Check your Mail!

CNN Time Free Email US Sports Baseball Pro Football College Football 1999 NBA Playoffs College Basketball Hockey Golf Plus Tennis Soccer Motorsports Womens More Inside Game Scoreboards World
EVENTS
MLB Playoffs
Rugby World Cup
Century's Best
Swimsuit '99

CENTERS
 Fantasy Central
 Inside Game
 Multimedia Central
 Statitudes
 Your Turn
 Teams
 Cities

AD PARTNERS

  Power of Caring
  presented by CIGNA


SPORTS ILLUSTRATED
 This Week's Issue
 Previous Issues
 Special Features
 Life of Reilly
 Frank Deford
 Subscriber Services
 SI for Women

FEATURES
 Trivia Blitz
 Free Email

TELEVISION
 CNN/SI - TV
 Turner Sports

SHOPPING
 CNN/SI Travel
 Golf Pro Shop
 MLB Gear Store
 NFL Gear Store

SI FOR KIDS
 Sports Parents
 Games
 Buzz World
 Shorter Reporter

SITE RESOURCES
 About Us
 myCNN
 
Inside Game

Where have all the runners gone?

Click here for more on this story

Posted: Thursday September 16, 1999 01:31 PM

  Inside Football - Dr. Z

Got a comment or question for Dr. Z? Click here.

Forgive me, please, if I don't join the applause for Dallas-Washington as one of the classic opening-day contests in history.

It's just a personal thing, and far be it from me to try to sway anyone toward my way of thinking, but I've never liked shootouts. Nasty, hard-bitten defensive games, where every yard is dearly won -- that's what it's all about, to my rather antiquated way of thinking.

Cheap scores just won't do it for me. Cornerbacks who miss tackles and turn six-yard hitch passes into 50-yard gains -- uh-uh. Blown coverages, such as the one that gave Raghib Ismail the 76-yard game-winner at the end ... well, you might call it a great play. I call it sandlot football.

What I saw in Week 1 was more four- and five-wideout sets, more open backfields than I've ever seen before. That's the blue-plate special so far in this young season. It's too early to call it a trend, of course, but what I saw after Week 1 was a further erosion of the running game in favor of the cheap fix -- the hitch, the quick out, the slant, the dink, the dunk, which can run a total up to 300 yards passing if you get a few missed tackles.

Seven quarterbacks threw for 300 or more last weekend; only four ballcarriers ran for 100 yards or better. The top performance was by the Colts' Edgerrin James, who rushed for 112 yards, a nice start for the rookie, but a rather anemic number to lead all 31 teams. Just for fun, I made a little five-year chart; 300-yard passing performances on opening day vs. 100-yard rushing performances, listing all the runners who topped James' mark.

Year 300-yard passers 100-yard rushers (more than 112 yards)
1999 7 4 (none)
1998 3 6 (Garrison Hearst, 187, Emmitt Smith 124, Edgar Bennett 115, James Stewart 115)
1997 2 8 (Eddie George 216, Robert Smith 169, Terry Allen 141, Anthony Johnson 134, Adrian Murrell 131, Lawrence Phillips 125, Raymont Harris 122)
1996 1 5 (Barry Sanders 161, Karim Abdul-Jabbar 115, Robert Smith 113)
1995 4 6 (Emmitt Smith 163, Terry Allen 131)

What does this mean? Right now, nothing. The season is only one week old. If the trend continues for five or six more weeks, though, you'll be hearing from me again. I guarantee it.

Around the league

I wasn't on the road last weekend, so I caught my usual eight games, start to finish, via the magic of the VCR. Here they are, with quickie observations:

  • Miami at Denver : The Broncos were the third premium team I saw look awful, Nos. 1 and 2 being San Francisco and Tampa Bay. But Denver was the worst. Why? Because this was the first time I saw a Mike Shanahan team look poorly prepared. Not only that, but the Broncos gave a kind of doggy, let's-mail-it-in impression.

    Their defense didn't look ready to play, their special teams had a punt and a field goal blocked. Their offense? Well, they still haven't figured out who's supposed to pick up the blitzing middle linebacker, Zach Thomas, who simply took young Brian Griese apart. Why couldn't they adjust? Beats me, but you just have to say they were out-coached.

    I don't want to take anything away from the Dolphins. They were terrific in all phases of the game. But what's with Denver anyway?

  • Minnesota at Atlanta: I was fascinated by Randy Moss. Every time he ran downfield he looked to the officials for a flag. Yeah, I know, the guy lit it up last year, and keeping him functional is good for the game, so they say, and it'll help the league sell more T-shirts, but gimme a break.

    Seven passes were thrown his way. He dropped one of the two incompletes, caught three short ones and drew two interference calls for a total of 76 yards. I didn't see him do one tough thing on the field.

    I agree with Falcon cornerback Ray Buchanan, who had this to say after the game: "[The officials] babied him. They did the same thing last year. You turn around and look for the ball, but he's the one grabbing your shoulder pads and pulling on your shirt. When they throw up air balls like that, the officials' decisions tend to be poor. I'm 5'10", and he's 6'10" or whatever [6'4"], and they're calling it on the poodle. They're putting him in diapers."

  • New England at New York Jets: The Giants Stadium synthetic turf claimed another victim. In two straight games there, two keynote Jets have gone down without being hit. First Wayne Chrebet breaks a bone in his foot, then Vinny Testaverde ruptures his Achilles' tendon. They had grass for a while in the summer. The players loved it. Then they brought back their usual synthetic. I don't care what kind of phony studies the league has initiated on this stuff. It's deadly and some day the owners will catch on.

    Now everyone's saying the Jets' season is kaput. I'm not so sure. The score was 10-7, New England, when Testaverde got hurt. The Jets outscored the Patriots 21-20 thereafter. When the Steelers lost Terry Bradshaw in 1976, their defense pitched five shutouts in the next nine games. Not saying the Jets have that kind of talent, but they're tough and a lot more resilient than folks give them credit for being.

    But can they do it with Rick Mirer running the show? Ah, that's where my argument tends to break down.

  • San Francisco at Jacksonville: First the Jags defense overwhelmed the Niners O-line (I still say that letting Kevin Gogan get away was a major error), then with the game still close the Niners secondary fell apart and it was all over. I don't think that would have happened with Merton Hanks, a late cut, still in there.

    O.K., you play the hand that's dealt, and the Niners certainly won't be as bad as they looked in that 41-3 debacle, but they didn't do a good job fortifying themselves in the running back department, either. Charlie Garner is a true twinkle-toes who came up with some breathtaking moves against the Jags, but he's a little fellow who can't carry a running attack by himself. Lawrence Phillips is just another guy.

    Even worse, the all-star trio of wideouts, Terrell Owens, J.J. Stokes and Jerry Rice, couldn't get any separation, and Steve Young was looking downfield at a spectrum of covered receivers. Then the rush got to him. Tough to operate in the rain, some people said, but it didn't seem to bother the Jaguars wideouts. Then again, they had the Niners cornerbacks to work against.

    After slopping around for a half, the Jags finally got it together offensively. I had my eyes on All-Pro left tackle Tony Boselli, as I usually do when I watch a Jacksonville game. I don't know what's happened to him since his rookie year, but he seems to have lost his punch. Oh, he's still fairly effective in his own way ( Charles Haley trying to mount a pass rush against him was a joke), and he'll position himself correctly and all that, but he won't go after people like the Redskins' Tre Johnson or the Cowboys' Larry Allen do. Now there are a couple of bruisers. It's strange.

  • Dallas at Washington: I think I mentioned this one in the lead: What's up with the Cowboys? No pass rush without Leon Lett, no coverage without Deion. Next case. And the Redskins? They tired in the Maryland heat. Dallas holds its preseason camp in Wichita Falls, where the thermometer hits 112. I know because I saw it recorded outside a downtown bank. And that was at 5 p.m. What did I enjoy most? Watching the best pair of guards in the business, Johnson and Allen, go to work.

  • New York Giants at Tampa Bay: Two teams trying to get an offense going behind linemen far inferior to the guys they were trying to block. So it turned into a defensive struggle decided by turnovers. Remember how dynamic the Giants offense looked in preseason, and how everyone was saying that a new era was dawning? Well, it was good for all of 107 yards against the Bucs, second lowest of any of the 30 teams that saw action last weekend. Only Cleveland was worse, but we shouldn't even count the Browns.

    New York's quarterback, Kent Graham, hung in tough, though, while the Bucs' Trent Dilfer -- and I've defended him through the years when everyone was hollering for his blood -- fell apart and had to be replaced. It was sad.

    Who jumped out at me? New York defensive tackle Christian Peter. Never saw him have a game like this. Maybe it was the guys he was playing against, and the Redskins' Johnson might bring him down to earth this Sunday, but, wow, what a day he had. Forget the tackles and assist numbers, the guy was constantly penetrating into the backfield, fouling up everything.

  • Carolina at New Orleans: Why under the wide, blue sky would I ever choose to watch a game like this when there were contests like Green Bay-Oakland to see, you ask. Here's why: I'll get plenty of looks at teams like Green Bay and Oakland during the course of the regular season, whereas I might not get another shot at the Panthers and Saints for a while. I don't watch these games to be entertained. I'm trying to look at players for my all-pro team at the end of the season, sleepers who might get overlooked, etc. And I'm trying to see how each NFL coach runs things.

    I know the Mike Ditka modus operandi well enough: Keep the emotional burners high because he's not gonna win it on personnel or strategy. But I was curious about George Seifert's return to combat. I saw one thing that depressed me.

    Down 19-10 with seven minutes to play, his offense, needing two scores, showed no senshe of urgency. It was slow getting in and out of the huddle. It was time for a no-huddle, actually, anything that would bring it to life, but everything was la-di-da, ho hum, let's take our loss and get on the bus. Uh-uh, won't cut it, George.

    One minor note on the biggest play of a very doggy game. I'm talking about the Saints' TD on Carolina's fumble on the opening kickoff. We know that nickel back Fred Weary made the hit that knocked the ball loose, and cornerback Tyrone Drakeford ran it in, but do you know who was the unsung hero on the play? Je'Rod Cherry, the Saints' sixth DB, who took down the whole wedge by himself, giving Weary a clear shot at the ballcarrier. Just thought you'd want to know.

  • Pittsburgh at Cleveland: I have one regret -- that I didn't bet my life savings on this one. The spread was 6, and I kind of figured what was gonna happen. Yeah, I know, where I live it's illegal to bet, but it would have been worth it to catch a flight to Vegas or something.

    I don't want to be too rough on the TV guys (there's plenty of time for that later in the season) but sometimes, in an effort to hype a game, they say the goofiest things. This from ESPN's Joe Theismann, talking about the Browns, in his pregame intro: "Defense is the strength of this football team. If the defense can make some plays, if the offense can score every time they get the ball, this team can be a lot more competitive. They've got a shot."

    Score every time it gets the ball? No offense in history has ever gone through a game like that. Oh, maybe Georgia Tech against Cumberland in the 222-0 massacre, but in the NFL? Puh-leeze!

    What will be my lasting memory of Cleveland-Pittsburgh? Browns coach Chris Palmer sang along with the national anthem, the Steelers' Billy Cowher did not. There's a message in there somewhere. I'm just not sure what it is.

    Got a comment or question for Dr. Z? Click here.

     
    Related information
    Stories
    Dr. Z's Power Rankings
    Dr. Z's Forecast
    Multimedia
    Visit Multimedia Central for the latest audio and video
    Search our site Watch CNN/SI 24 hours a day

    Sports Illustrated and CNN have combined to form a 24 hour sports news and information channel. To receive CNN/SI at your home call your cable operator or DirecTV.


  • To the top

    Copyright © 1999 CNN/SI. A Time Warner Company.
    All Rights Reserved.

    Terms under which this service is provided to you.
    Read our privacy guidelines.