SI.com Fantasy Minors College Baseball Baseball

 

First-ballot Hall of Famers

  Ty Cobb received 222 of a possible 226 votes in 1936. AP

Joe DiMaggio and Rogers Hornsby were not first-ballot Hall of Famers. Neither were Yogi Berra, Roy Campanella, Jimmie Foxx, Carl Hubbell, Harmon Killebrew, Eddie Mathews or Mel Ott. In fact, no player has been a unanimous choice on the first ballot.

Since the first Hall of Fame election in 1936, 32 players have been elected in their first year on the ballot. Other than the inaugural Hall election, only once have three first-year candidates been elected in one year -- Nolan Ryan, George Brett, Robin Yount in 1999.

Five pairs of first-year eligibles have gained admission to Cooperstown -- Bob Feller and Jackie Robinson (1962); Hank Aaron and Frank Robinson (1982); Johnny Bench and Carl Yastrzemski (1989); Joe Morgan and Jim Palmer (1990); and Kirby Puckett and Dave Winfield (2001).


First and Foremost
First-ballot Hall of Famers with year inducted and primary position,
listed by Baseball Writers' Association of America voting percentage:
Player  Year  Pos.  Pct. 
Tom Seaver  1992  RHP  98.84 
Nolan Ryan  1999  RHP  98.79 
Ty Cobb  1936  CF  98.23 
George Brett  1999  3B  98.19 
Hank Aaron  1982  RF  97.83 
Mike Schmidt  1995  3B  96.52 
Johnny Bench  1989  96.42 
Steve Carlton  1994  LHP  95.82 
Honus Wagner  1936  SS  95.13 
Babe Ruth  1936  RF  95.13 
Willie Mays  1979  CF  94.68 
Carl Yastrzemski  1989  LF  94.63 
Bob Feller  1962  RHP  93.75 
Reggie Jackson  1993  RF  93.62 
Ted Williams  1966  LF  93.38 
Stan Musial  1969  LF  93.24 
Jim Palmer  1990  RHP  92.57 
Brooks Robinson  1983  3B  91.98 
Ozzie Smith  2002  SS  91.74 
Christy Mathewson  1936  RHP  90.71 
Rod Carew  1991  2B  90.52 
Frank Robinson  1982  RF  89.16 
Al Kaline  1980  RF  88.31 
Mickey Mantle  1974  CF  88.22 
Sandy Koufax  1972  LHP  86.87 
Dave Winfield  2001  RF  84.47 
Bob Gibson  1981  RHP  84.04 
Ernie Banks  1977  SS  83.81 
Walter Johnson  1936  RHP  83.63 
Warren Spahn  1973  LHP  82.89 
Willie Stargell  1988  LF  82.44 
Kirby Puckett  2001  OF  82.14 
Joe Morgan  1990  2B  81.76 
Willie McCovey  1986  1B  81.41 
Lou Brock  1985  LF  79.75 
Jackie Robinson  1962  2B  77.50 
Robin Yount  1999  SS  77.46 
 


 


 
CNNSI