|
Updated: Tuesday May 26, 12:58 PM
|
| American League | National League | Federal League | Players League | Union Association | American Association |
| No. | Player | Position | Bats | Throws | Height | Weight | Birth Date |
| -- | Nava, Sandy | C | 5'6" | 155 | 04/12/1850 | ||
| -- | York, Tom | -- | Left | 5'9" | 165 | 07/13/1851 | |
| -- | Start, Joe | 1B | Left | Left | 5'9" | 165 | 10/14/1842 |
| -- | Carroll, Cliff | -- | Both | Right | 5'8" | 163 | 10/18/1859 |
| -- | Denny, Jerry | 3B | Right | Right | 5'11" | 180 | 03/16/1859 |
| -- | Farrell, Jack | 2B | Right | Right | 5'9" | 165 | 07/05/1857 |
| -- | Gilligan, Barney | C | Right | Right | 5'6" | 130 | 01/03/1856 |
| -- | Hines, Paul | -- | Right | Right | 5'9" | 173 | 03/01/1852 |
| -- | Manning, Tim | SS | Right | Right | 5'10" | 170 | 12/03/1853 |
| -- | Radbourn, Old Hoss | P | Right | Right | 5'9" | 168 | 12/11/1854 |
| -- | Reilley, Charlie | C | Right | Right | 5'10" | 165 | |
| -- | Sweeney, Charlie | -- | Right | Right | 5'10" | 181 | 04/13/1863 |
| -- | Troy, Dasher | SS | Right | Right | 5'5" | 154 | 05/08/1856 |
| -- | Ward, Monte | -- | Left | Right | 5'9" | 165 | 03/03/1860 |
| -- | Whitney, Art | SS | Right | Right | 5'8" | 155 | 01/16/1858 |
| -- | Wright, George | SS | Right | Right | 5'9" | 150 | 01/28/1847 |
