| Time | Quarter | Team | Situation | Play |
| 15:00 | 1st | NE | -- | > Stephen Gostkowski kicks 70 yards from NE30 to Mia0, TOUCHBACK. |
| 15:00 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia20 | > Chad Henne Pass to Ronnie Brown to Mia32 for 12 yards |
| 14:35 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia32 | > Chad Henne Pass to Brian Hartline to Mia36 for 4 yards |
| 13:58 | 1st | Mia | 2nd & 6 at Mia36 | > Ronnie Brown Off Left Guard to Mia39 for 3 yards |
| 13:16 | 1st | Mia | 3rd & 3 at Mia39 | > Chad Henne Pass to Anthony Fasano to NE40 for 21 yards |
| 12:45 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE40 | > Chad Henne sacked at NE45 for -5 yards |
| 12:13 | 1st | Mia | 2nd & 15 at NE45 | > Chad Henne Pass to Ronnie Brown to NE36 for 9 yards |
| 11:28 | 1st | Mia | 3rd & 6 at NE36 | > Ronnie Brown up the Middle to NE38 for -2 yards |
| 11:07 | 1st | Mia | 4th & 8 at NE38 | > Brandon Fields punts 27 yards to NE11, Wes Welker returns to NE11 for no gain. Wes Welker FUMBLES, recovered at NE11 by Wes Welker RETURNED for 0 yards. |
| 10:56 | 1st | NE | 1st & 10 at NE11 | > BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Left Tackle to NE17 for 6 yards |
| 10:17 | 1st | NE | 2nd & 4 at NE17 | > Tom Brady Pass Incomplete to Brandon Tate |
| 10:10 | 1st | NE | 3rd & 4 at NE17 | > Tom Brady Pass Incomplete to Wes Welker |
| 10:02 | 1st | NE | 4th & 4 at NE17 | > Zoltan Mesko punts 60 yards to Mia23, Davone Bess returns to Mia36 for 13 yards |
| 9:50 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia36 | > Chad Henne Pass to Davone Bess to NE43 for 21 yards |
| 9:15 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE43 | > Ricky Williams Off Left End to NE32 for 11 yards |
| 8:34 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE32 | > Ricky Williams Off Left End to NE26 for 6 yards |
| 8:09 | 1st | Mia | 2nd & 4 at NE26 | > Ricky Williams Off Left Tackle to NE21 for 5 yards |
| 7:25 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE21 | > Miami Dolphins timeout. |
| 7:25 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE21 | > Chad Henne Pass to Ricky Williams to NE14 for 7 yards |
| 6:59 | 1st | Mia | -- | > Mia-Richie Incognito PENALIZED -10 yards for Holding |
| 6:34 | 1st | Mia | 2nd & 13 at NE24 | > Ronnie Brown Off Right Tackle to NE19 for 5 yards |
| 5:56 | 1st | Mia | 3rd & 8 at NE19 | > Chad Henne Pass to Davone Bess for 19 yards for a TOUCHDOWN |
| 5:48 | 1st | Mia | -- | > Dan Carpenter extra point is GOOD. Holder-Brandon Fields |
| 5:48 | 1st | Mia | -- | > Dan Carpenter kicks 71 yards from Mia30 to NE-1, Brandon Tate returns to NE24 for 25 yards |
| 5:42 | 1st | NE | 1st & 10 at NE24 | > Tom Brady Pass to Brandon Tate to NE35 for 11 yards |
| 5:22 | 1st | NE | 1st & 10 at NE35 | > BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Left Guard to NE38 for 3 yards |
| 4:51 | 1st | NE | -- | > NE-Matt Light PENALIZED -10 yards for Holding |
| 4:23 | 1st | NE | 2nd & 17 at NE28 | > Tom Brady Pass to Brandon Tate to NE34 for 6 yards |
| 3:45 | 1st | NE | 3rd & 11 at NE34 | > Tom Brady Pass to Rob Gronkowski to NE38 for 4 yards |
| 3:07 | 1st | NE | 4th & 7 at NE38 | > Zoltan Mesko punts 39 yards to Mia23, Davone Bess returns to Mia33 for 10 yards |
| 2:56 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia33 | > Chad Henne Pass Incomplete to Brian Hartline |
| 2:52 | 1st | Mia | 2nd & 10 at Mia33 | > Ronnie Brown up the Middle to Mia32 for -1 yards |
| 2:12 | 1st | Mia | 3rd & 11 at Mia32 | > Chad Henne Pass to Davone Bess to Mia45 for 13 yards |
| 1:32 | 1st | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia45 | > Chad Henne pass intended for Brandon Marshall intercepted by Rob Ninkovich RETURNED from NE39 for 1 yard. |
| 1:24 | 1st | NE | 1st & 10 at NE40 | > BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Right Tackle to NE46 for 6 yards |
| 0:43 | 1st | NE | 2nd & 4 at NE46 | > BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Right End to Mia48 for 6 yards |
| 0:08 | 1st | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia48 | > Tom Brady Pass to Aaron Hernandez to Mia49 for -1 yards |
| Time | Quarter | Team | Situation | Play |
| 15:00 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 11 at Mia49 | Tom Brady Pass to Aaron Hernandez to Mia39 for 10 yards |
| 14:18 | 2nd | NE | 3rd & 1 at Mia39 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Right Tackle to Mia39 for no gain |
| 13:38 | 2nd | NE | 4th & 1 at Mia39 | Tom Brady Off Right Guard to Mia37 for 2 yards |
| 13:07 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia37 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Right Tackle to Mia33 for 4 yards |
| 12:34 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 6 at Mia33 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Right End to Mia28 for 5 yards |
| 11:54 | 2nd | NE | 3rd & 1 at Mia28 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Left Tackle to Mia26 for 2 yards |
| 11:15 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia26 | Sammy Morris Off Right End to Mia27 for -1 yards |
| 10:34 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 11 at Mia27 | Danny Woodhead up the Middle to Mia18 for 9 yards |
| 9:51 | 2nd | NE | 3rd & 2 at Mia18 | New England Patriots timeout. |
| 9:51 | 2nd | NE | 3rd & 2 at Mia18 | Tom Brady Pass to Aaron Hernandez to Mia9 for 9 yards |
| 9:08 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 9 at Mia9 | Tom Brady sacked at Mia15 for -6 yards |
| 8:35 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 15 at Mia15 | Sammy Morris Off Left Tackle to Mia11 for 4 yards |
| 7:55 | 2nd | NE | 3rd & 11 at Mia11 | Tom Brady Pass to Wes Welker to Mia5 for 6 yards |
| 7:16 | 2nd | NE | 4th & 5 at Mia5 | Stephen Gostkowski 23 yard field goal is GOOD. Holder-Zoltan Mesko |
| 7:13 | 2nd | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski kicks 70 yards from NE30 to Mia0, Nolan Carroll returns to Mia21 for 21 yards |
| 7:06 | 2nd | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia21 | Chad Henne Pass Incomplete to Brian Hartline |
| 7:02 | 2nd | Mia | 2nd & 10 at Mia21 | Ronnie Brown Off Right Tackle to Mia25 for 4 yards |
| 6:21 | 2nd | Mia | 3rd & 6 at Mia25 | Chad Henne Pass to Davone Bess to Mia39 for 14 yards |
| 5:41 | 2nd | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia39 | Davone Bess Off Left End to Mia36 for -3 yards |
| 5:04 | 2nd | Mia | 2nd & 13 at Mia36 | Ronnie Brown up the Middle to Mia39 for 3 yards |
| 4:23 | 2nd | Mia | 3rd & 10 at Mia39 | New England Patriots timeout. |
| 4:23 | 2nd | Mia | -- | NE-Devin McCourty PENALIZED 16 yards for Pass Interference |
| 4:16 | 2nd | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE45 | Mia-Pat McQuistan PENALIZED -5 yards for False Start |
| 4:16 | 2nd | Mia | 1st & 15 at NE50 | Chad Henne Pass to Davone Bess to NE43 for 7 yards |
| 3:37 | 2nd | Mia | 2nd & 8 at NE43 | Ricky Williams Off Right Tackle to NE27 for 16 yards |
| 2:55 | 2nd | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE27 | Chad Henne pass intended for Patrick Cobbs intercepted by Rob Ninkovich RETURNED from NE25 for no gain. |
| 2:47 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 10 at NE25 | Tom Brady Pass to Wes Welker to NE31 for 6 yards |
| 2:21 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 4 at NE31 | Tom Brady Pass to Wes Welker to NE36 for 5 yards |
| 2:00 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 10 at NE36 | Tom Brady Pass to Aaron Hernandez to NE41 for 5 yards |
| 1:56 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 5 at NE41 | Two-Minute Warning |
| 1:56 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 5 at NE41 | Danny Woodhead Off Right Tackle to NE45 for 4 yards |
| 1:39 | 2nd | NE | 3rd & 1 at NE45 | Tom Brady up the Middle to Mia50 for 5 yards |
| 1:20 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia50 | Tom Brady Pass to Wes Welker to Mia45 for 5 yards |
| 0:59 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 5 at Mia45 | Tom Brady Pass to Brandon Tate to Mia35 for 10 yards |
| 0:40 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia35 | Tom Brady Pass Incomplete |
| 0:32 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 10 at Mia35 | Tom Brady Pass to Brandon Tate to Mia23 for 12 yards |
| 0:26 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia23 | Miami Dolphins timeout. |
| 0:26 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia23 | Tom Brady Pass to Wes Welker to Mia12 for 11 yards |
| 0:12 | 2nd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia12 | Tom Brady Pass Incomplete to Randy Moss |
| 0:08 | 2nd | NE | 2nd & 10 at Mia12 | Tom Brady sacked at Mia12 for no loss |
| 0:03 | 2nd | NE | 3rd & 10 at Mia12 | New England Patriots timeout. |
| 0:03 | 2nd | NE | 3rd & 10 at Mia12 | Miami Dolphins timeout. |
| 0:03 | 2nd | NE | 3rd & 10 at Mia12 | Stephen Gostkowski 30 yard field goal is GOOD. Holder-Zoltan Mesko |
| Time | Quarter | Team | Situation | Play |
| 15:00 | 3rd | Mia | -- | Dan Carpenter kicks 73 yards from Mia30 to NE-3, Brandon Tate returns for 103 yards for a TOUCHDOWN |
| 14:46 | 3rd | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski extra point is GOOD. Holder-Zoltan Mesko |
| 14:46 | 3rd | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski kicks 70 yards from NE30 to Mia0, TOUCHBACK. |
| 14:46 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia20 | Ronnie Brown up the Middle to Mia22 for 2 yards |
| 14:13 | 3rd | Mia | 2nd & 8 at Mia22 | Chad Henne Pass Incomplete to Anthony Fasano |
| 14:06 | 3rd | Mia | 3rd & 8 at Mia22 | Chad Henne Pass to Brandon Marshall to Mia26 for 4 yards |
| 13:32 | 3rd | Mia | 4th & 4 at Mia26 | Brandon Fields punt is blocked by Patrick Chung. Brandon Spikes RETURNED from Mia15 for no gain. |
| 13:26 | 3rd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia15 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Right Tackle to Mia12 for 3 yards |
| 12:50 | 3rd | NE | 2nd & 7 at Mia12 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Left Guard for 12 yards for a TOUCHDOWN |
| 12:44 | 3rd | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski extra point is GOOD. Holder-Zoltan Mesko |
| 12:44 | 3rd | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski kicks 70 yards from NE30 to Mia0, TOUCHBACK. |
| 12:44 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia20 | Ricky Williams Off Left Guard to Mia22 for 2 yards |
| 12:18 | 3rd | Mia | 2nd & 8 at Mia22 | Chad Henne Pass to Brian Hartline to Mia29 for 7 yards |
| 11:49 | 3rd | Mia | 3rd & 1 at Mia29 | Ricky Williams Off Left Guard to Mia40 for 11 yards |
| 11:13 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia40 | Ronnie Brown Off Right Guard to Mia45 for 5 yards |
| 10:34 | 3rd | Mia | 2nd & 5 at Mia45 | Chad Henne Pass Incomplete to Brian Hartline |
| 10:29 | 3rd | Mia | 3rd & 5 at Mia45 | Chad Henne Pass to Anthony Fasano to NE42 for 13 yards |
| 9:48 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE42 | Chad Henne Pass to Brandon Marshall to NE23 for 19 yards |
| 9:21 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE23 | Mia-Jake Long PENALIZED -5 yards for False Start |
| 9:04 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 15 at NE28 | Chad Henne Pass to Ricky Williams for 28 yards for a TOUCHDOWN |
| 8:56 | 3rd | Mia | -- | Dan Carpenter extra point is GOOD. Holder-Brandon Fields |
| 8:56 | 3rd | Mia | -- | Dan Carpenter kicks 73 yards from Mia30 to NE-3, Brandon Tate returns to NE22 for 25 yards |
| 8:49 | 3rd | NE | 1st & 10 at NE22 | Tom Brady Pass to Wes Welker to NE27 for 5 yards |
| 8:41 | 3rd | NE | 2nd & 5 at NE27 | Danny Woodhead up the Middle to NE33 for 6 yards |
| 8:07 | 3rd | NE | 1st & 10 at NE33 | Danny Woodhead Off Left Tackle to NE36 for 3 yards |
| 7:32 | 3rd | NE | 2nd & 7 at NE36 | Tom Brady Pass Incomplete to Wes Welker |
| 7:26 | 3rd | NE | 3rd & 7 at NE36 | Tom Brady Pass to Wes Welker to Mia47 for 17 yards |
| 6:55 | 3rd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia47 | Danny Woodhead Off Left End to Mia41 for 6 yards |
| 6:27 | 3rd | NE | 2nd & 4 at Mia41 | Danny Woodhead Off Right Guard to Mia35 for 6 yards |
| 5:52 | 3rd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia35 | Danny Woodhead Off Left Guard to Mia31 for 4 yards |
| 5:18 | 3rd | NE | 2nd & 6 at Mia31 | Tom Brady Pass to Wes Welker to Mia16 for 15 yards |
| 4:56 | 3rd | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia16 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Left Guard to Mia12 for 4 yards |
| 4:27 | 3rd | NE | 2nd & 6 at Mia12 | Tom Brady Off Left Guard to Mia11 for 1 yard |
| 4:09 | 3rd | NE | 3rd & 5 at Mia11 | Tom Brady Pass to Danny Woodhead for 11 yards for a TOUCHDOWN |
| 4:02 | 3rd | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski extra point is GOOD. Holder-Zoltan Mesko |
| 4:02 | 3rd | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski kicks 70 yards from NE30 to Mia0, TOUCHBACK. |
| 4:02 | 3rd | Mia | -- | Mia-Brandon Marshall PENALIZED -10 yards for Pass Interference |
| 3:38 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 20 at Mia10 | Chad Henne Pass to Brandon Marshall to Mia14 for 4 yards |
| 2:55 | 3rd | Mia | 2nd & 16 at Mia14 | Chad Henne Pass to Roberto Wallace to Mia26 for 12 yards |
| 2:22 | 3rd | Mia | 3rd & 4 at Mia26 | New England Patriots timeout. |
| 2:22 | 3rd | Mia | 3rd & 4 at Mia26 | Chad Henne Pass to Davone Bess to Mia31 for 5 yards |
| 1:46 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia31 | Chad Henne Pass to Brandon Marshall to Mia46 for 15 yards |
| 1:06 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia46 | Chad Henne Pass to Anthony Fasano to NE42 for 12 yards |
| 0:37 | 3rd | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE42 | Chad Henne Pass to Ronnie Brown to NE34 for 8 yards |
| 0:11 | 3rd | Mia | 2nd & 2 at NE34 | Ronnie Brown Off Right Tackle to NE29 for 5 yards |
| Time | Quarter | Team | Situation | Play |
| 15:00 | 4th | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE29 | Chad Henne Pass Incomplete to Brandon Marshall |
| 14:56 | 4th | Mia | 2nd & 10 at NE29 | Chad Henne sacked at NE36 for -7 yards |
| 14:22 | 4th | Mia | 3rd & 17 at NE36 | Chad Henne Pass Incomplete to Davone Bess |
| 14:16 | 4th | Mia | 4th & 17 at NE36 | Dan Carpenter 53 yard field goal is BLOCKED by Patrick Chung. Kyle Arrington RETURNED from Mia35 for 35 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| 14:05 | 4th | NE | -- | NE-Julian Edelman PENALIZED -5 yards for False Start |
| 14:05 | 4th | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski extra point is GOOD. Holder-Zoltan Mesko |
| 14:05 | 4th | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski kicks 70 yards from NE30 to Mia0, TOUCHBACK. |
| 14:05 | 4th | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia20 | Ricky Williams Off Left Guard to Mia23 for 3 yards |
| 13:40 | 4th | Mia | 2nd & 7 at Mia23 | Chad Henne Pass to Ricky Williams to Mia29 for 6 yards |
| 13:21 | 4th | Mia | 3rd & 1 at Mia29 | Chad Henne Pass to Brandon Marshall to Mia37 for 8 yards |
| 12:59 | 4th | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia37 | Ricky Williams up the Middle to Mia39 for 2 yards |
| 12:37 | 4th | Mia | 2nd & 8 at Mia39 | Mia-Joe Berger PENALIZED -5 yards for False Start |
| 12:14 | 4th | Mia | 2nd & 13 at Mia34 | Chad Henne Pass to Brian Hartline to Mia44 for 10 yards |
| 11:36 | 4th | Mia | 3rd & 3 at Mia44 | Ronnie Brown up the Middle to Mia45 for 1 yard |
| 10:57 | 4th | Mia | 4th & 2 at Mia45 | New England Patriots timeout. |
| 10:57 | 4th | Mia | 4th & 2 at Mia45 | Chad Henne Pass to Ronnie Brown to Mia45 for no gain |
| 10:36 | 4th | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia45 | Danny Woodhead Off Right Tackle to Mia47 for -2 yards |
| 10:10 | 4th | NE | 2nd & 12 at Mia47 | Tom Brady Pass to Aaron Hernandez to Mia41 for 6 yards |
| 9:33 | 4th | NE | 3rd & 6 at Mia41 | Tom Brady sacked at Mia42 for -1 yards |
| 9:20 | 4th | NE | 4th & 7 at Mia42 | Zoltan Mesko punts 24 yards to Mia18, Davone Bess Fair Catch |
| 9:15 | 4th | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia18 | Chad Henne Pass Incomplete to Davone Bess |
| 9:08 | 4th | Mia | 2nd & 10 at Mia18 | Chad Henne Pass to Davone Bess to Mia26 for 8 yards |
| 8:30 | 4th | Mia | 3rd & 2 at Mia26 | Ronnie Brown Off Left Guard to Mia28 for 2 yards |
| 7:45 | 4th | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia28 | Chad Henne Pass to Davone Bess to Mia37 for 9 yards |
| 7:17 | 4th | Mia | 2nd & 1 at Mia37 | Chad Henne Pass to Anthony Fasano to Mia47 for 10 yards |
| 6:42 | 4th | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia47 | Chad Henne pass intended for Brandon Marshall intercepted by Patrick Chung RETURNED for 51 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| 6:30 | 4th | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski extra point is GOOD. Holder-Zoltan Mesko |
| 6:30 | 4th | NE | -- | Stephen Gostkowski kicks 70 yards from NE30 to Mia0, Nolan Carroll returns to Mia33 for 33 yards |
| 6:23 | 4th | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia33 | Tyler Thigpen Pass Incomplete to Davone Bess |
| 6:18 | 4th | Mia | 2nd & 10 at Mia33 | Tyler Thigpen Pass Incomplete to Brian Hartline |
| 6:12 | 4th | Mia | 3rd & 10 at Mia33 | Tyler Thigpen Off Right Guard to Mia45 for 12 yards |
| 5:34 | 4th | Mia | 1st & 10 at Mia45 | Tyler Thigpen Pass to Anthony Fasano to NE44 for 11 yards |
| 5:14 | 4th | Mia | 1st & 10 at NE44 | Tyler Thigpen Pass to Ricky Williams to NE40 for 4 yards |
| 4:50 | 4th | Mia | 2nd & 10 at NE44 | New England Patriots timeout. |
| 4:50 | 4th | Mia | 2nd & 6 at NE40 | Tyler Thigpen Pass Incomplete to Brian Hartline |
| 4:41 | 4th | Mia | 3rd & 6 at NE40 | Tyler Thigpen pass intended for Brian Hartline intercepted by Jarrad Page RETURNED from NE23 for no gain. |
| 4:36 | 4th | NE | 1st & 10 at NE23 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis up the Middle to NE27 for 4 yards |
| 4:36 | 4th | NE | -- | Mia-Kendall Langford PENALIZED 5 yards for Holding |
| 4:28 | 4th | NE | 1st & 10 at NE32 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Right Tackle to NE39 for 7 yards |
| 3:44 | 4th | NE | 2nd & 3 at NE39 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Left End to NE43 for 4 yards |
| 3:01 | 4th | NE | 1st & 10 at NE43 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Right Tackle to NE46 for 3 yards |
| 2:10 | 4th | NE | 2nd & 7 at NE46 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis Off Left End to Mia47 for 7 yards |
| 2:00 | 4th | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia47 | Two-Minute Warning |
| 2:00 | 4th | NE | 1st & 10 at Mia47 | Tom Brady Kneel to Runout Clock to Mia48 for -1 yards |
| 1:17 | 4th | NE | 2nd & 11 at Mia48 | Tom Brady Kneel to Runout Clock to Mia49 for -1 yards |
| 0:59 | 4th | NE | 3rd & 12 at Mia49 | Brian Hoyer Kneel to Runout Clock to NE49 for -2 yards |