| Time | Quarter | Team | Situation | Play |
| 15:00 | 1st | Buf | -- | > Rian Lindell kicks 73 yards from Buf30 to Pit-3, Emmanuel Sanders returns to Pit22 for 25 yards |
| 14:55 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit22 | > Rashard Mendenhall Off Right Guard to Pit32 for 10 yards |
| 14:15 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit32 | > Ben Roethlisberger pass to the right to Hines Ward to Pit38 for 6 yards |
| 13:35 | 1st | Pit | 2nd & 4 at Pit38 | > Rashard Mendenhall Off Right Tackle to Pit43 for 5 yards |
| 12:54 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit43 | > Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Heath Miller to Pit45 for 2 yards |
| 12:12 | 1st | Pit | 2nd & 8 at Pit45 | > Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the right intended for Hines Ward |
| 12:04 | 1st | Pit | 3rd & 8 at Pit45 | > Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Hines Ward to Buf34 for 21 yards |
| 11:22 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf34 | > Rashard Mendenhall Off Left Guard to Buf29 for 5 yards |
| 10:38 | 1st | Pit | -- | > Buf-Antonio Coleman PENALIZED 5 yards for Offside |
| 10:32 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf24 | > Rashard Mendenhall Off Left Guard to Buf18 for 6 yards |
| 9:54 | 1st | Pit | 2nd & 4 at Buf18 | > Rashard Mendenhall Off Right End to Buf15 for 3 yards |
| 9:11 | 1st | Pit | 3rd & 1 at Buf15 | > Isaac Redman up the Middle to Buf6 for 9 yards |
| 8:29 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 6 at Buf6 | > Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Buf4 for 2 yards |
| 7:51 | 1st | Pit | 2nd & 4 at Buf4 | > Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Buf1 for 3 yards |
| 7:09 | 1st | Pit | 3rd & 1 at Buf1 | > Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle for 1 yard for a TOUCHDOWN |
| 7:06 | 1st | Pit | -- | > Shaun Suisham extra point is GOOD. Holder-Daniel Sepulveda |
| 7:06 | 1st | Pit | -- | > Shaun Suisham kicks 47 yards from Pit30 to Buf23, Leodis McKelvin returns to Buf34 for 11 yards |
| 7:02 | 1st | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf34 | > Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Donald Jones to Buf46 for 12 yards |
| 6:23 | 1st | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf46 | > Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson |
| 6:19 | 1st | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Buf46 | > Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Donald Jones |
| 6:15 | 1st | Buf | 3rd & 10 at Buf46 | > Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Lee Evans |
| 6:09 | 1st | Buf | 4th & 10 at Buf46 | > Brian Moorman punts 47 yards to Pit7, Antwaan Randle El returns to Pit22 for 15 yards |
| 5:57 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit22 | > Rashard Mendenhall Off Right Guard to Pit24 for 2 yards |
| 5:20 | 1st | Pit | 2nd & 8 at Pit24 | > Rashard Mendenhall Off Left End to Pit27 for 3 yards |
| 4:34 | 1st | Pit | 3rd & 5 at Pit27 | > Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Mewelde Moore to Pit34 for 7 yards |
| 3:52 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit34 | > Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Hines Ward to Buf48 for 18 yards |
| 3:22 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf48 | > Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the left intended for Emmanuel Sanders |
| 3:17 | 1st | Pit | 2nd & 10 at Buf48 | > Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the right intended for Mike Wallace |
| 3:12 | 1st | Pit | 3rd & 10 at Buf48 | > Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Mewelde Moore to Buf37 for 11 yards |
| 2:45 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf37 | > Rashard Mendenhall Off Left Guard to Buf39 for -2 yards |
| 2:06 | 1st | Pit | 2nd & 12 at Buf39 | > Rashard Mendenhall Off Right Guard to Buf30 for 9 yards |
| 2:06 | 1st | Pit | 3rd & 3 at Buf30 | > Pit-Jonathan Scott PENALIZED -5 yards for False Start |
| 0:53 | 1st | Pit | 3rd & 8 at Buf35 | > Ben Roethlisberger pass to the right to Heath Miller to Buf22 for 13 yards |
| 0:20 | 1st | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf22 | > Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the right intended for Emmanuel Sanders |
| 0:16 | 1st | Pit | 2nd & 10 at Buf22 | > Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Buf27 for -5 yards |
| Time | Quarter | Team | Situation | Play |
| 15:00 | 2nd | Pit | 3rd & 15 at Buf27 | Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the right intended for Heath Miller |
| 14:49 | 2nd | Pit | 4th & 15 at Buf27 | Shaun Suisham 45 yard field goal is GOOD. Holder-Daniel Sepulveda |
| 14:45 | 2nd | Pit | -- | Shaun Suisham kicks 69 yards from Pit30 to Buf1, Leodis McKelvin returns to Buf39 for 38 yards |
| 14:36 | 2nd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf39 | Fred Jackson up the Middle to Buf41 for 2 yards |
| 13:59 | 2nd | Buf | 2nd & 8 at Buf41 | Fred Jackson up the Middle to Buf40 for -1 yards |
| 13:19 | 2nd | Buf | 3rd & 9 at Buf40 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Donald Jones |
| 13:12 | 2nd | Buf | 4th & 9 at Buf40 | Brian Moorman punts 37 yards to Pit23, Downed |
| 13:05 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit23 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Left End to Pit23 for no gain |
| 12:22 | 2nd | Pit | 2nd & 10 at Pit23 | Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the left intended for Rashard Mendenhall |
| 12:15 | 2nd | Pit | 3rd & 10 at Pit23 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the right to Mike Wallace to Pit35 for 12 yards |
| 11:36 | 2nd | Pit | -- | Pit-Ramon Foster PENALIZED -10 yards for Holding |
| 11:03 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 20 at Pit25 | Ben Roethlisberger sacked at Pit24 for -1 yards |
| 10:25 | 2nd | Pit | -- | Buf-Leodis McKelvin PENALIZED 5 yards for Illegal Contact |
| 10:10 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit29 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Right Guard to Pit36 for 7 yards |
| 9:29 | 2nd | Pit | 2nd & 3 at Pit36 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Right Tackle to Pit42 for 6 yards |
| 8:47 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit42 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Pit47 for 5 yards |
| 8:04 | 2nd | Pit | 2nd & 5 at Pit47 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Left Tackle to Buf48 for 5 yards |
| 7:17 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf48 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. |
| 7:17 | 2nd | Pit | -- | Pit-Chris Kemoeatu PENALIZED -10 yards for Holding |
| 6:46 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 20 at Pit42 | Ben Roethlisberger sacked at Pit41 for -1 yards |
| 6:06 | 2nd | Pit | 2nd & 21 at Pit41 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Hines Ward to Buf47 for 12 yards |
| 5:25 | 2nd | Pit | 3rd & 9 at Buf47 | Ben Roethlisberger sacked at Pit45 for -8 yards |
| 5:02 | 2nd | Pit | 4th & 17 at Pit45 | Daniel Sepulveda punts 33 yards to Buf22, Leodis McKelvin Fair Catch |
| 4:55 | 2nd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf22 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Fred Jackson to Buf34 for 12 yards |
| 4:30 | 2nd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf34 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson |
| 4:26 | 2nd | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Buf34 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Stevie Johnson to Buf48 for 14 yards |
| 3:46 | 2nd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf48 | Fred Jackson Off Right Tackle to Pit46 for 6 yards |
| 3:03 | 2nd | Buf | 2nd & 4 at Pit46 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to David Nelson to Pit39 for 7 yards |
| 2:22 | 2nd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit39 | Fred Jackson Off Left Guard to Pit40 for -1 yards |
| 2:00 | 2nd | Buf | 2nd & 11 at Pit40 | Two-Minute Warning |
| 2:00 | 2nd | Buf | 2nd & 11 at Pit40 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson |
| 1:56 | 2nd | Buf | 3rd & 11 at Pit40 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for David Nelson |
| 1:52 | 2nd | Buf | 4th & 11 at Pit40 | Brian Moorman punts 22 yards to Pit18, Downed |
| 1:42 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit18 | Mewelde Moore up the Middle to Pit19 for 1 yard |
| 1:36 | 2nd | Pit | 2nd & 9 at Pit19 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Hines Ward to Pit27 for 8 yards |
| 1:14 | 2nd | Pit | 3rd & 1 at Pit27 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the right to Heath Miller to Pit32 for 5 yards |
| 0:53 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit32 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the right to Hines Ward to Buf50 for 18 yards |
| 0:45 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf50 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. |
| 0:45 | 2nd | Pit | -- | Pit-Jonathan Scott PENALIZED -10 yards for Holding |
| 0:37 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 20 at Pit40 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the right to Emmanuel Sanders to Buf44 for 16 yards |
| 0:28 | 2nd | Pit | 2nd & 4 at Buf44 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. |
| 0:28 | 2nd | Pit | 2nd & 4 at Buf44 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Emmanuel Sanders to Buf33 for 11 yards |
| 0:15 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf33 | Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the middle |
| 0:14 | 2nd | Pit | -- | Buf-Drayton Florence PENALIZED 5 yards for Illegal Contact |
| 0:08 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf28 | Buffalo Bills timeout. |
| 0:08 | 2nd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf28 | Shaun Suisham 46 yard field goal is GOOD. Holder-Daniel Sepulveda |
| 0:03 | 2nd | Pit | -- | Shaun Suisham kicks 46 yards from Pit30 to Buf24, Leodis McKelvin returns to Buf31 for 7 yards |
| Time | Quarter | Team | Situation | Play |
| 15:00 | 3rd | Pit | -- | Shaun Suisham kicks 70 yards from Pit30 to Buf0, TOUCHBACK. |
| 15:00 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf20 | Fred Jackson Off Left Tackle to Buf27 for 7 yards |
| 14:16 | 3rd | Buf | 2nd & 3 at Buf27 | Fred Jackson Off Right Tackle to Buf27 for no gain |
| 13:34 | 3rd | Buf | 3rd & 3 at Buf27 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the middle to Stevie Johnson to Buf35 for 8 yards |
| 12:52 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf35 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Quinton Ganther to Buf43 for 8 yards |
| 12:07 | 3rd | Buf | 2nd & 2 at Buf43 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Fred Jackson to Buf47 for 4 yards |
| 11:25 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf47 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Lee Evans |
| 11:20 | 3rd | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Buf47 | Ryan Fitzpatrick sacked at Buf40 for -7 yards |
| 10:43 | 3rd | Buf | 3rd & 17 at Buf40 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Stevie Johnson to Pit42 for 18 yards |
| 10:00 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit42 | Fred Jackson Off Right Tackle to Pit33 for 9 yards |
| 9:20 | 3rd | Buf | 2nd & 1 at Pit33 | Quinton Ganther up the Middle to Pit31 for 2 yards |
| 8:38 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit31 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Lee Evans to Pit22 for 9 yards. Lee Evans FUMBLES (FF-James Harrison), recovered at Pit22 by Troy Polamalu RETURNED for 0 yards. |
| 8:29 | 3rd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit19 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Pit30 for 11 yards |
| 7:51 | 3rd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit30 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Pit35 for 5 yards |
| 7:13 | 3rd | Pit | 2nd & 5 at Pit35 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the middle to Hines Ward to Buf41 for 24 yards |
| 6:29 | 3rd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf41 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Buf39 for 2 yards |
| 5:46 | 3rd | Pit | 2nd & 8 at Buf39 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the right to Mike Wallace to Buf35 for 4 yards |
| 5:03 | 3rd | Pit | 3rd & 4 at Buf35 | Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the right intended for Mewelde Moore |
| 5:00 | 3rd | Pit | 4th & 4 at Buf35 | Ben Roethlisberger punts 35 yards to Buf0, TOUCHBACK. |
| 4:54 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf20 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson |
| 4:49 | 3rd | Buf | -- | Pit-James Harrison PENALIZED 15 yards for Roughing Passer |
| 4:46 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf35 | Buf-Mansfield Wrotto PENALIZED -5 yards for False Start |
| 4:46 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 15 at Buf30 | Fred Jackson up the Middle to Buf35 for 5 yards |
| 4:01 | 3rd | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Buf35 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Lee Evans |
| 3:57 | 3rd | Buf | 3rd & 10 at Buf35 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Fred Jackson for 65 yards for a TOUCHDOWN |
| 3:45 | 3rd | Buf | -- | Rian Lindell extra point is GOOD. Holder-Brian Moorman |
| 3:45 | 3rd | Buf | -- | Rian Lindell kicks 55 yards from Buf30 to Pit15, Emmanuel Sanders returns to Pit31 for 16 yards |
| 3:40 | 3rd | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit31 | Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the right intended for Mike Wallace |
| 3:35 | 3rd | Pit | 2nd & 10 at Pit31 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Pit32 for 1 yard |
| 2:54 | 3rd | Pit | 3rd & 9 at Pit32 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the right to Mewelde Moore to Pit39 for 7 yards |
| 2:23 | 3rd | Pit | 4th & 2 at Pit39 | Daniel Sepulveda punts 41 yards to Buf20, Leodis McKelvin Fair Catch |
| 2:17 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf20 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson |
| 2:12 | 3rd | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Buf20 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Donald Jones to Buf25 for 5 yards |
| 1:27 | 3rd | Buf | 3rd & 5 at Buf25 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Fred Jackson to Buf35 for 10 yards |
| 0:46 | 3rd | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf35 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Quinton Ganther to Buf36 for 1 yard |
| 0:16 | 3rd | Buf | 2nd & 9 at Buf36 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the middle to Stevie Johnson to Buf49 for 13 yards |
| Time | Quarter | Team | Situation | Play |
| 15:00 | 4th | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf49 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to David Nelson to Pit34 for 17 yards |
| 14:33 | 4th | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit34 | Quinton Ganther up the Middle to Pit28 for 6 yards |
| 13:52 | 4th | Buf | -- | Pit-Keenan Lewis PENALIZED 17 yards for Pass Interference |
| 13:47 | 4th | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit11 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the middle intended for Donald Jones |
| 13:43 | 4th | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Pit11 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Donald Jones |
| 13:39 | 4th | Buf | 3rd & 10 at Pit11 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Lee Evans |
| 13:35 | 4th | Buf | 4th & 10 at Pit11 | Rian Lindell 29 yard field goal is GOOD. Holder-Brian Moorman |
| 13:32 | 4th | Buf | -- | Rian Lindell kicks 73 yards from Buf30 to Pit-3, Emmanuel Sanders returns to Pit21 for 24 yards |
| 13:26 | 4th | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit21 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Pit23 for 2 yards. Rashard Mendenhall FUMBLES (FF-Jairus Byrd), recovered at Pit23 by Jairus Byrd RETURNED for 0 yards. |
| 13:12 | 4th | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit23 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Stevie Johnson to Pit20 for 3 yards |
| 12:37 | 4th | Buf | 2nd & 7 at Pit20 | Fred Jackson up the Middle to Pit14 for 6 yards |
| 11:55 | 4th | Buf | 3rd & 1 at Pit14 | Ryan Fitzpatrick up the Middle to Pit14 for no gain |
| 11:29 | 4th | Buf | 4th & 1 at Pit14 | Rian Lindell 32 yard field goal is GOOD. Holder-Brian Moorman |
| 11:25 | 4th | Buf | -- | Rian Lindell kicks 66 yards from Buf30 to Pit4, Emmanuel Sanders returns to Pit20 for 16 yards |
| 11:20 | 4th | Pit | -- | Pit-Chris Kemoeatu PENALIZED -10 yards for Holding |
| 10:51 | 4th | Pit | 1st & 20 at Pit10 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the middle to Heath Miller to Pit36 for 26 yards |
| 10:12 | 4th | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit36 | Mewelde Moore up the Middle to Pit36 for no gain |
| 9:30 | 4th | Pit | 2nd & 10 at Pit36 | Ben Roethlisberger sacked at Pit29 for -7 yards |
| 8:59 | 4th | Pit | 3rd & 17 at Pit29 | Ben Roethlisberger Off Right Tackle to Pit47 for 18 yards |
| 8:04 | 4th | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit47 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Right Guard to Buf31 for 22 yards |
| 7:19 | 4th | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf31 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Right Tackle to Buf30 for 1 yard |
| 6:35 | 4th | Pit | 2nd & 9 at Buf30 | Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the left intended for Heath Miller |
| 6:30 | 4th | Pit | 3rd & 9 at Buf30 | Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the right intended for Emmanuel Sanders |
| 6:24 | 4th | Pit | 4th & 9 at Buf30 | Shaun Suisham 48 yard field goal is GOOD. Holder-Daniel Sepulveda |
| 6:19 | 4th | Pit | -- | Shaun Suisham kicks 55 yards from Pit30 to Buf15, Leodis McKelvin returns to Buf41 for 26 yards |
| 6:19 | 4th | Buf | -- | Pit-Keyaron Fox PENALIZED 15 yards for Unnecessary Roughness |
| 6:13 | 4th | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit44 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to David Nelson to Pit40 for 4 yards |
| 5:48 | 4th | Buf | 2nd & 6 at Pit40 | Fred Jackson up the Middle to Pit38 for 2 yards |
| 5:19 | 4th | Buf | 3rd & 4 at Pit38 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the middle to Stevie Johnson to Pit36 for 2 yards |
| 4:35 | 4th | Buf | 4th & 2 at Pit36 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to Stevie Johnson to Pit26 for 10 yards |
| 4:30 | 4th | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit26 | Fred Jackson Off Left Tackle to Pit15 for 11 yards. Fred Jackson FUMBLES (FF-William Gay), recovered at Pit15 by Lee Evans RETURNED for 0 yards. |
| 3:40 | 4th | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit15 | Quinton Ganther up the Middle to Pit12 for 3 yards |
| 3:00 | 4th | Buf | 2nd & 7 at Pit12 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right intended for Stevie Johnson intercepted by Troy Polamalu RETURNED from Pit1 for 5 yards. |
| 2:51 | 4th | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit6 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Pit9 for 3 yards |
| 2:09 | 4th | Pit | 2nd & 7 at Pit9 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Pit14 for 5 yards |
| 2:03 | 4th | Pit | 3rd & 2 at Pit14 | Buffalo Bills timeout. |
| 2:03 | 4th | Pit | 3rd & 2 at Pit14 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Mewelde Moore to Pit22 for 8 yards |
| 1:58 | 4th | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit22 | Two-Minute Warning |
| 1:58 | 4th | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit22 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Left Tackle to Pit23 for 1 yard |
| 1:53 | 4th | Pit | 2nd & 9 at Pit23 | Buffalo Bills timeout. |
| 1:53 | 4th | Pit | 2nd & 9 at Pit23 | Isaac Redman Off Right Guard to Pit25 for 2 yards |
| 1:48 | 4th | Pit | 3rd & 7 at Pit25 | Buffalo Bills timeout. |
| 1:48 | 4th | Pit | -- | Pit-Chris Kemoeatu PENALIZED -10 yards for Holding |
| 1:40 | 4th | Pit | 3rd & 17 at Pit15 | Pit-Jonathan Scott PENALIZED -5 yards for False Start |
| 1:40 | 4th | Pit | 3rd & 22 at Pit10 | Mewelde Moore Off Right Tackle to Pit21 for 11 yards |
| 0:55 | 4th | Pit | 4th & 11 at Pit21 | Daniel Sepulveda punts 42 yards to Buf37, Leodis McKelvin returns to Buf46 for 9 yards |
| 0:46 | 4th | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf46 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Stevie Johnson |
| 0:41 | 4th | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Buf46 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the middle to David Nelson to Pit40 for 14 yards. Replay challenge - ruling upheld. |
| 0:27 | 4th | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit40 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Lee Evans |
| 0:22 | 4th | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Pit40 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to David Nelson to Pit31 for 9 yards |
| 0:08 | 4th | Buf | 3rd & 1 at Pit31 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the middle |
| 0:07 | 4th | Buf | 4th & 1 at Pit31 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. |
| 0:07 | 4th | Buf | 4th & 1 at Pit31 | Rian Lindell 49 yard field goal is GOOD. Holder-Brian Moorman |
| 0:02 | 4th | Buf | -- | Rian Lindell kicks 51 yards from Buf30 to Pit19, Mewelde Moore returns to Pit26 for 7 yards |
| Time | Quarter | Team | Situation | Play |
| 15:00 | OT | Pit | -- | Shaun Suisham kicks 67 yards from Pit30 to Buf3, Leodis McKelvin returns to Pit48 for 49 yards |
| 14:51 | OT | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit48 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Lee Evans |
| 14:45 | OT | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Pit48 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the right to David Nelson to Pit41 for 7 yards |
| 14:03 | OT | Buf | 3rd & 3 at Pit41 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Donald Jones |
| 13:59 | OT | Buf | 4th & 3 at Pit41 | Brian Moorman punts 37 yards to Pit4, Out of Bounds |
| 13:50 | OT | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit4 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Pit6 for 2 yards |
| 13:17 | OT | Pit | 2nd & 8 at Pit6 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Left Tackle to Pit10 for 4 yards |
| 12:35 | OT | Pit | 3rd & 4 at Pit10 | Ben Roethlisberger sacked at Pit1 for -9 yards |
| 12:19 | OT | Pit | 4th & 13 at Pit1 | Daniel Sepulveda punts 55 yards to Buf44, Leodis McKelvin returns to Buf34 for -10 yards. Leodis McKelvin FUMBLES (FF-Keenan Lewis), recovered at Buf34 by Drayton Florence RETURNED for 0 yards. |
| 12:04 | OT | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf34 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the right intended for Donald Jones |
| 12:00 | OT | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Buf34 | Ryan Fitzpatrick pass to the left to Fred Jackson to Buf47 for 13 yards |
| 11:22 | OT | Buf | 1st & 10 at Buf47 | Fred Jackson up the Middle to Pit40 for 13 yards |
| 10:38 | OT | Buf | 1st & 10 at Pit40 | Ryan Fitzpatrick incomplete pass to the left intended for Stevie Johnson |
| 10:30 | OT | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Pit40 | Buffalo Bills timeout. |
| 10:30 | OT | Buf | 2nd & 10 at Pit40 | Ryan Fitzpatrick up the Middle to Pit36 for 4 yards |
| 9:45 | OT | Buf | 3rd & 6 at Pit36 | Ryan Fitzpatrick sacked at Pit39 for -3 yards |
| 9:27 | OT | Buf | 4th & 9 at Pit39 | Brian Moorman punts 39 yards to Pit0, TOUCHBACK. |
| 9:20 | OT | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit20 | Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the right intended for Heath Miller |
| 9:15 | OT | Pit | 2nd & 10 at Pit20 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Pit22 for 2 yards |
| 8:34 | OT | Pit | 3rd & 8 at Pit22 | Ben Roethlisberger pass to the left to Mike Wallace to Pit39 for 17 yards |
| 7:51 | OT | Pit | 1st & 10 at Pit39 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Right Tackle to Pit47 for 8 yards |
| 7:09 | OT | Pit | 2nd & 2 at Pit47 | Isaac Redman up the Middle to Buf48 for 5 yards |
| 6:28 | OT | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf48 | Rashard Mendenhall up the Middle to Buf39 for 9 yards |
| 5:47 | OT | Pit | 2nd & 1 at Buf39 | Isaac Redman up the Middle to Buf37 for 2 yards |
| 5:06 | OT | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf37 | Ben Roethlisberger incomplete pass to the right |
| 5:00 | OT | Pit | 2nd & 10 at Buf37 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Left Tackle to Buf29 for 8 yards |
| 4:28 | OT | Pit | 3rd & 2 at Buf29 | Pittsburgh Steelers timeout. |
| 4:28 | OT | Pit | 3rd & 2 at Buf29 | Isaac Redman Off Right Guard to Buf22 for 7 yards |
| 3:47 | OT | Pit | 1st & 10 at Buf22 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Left Tackle to Buf22 for no gain |
| 3:04 | OT | Pit | 2nd & 10 at Buf22 | Rashard Mendenhall Off Left End to Buf22 for no gain |
| 2:19 | OT | Pit | 3rd & 10 at Buf22 | Shaun Suisham 41 yard field goal is GOOD. Holder-Daniel Sepulveda |