SI.com College Football College Football

Posted: Tuesday May 06, 2003 12:43 PM


What kind of coach should Alabama hire?
Read both sides, now read what you had to say.
Experience a must


Taskmaster Tom Coughlin fits the bill.
Tom Pidgeon/Getty Images


By Stewart Mandel

So you're Alabama. You've got a certifiable crisis on your hands. You're at the center of a national controversy, you've lost two head coaches in five months and, on top of everything else, you're dealing with four more years of NCAA probation.

Is this really the time to be taking a chance on some young, unproven commodity?

Alabama football right now is a ship without a captain. It needs a strong leader in the worst way imaginable, and that leader had better come with certain qualifications.

Experience as a head coach at a major program. Tough, hard-nosed discipline. A demeanor that commands respect.

And, I think it goes without saying at this point, no skeletons in the closet.

The most prominent name among the current list of candidates fitting the above description is Tom Coughlin, a successful head coach at both the college (Boston College) and NFL (Jacksonville) levels. His scrupulous methods are legendary, his morals unquestioned, and he's dealt with every form of adversity imaginable.

His only negative, at least in the eyes of Tide fans, is that he's an outsider, much like estranged predecessors Dennis Franchione and Mike Price. To fall into that logic, though, is to make the same kind of mistake that has been holding Alabama back for going on two decades now.

Anointing someone just because he's got 'Bama in his blood is not going to magically transport the Tide back to the way things were under Bear Bryant, because you know what? Those days are over and they're not coming back.

This is not about piling up national championships. A much more attainable goal right now is to simply to get things headed back in the right direction.

And I can think of at least one man who's proven himself more than capable of accomplishing just that.

Build for the future


Mike Shula would be a fresh start.
Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

By B. Duane Cross

The University of Alabama is standing at a crossroads. To the left is the path of how things have always been done. To the right is the way to rebuilding a once-proud program in a manner that will shake the nation's negative perception of 'Bama football.

What university president Robert Witt and athletic director Mal Moore need to do is simple: Hire a coach willing to stake his claim. Previous head coaching experience is not a prerequisite.

Restoring the Tide to national prominence is not a job for the quick-fix artists many believe are best suited to inherit the mantle. Alabama needs to hire a coach who will be there for the long term, a coach who potentially will be there for generations of Tide faithful. It must be someone who will embrace the tradition. 'Bama needs youth and vigor, someone who will weather the reduction in scholarships, the postseason bowl ban and the recruiting trail sniping, all in the name of returning Alabama to respectability.

What Alabama does not need is a retread or someone else's reject. This is a chance for a new beginning for 'Bama. Who better to jumpstart that rebirth than a coach who will work to make a name for himself while shouldering the burden of an immortal coach who has loomed over those who followed his glorious tenure?

Obviously, the next coach at Alabama clearly has his work cut out for him. He also has the support of a fan base that will appreciate the coach who understands growing with the program as well as growing the program.

Alabama football is in shambles. For the program to return to national prominence, a short-term solution will not resolve the issue. A stop-gap hiring so that Tide fans can point to a figurehead is not the answer.

The answer lies within a coach who knows that Alabama will not compete for the national title this year. Or next. Or even in 2005. The next coach must be someone who can see the distant future, not a sordid recent past.



 
Related information
Stories
Alabama fires head coach Price
Stewart Mandel: Another bad idea by 'Bama
Stewart Mandel's Mailbag: 'Bama talks back
Panthers assistant interviews for Alabama job
Tide eyes Shula; Jackson pushes black candidates
Tough to Bear: Alabama coaches since Bryant
SI's Phil Taylor: 'Fire first, question later' mentality shortsighted
Multimedia
Visit Video Plus for the latest audio and video

 


 
CNNSI