SI.com

 

Honesty is the best Policy

Browns president discouraged by team's mediocrity

Posted: Monday December 16, 2002 8:54 PM
  More in this column:
He-said, he-said in Detroit
Anybody's AFC
Bledsoe's disappearing act
Manning's improv
Cali can't
Mitchell in impressive company
Ravens hang around
Wayne's woe
Short snaps ...

Carmen Policy didn't have any answers late Sunday afternoon, but I'll give him credit for at least asking all the right questions.

The Cleveland team president stood amid the gloom of the Browns locker room and wondered how his fourth-year franchise had failed to protect a 16-0 halftime lead in its biggest game since makings its 1999 debut? Or how a team that was considered a preseason playoff contender could drop to 2-5 at home on the year?

Lastly, Policy was well within his right to question when the Browns, who have spent generously in free agency and the draft, were going to start seeing those investments pay off?

The Browns, who dropped to 7-7 with their 28-23 loss to the Colts, teased us again Sunday. In the first half, they played nearly flawlessly, building a 16-0 lead against a talented Indianapolis team that's probably playoff bound.

But in the second half, Cleveland's defense disappeared, its offense did the minimum and the Browns proved incapable of handling the pressure of a big game. A game that could have made their season.

"I thought we were going to step up and understand what it was all about -- the playoffs, home field, dealing with the big game -- and we just didn't do it," Policy said. "They don't know how to win in this kind of situation. It takes you to a different level when so much is on the line.

"This was not expected or anticipated. This team and this coaching staff has to look itself in the mirror and ask, 'What have we accomplished? What have we failed to accomplish and where are we going?' That's their job."

The Browns are now 19-43 (.306) since re-entering the league in 1999. This season -- head coach Butch Davis' second in town -- was supposed to be the beginning of true playoff contention. Instead it has been a maddeningly inconsistent ride with an equal number of peaks and valleys. That's great if you're in the roller coaster business, but it's tough on a football organization.

"There are two games left," Policy said. "Those two games, believe it or not, are still important, notwithstanding playoff ramifications. ... Everybody has to say to themselves, 'Come on. Get ready for accountability.'"

Where does that accountability start? Not in the usual place. Davis' job is in no jeopardy. He's 14-16 in the first 30 games of his tenure, and in that span, the Browns have shown only one dominant trait: the ability to make every game close at the end. Still, Policy backed Davis to the hilt on Sunday, and it was no dreaded vote of confidence.

"He's our guy," Policy said. "If there's one thing that's not unshaken, it's our faith in Butch. If there's one thing I feel we're doing right ... it's the fact that Butch Davis is our [head] coach."

Nobody else in Cleveland should feel all that comfortable this offseason. The Browns haven't exactly fleeced the top of the draft with their first-round selections of quarterback Tim Couch, defensive end Courtney Brown and defensive tackle Gerard Warren, and big-money free agents like Ross Verba, Dwayne Rudd and Robert Griffith have not been difference makers so far, either.

Couch's future is especially puzzling. While he took a significant step Sunday in playing well before the home crowd -- something that had become a major issue after his reaction to being booed in early October -- he didn't progress as far as he would have had he made a play to win the game in the final minute. Instead, he misfired three times and ran once for 5 yards after leading the Browns to a first-and-goal at the 10.

"I wanted to come out and win this game more than anything -- more than any game I've ever been in," Couch said. "I thought I played well, but I just couldn't get it in at the end. Obviously this hurt us. We don't know what's going to happen."

Policy said a lot about Couch in what he didn't say on Sunday. He stopped significantly short of an endorsement. When asked if Couch was still Cleveland's guy, Policy said, "I hope he is. I hope he is." He added that while Couch did some "phenomenal" things against the Colts, "I wish he could've done more. I wish everyone could have done more."

Could have done more. Policy may have inadvertently stumbled upon the motto of the Browns' 2002 season.

A he-said, he-said situation in Detroit

Strange doings in Detroit these days. League sources say Lions head coach Marty Mornhinweg is spreading the word among his friends and coaching associates that the Ford family has informed him that he will return in 2003, but that team president/CEO Matt Millen is on the way out.

Millen, however, is said to be intimating just the opposite to those close to him -- that Mornhinweg is gone, but he'll survive the purge.

Some sources are spreading the notion that the Lions' head coaching vacancy to come is a large part of the reason that Washington defensive coordinator Marvin Lewis turned down Michigan State last week. Detroit and Cincinnati are the NFL teams believed to be most interested in hiring Lewis as a head coach.

It's the AFC: Anybody's Football Conference

Colts president Bill Polian broke into the NFL in 1978, but he's never seen anything quite like this year's AFC, where just one win can swing a team's fortunes dramatically. Fourteen of the conference's 16 teams are still alive in the playoff chase, and nobody has clinched a postseason berth.

"We're 15 weeks into a 17-week season, and nothing has been decided yet," said Polian on Sunday in Cleveland, shaking his head in amazement. "These guys have heard me say since June that this is going 17 weeks, and that's what it's going to do. It doesn't matter what you did today. If you won, enjoy it, but then it's back to the grindstone tomorrow. That's where the AFC is at this year."

Bledsoe's game has headed south for the winter

Quick question: Whatever happened to Drew Bledsoe? On Sunday, the Bills quarterback was 11-of-33 for 107 yards. To put that into perspective, all 29 other quarterbacks who played the majority of their team's snaps threw for more yardage Sunday.

The first half of Bledsoe's season was MVP material. He threw for 2,500 yards (312.5 per game) with 16 touchdowns and five interceptions. The Bills were 5-3 and averaging 30.1 points per game.

In his past six games -- or ever since his first game against his former team, New England -- Bledsoe has thrown for just 1,449 yards (241.5 per game) with seven touchdowns and eight picks. Buffalo is 2-4 in that span and averaging 18.5 points per game. In four of the six games, the Bills have scored 17 points or fewer.

Manning keeps making it up as he goes along

There are no records for this sort of thing, but Colts quarterback Peyton Manning audibled on all four of his team's touchdowns Sunday in Cleveland. Has anyone ever done that before?

Manning, who calls his own plays, audibled about 70 percent of the time against the Browns. The gutsiest of his check-offs at the line was a fourth-and-3 call from the Cleveland 29 with the Colts trailing 16-0 early in the third quarter. Manning changed from a pass to Marvin Harrison to a run by rookie James Mungro because he noticed Harrison was going to be doubled.

"I signaled to [Mungro}, and he gave me that blank look like he always does," Manning quipped. "I knew he knew what he was doing, but it still makes me nervous.

Said Mungro: "Your eyes would get wide, too, when he's calling audibles with three seconds left on the play clock."

Will the Chargers be left out on the left coast?

All in all, Sunday was a bummer for NFL teams from California. The Raiders (9-5) lost at Miami, letting a big chance to grab the upper hand in the AFC's home-field advantage race slip away. The Chargers (8-6) failed in the final minute in Buffalo, giving them five losses in seven games and doing great damage to their fading wild-card hopes. And the 49ers (9-5) were whipped at home by Green Bay, putting them in line to play host to no more than one home game in the NFC playoffs.

At least two, and maybe all three, teams still could make the playoffs. But not that long ago, this season looked like a lock to be the first time all three franchises had qualified for the postseason in the same year.

Mitchell's numbers can you leave you numb

This may be the most amazing statistic I've seen in a good long while: Philadelphia return man/running back Brian Mitchell now ranks second on the NFL's career list for combined net yardage with 21,912. He passed Walter Payton (21,803) on Sunday and trails only Jerry Rice (22,202).

Rice, Mitchell and Payton. You could have knocked me over with a feather. Mitchell has been a very good player for a long time. An under-appreciated talent. But sandwiched between Rice and Payton -- two first-ballot Hall of Famers? That's a very high-rent district. Heck, that's the penthouse.

Mitchell someday may inspire some Hall of Fame support himself. And he's probably a borderline candidate. But he has largely made his mark in the game as a special teams performer, and that's an enshrinement threshold (see Steve Tasker) that Hall voters still haven't crossed.

Baltimore just keeps hanging around for another week

Here's the second-most improbable thought of the day. If the Steelers lose at Tampa Bay next Monday night and the Ravens take care of business against the visiting Browns on Sunday, Baltimore will be guaranteed a non-losing record and wind up playing meaningful games throughout its entire schedule.

That despite dismantling its roster this offseason in an unprecedented salary-cap purge. That's remarkable, and doesn't even touch upon that Baltimore at Pittsburgh in Week 17 would be for the AFC North title. The Ravens either prove just how good head coach Brian Billick and GM Ozzie Newsome are at their jobs or how mediocre most of the NFL is. More likely, both.

Chrebet is one Jet who should have been grounded

I like the aggressive way Wayne Chrebet plays the game, but the veteran Jets receiver didn't put his Hofstra education to good use when he decided to try to leap over a pack of Bears defensive backs late in Sunday's loss to Chicago.

If you're approaching the goal line and down to a handful of seconds in the game, fine, jump and take your shot at pulling off a Matrix-like move. But Chrebet went airborne near the 15-yard line with about 1:10 remaining in the seven-point game.

He got all the way up there, looked down at the waiting ground and forgot all about ball control at that point. His resulting fumble effectively ended the game and New York's playoff chances. Chrebet the Jet looked good preparing for takeoff, but he didn't exactly stick the landing. Aggressive is good. Smart is even better.

Short snaps ...

  • I just love the final weekends of the NFL's regular season when those Saturday games dot the schedule. In my mind's eye, I have memories of long afternoons of interrupted Christmas shopping at the mall as I stand mesmerized, watching the NFL game on all 47 TVs at once in the electronic/appliance section of JC Penney.

    For some reason, it seems like it was always Bill Parcells' Giants or Walt Michaels' Jets beating somebody in the cold and wind of the Meadowlands. Am I wrong?

  • Am I the only one who thinks it's kind of cool that six days shy of the 44th anniversary of the game billed as the league's greatest ever -- the Colts' overtime win against the Giants in the 1958 NFL title game -- there will be a rematch of sorts Sunday in Indianapolis?

    True, it'll be in the RCA Dome rather than old Yankee Stadium, and the Colts haven't represented Baltimore for the past 18 years or so. Still, you take what you can get. No championships will be at stake, but the game is important for both teams' playoff aspirations.

    Here's hoping that Manning forgets to ask the league for permission and dons those Johnny Unitas-style black high-tops this week.

  • So the past two weeks have shown us how both Michael Vick and the Raiders' passing attack can be slowed, right? Yeah, as long as you have Tampa Bay's sideline-to-sideline defensive team speed and Miami's suffocating cover cornerbacks and stiff pass rush, it's easy.

  • If the Giants pull off their improbable late-season rally and steal a wild-card berth from either the Saints or Falcons, somebody in New York owes Mike Tice and Jay Feely a beer. It was Tice's call to go for the two-point conversion and the win in Minnesota's upset at New Orleans, and it was Feely -- the Atlanta kicker -- who missed his 36-yard overtime field-goal attempt, paving the way for Seattle's surprise win.

  • Speaking of Tice, I happen to know that the Vikings' first-year head coach likes to play the horsies in his spare time. Suffice to say going for two when he was down by one in the final seconds at New Orleans wasn't the biggest gamble he has ever made. Besides, given the Vikings' defense and that 16-game road losing streak, I'd say going for the deuce rather than letting the Saints' Deuce McAllister beat him was a pretty good bet.

  • Call me a hopeless romantic, but Doug Flutie coming off the bench to win at Buffalo would have been fun. And yes, I'm going to resist the urge to say he came up short.

    Don Banks covers pro football for CNNSI.com.

     
    Related information
    Stories
    Previous Don Banks Columns
    Multimedia
    Visit Video Plus for the latest audio and video

  •  


     
    CNNSI