanta: 3B Chipper Jones. Chicago: x-OF Sammy Sosa. Cincinnati: x-SS Barry Larkin, 1B Sean Casey. Colorado: x-OF Larry Walker. Florida: SS Alex Gonzalez. Houston: x-2B Craig Biggio, 1B Jeff Bagwell, P Jose Lima, P Mike Hampton, P Billy Wagner. Los Angeles: P Kevin Brown, P Jeff Shaw. Milwaukee: C Dave Nilsson. Montreal: OF Vladimir Guerrero. New York: x-C Mike Piazza, P John Franco. Philadelphia: P Curt Schilling. Pittsburgh: C Jason Kendall. St. Louis: x-1b Mark McGwire, P Kent Bottenfield. San Diego: x-OF Tony Gwynn, P Trevor Hoffman. San Francisco: OF Barry Bonds.

    Quick Comments: Bonds has been injured, but should get to play at Fenway at least once in his career. Cubs OF Henry Rodriguez gets squeezed, as do Jeromy Burnitz, Robin Ventura and Jeff Kent. Robb Nen gets edged by Shaw's and Franco's stats. John Smoltz felt soreness in his most recent start, so he misses, but fellow Braves pitcher Greg Maddux might make it with his recent surge.

    Paying through the roof

    When the Mariners move into Safeco Field on July 15, they'll have the second-most expensive ticket in baseball.

    Among the 382 Diamond Club seats behind home plate will be 28 first-row seats costing $195 per game.

    The only ticket in baseball that's more expensive are the 60 Legends Box seats in the first row at Yankee Stadium, which cost $197.53 (they are sold at $16,000 each for the 81 home games).

    The second-row seats at Safeco sell for $175 each, the third row for $160 apiece, the fourth row for $145, the fifth row for $130, the sixth row for $120, the seventh for $110 and the eighth for $100.

    For normal tickets, the Yankees still charge a lot more -- $50 for the best boxes to $25 for the Mariners (the Terrace Club seats at Safeco, which include food service, go for $33 each).

    Tricky snow

    First basemen try it every so often, but they rarely succeed. So J.T. Snow was pretty pleased when the San Francisco Giants caught Los Angeles pitcher Carlos Perez with the hidden-ball trick last weekend.

    Perez had just driven in a run with a bunt single, and was celebrating at first base. He also began stretching, which may have distracted the first-base coach. In any case, Snow decided it was worth a try.

    "It's the first time I've ever done it [successfully]," Snow said. "It was a close play and there was a lot of activity going on at first base. The first-base coach turned his back and was talking to Perez."

    Snow waited for pitcher Chris Brock to get off the mound and patiently watched as Perez stepped off the bag.

    "When I tagged him out, I think he was stunned. The umpire knew I had the ball and was waiting for the play to happen," Snow said. "The pitcher is a good guy to try it with. He can get caught up in the moment of getting a hit."

    Just wait a few years

    Even after the fact, Phillies leadoff man Doug Glanville and manager Terry Francona were holding out hope -- sort of -- that an official scorer's ruling might be reversed.

    On Tuesday, Glanville reached when his grounder glanced off pitcher Kris Benson's shin. Such plays are usually scored as hits, but Bob Webb called it an error.

    Official scorers have up until 24 hours to change their calls, but that didn't happen. Still, Francona looked at a loophole.

    "If they can do it for Hack Wilson, maybe Dougie's got a chance," he said.

    Recently, a baseball committee gave Hack Wilson one additional RBI and upped his record total to 191 in 1930.

    "Years from now, when Benson has tied Jim Kaat's record for Gold Gloves, baseball scholars will take away that error and give me the base hit," Glanville said.

    Turning Japanese

    Nelson Liriano and Rich Batchelor are the latest former major leaguers to join teams in Japan.

    Liriano hit .260 in 11 seasons in the big leagues. The 35-year-old infielder played briefly for Colorado last year, and was in the Mexican League this season. He joined the Chunichi Dragons.

    Batchelor was 0-4 with 12 saves and a 4.50 ERA this year for Class AAA Tucson, Arizona's top farm team. He will join former major leaguers Jason Jacome and Roberto Petagine on the Yakult Swallows, and will take the roster spot of one-time big leaguer Mark Acre, likely sidelined for the season by a shoulder injury.

     
    Related information
    Stories
    Sports Illustrated's Inside Baseball
    Multimedia
    Click here for the latest audio and video
    Search our site Watch CNN/SI 24 hours a day

    Sports Illustrated and CNN have combined to form a 24 hour sports news and information channel. To receive CNN/SI at your home call your cable operator or DirecTV.

    Copyright 2003 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.



  • To the top

    Copyright © 1999 CNN/SI. A Time Warner Company.
    All Rights Reserved.

    Terms under which this service is provided to you.
    Read our privacy guidelines.