SI.com Fantasy More Football Leagues Pro Football Pro Football

Multiplicity

Emmitt merely the latest star to change teams

Posted: Thursday March 27, 2003 11:57 AM
  Eric Dickerson Eric Dickerson's Hall of Fame career had four stops, including seasons with both Los Angeles teams. Mike Powell/Allsport

By B. Duane Cross, SI.com

If the shock of Emmitt Smith not being with the Dallas Cowboys in 2003 hadn't set in -- even after he was released last month -- Wednesday's announcement that the NFL's all-time leading rusher had signed with the Arizona Cardinals was a cold splash of water in the face.

Fans of America's Team shouldn't take it so hard, though. After all, free agency is the American way. Emmitt's not the first star to fall from grace with the team that drafted him. Ask anyone in San Francisco, and 10 years ago they couldn't have fathomed Jerry Rice playing for another team. Or, before him, Joe Montana.

Of course, Dallas has seen this before. Tony Dorsett spent 11 seasons with the Cowboys before wrapping his career with one unremarkable season with Denver in 1988.

At least Fran Tarkenton came back to Minnesota, even before re-signing with a team for the sole purpose of ceremoniously "retiring as a fill-in-the-blank" became fashionable. In fact, Tarkenton left the Vikings for five seasons with the Giants before returning to Minnesota -- and three trips to the Super Bowl.

The days of a star player being drafted by and spending his career with one team are becoming fewer and farther between.

  • Three-time MVP Brett Favre of Green Bay? Atlanta chose him in 1991.

  • Five-time Pro Bowler Jimmy Smith of Jacksonville? Dallas selected him in '92, and he was with Philadelphia in '94.

  • Former MVP Marshall Faulk of St. Louis? Indianapolis picked him in '94.

    Even Ricky Williams -- the running back New Orleans couldn't live without and traded its entire 1999 draft to Washington in order to move up and select the Heisman Tropy winner -- has moved on.

    The reasons are varied, but money (read: salary cap) is a major factor in many of these transactions. Smith would've counted $2.8 million against the Cowboys' 2003 cap, with the remaining $2.1 million hitting in '04. Because Dallas did not wait until June 1 to release Smith, the Cowboys absorb the entire $4.9 million this season.

    Among the top five in the major yardage categories, only John Elway (passing) and Cris Carter (receiving) did not accumulate at least 50 percent of their yards with the team that drafted them. At least Rams fans were treated to 55 percent of Eric Dickerson's rushing total, including his single-season record of 2,105 in 1984.

    Furthermore, no less than seven players in the top 10 in each category -- rushing yards, receiving yards, passing yards and yards from scrimmage -- played for at least two teams during their career. Among the notables:

  • Franco Harris, eighth all-time in rushing is a Pittsburgh icon and forever etched in Steelers lore with his "Immaculate Reception," spent one forgettable season in Seattle to wrap up his career.

  • Charlie Joiner, 10th on the receiving list, is best known as "Air Coryell's" go-to guy, but he spent 3 1/2 season with both Houston and Cincinnati before becoming Option A for Dan Fouts.

  • Johnny Unitas, the NFL's eighth-leading passer, wrapped up his Hall of Fame career with one season in San Diego -- sharing the same sideline with Fouts, who was a rookie with the Chargers in 1973.

    Of course, Emmitt's departure has been 13 years in the making; of the top 50 all-time rushers, only 13 played their career with one team.

    Below is the list of the top five players all-time in rushing yards, receiving yards, passing yards and yards from scrimmage, including the team that drafted him, career yards, yards gained with the team that drafted him and percentage of yards with that team:

    Rushing
    All-Time Top 5
    Player  Drafted  Yards  Yds./Team  Pct./Team 
    Emmitt Smith  Dal.  17,162  17,162  100 
    Walter Payton  Chi.  16,726  16,726  100 
    Barry Sanders  Det.  15,269  15,269  100 
    Eric Dickerson  L.A.  13,259  7,245  55 
    Tony Dorsett  Dal.  12,739  12,036  94 
    Note: Top 10 with more than one team: 7, including Smith.
     
    Receiving
    All-Time Top 5
    Player  Drafted  Yards  Yds./Team  Pct./Team 
    Jerry Rice  S.F.  21,597  19,247  89 
    Tim Brown  L.A.  14,167  14,167  100 
    James Lofton  G.B.  14,004  9,656  69 
    Cris Carter  Phi.  13,899  1,450  10 
    Henry Ellard  L.A.  13,777  9,761  71 
    Note: Top 10 with more than one team: 8.
     
    Passing
    All-Time Top 5
    Player  Drafted  Yards  Yds./Team  Pct./Team 
    Dan Marino  Mia.  61,361  61,361  100 
    * -- John Elway  Bal.  51,475 
    # -- Warren Moon  --  49,325  33,685  68 
    Fran Tarkenton  Min.  47,003  33,098  70 
    Dan Fouts  S.D.  43,040  43,040  100 
    * -- Refused to play for Baltimore after being drafted; traded to Denver.
    # -- Was not drafted. Stats represent seasons with Houston, his first NFL team.
    Note: Top 10 with more than one team: 8, including Elway.
     
    Yards from Scrimmage
    All-Time Top 5
    Player  Drafted  Yards  Yds./Team  Pct./Team 
    Jerry Rice  S.F.  22,242  19,872  89 
    Walter Payton  Chi.  21,264  21,264  100 
    Emmitt Smith  Dal.  20,174  20,174  100 
    Barry Sanders  Det.  18,190  18,190  100 
    Marcus Allen  Oak.  17,654  12,803  73 
    Note: Top 10 with more than one team: 8, including Smith.

     
    Related information
    Stories
    Emmitt Smith signs with Cardinals
    Don Banks: Emmitt's move begins new chapter or final chapter?
    Multimedia
    Visit Video Plus for the latest audio and video

  •  


     
    CNNSI