SI.com

 

Let your vote be heard

Breaking down who should make the All-Star Game

Posted: Sunday December 29, 2002 1:22 PM
  Jon A. Dolezar - Inside the NHL

The NHL All-Star Game is still more than a month away, but the voting for the starters ends Tuesday.

If you are having trouble making decisions on which holes to punch on your ballot, our voting guide is here to help. The players with the voting lead as of Dec. 27 are listed first with an asterisk at each position, followed by our other ranked choices. The honorable mentions are in alphabetical order. The vote totals for the Eastern Conference and Western Conference were updated on Dec. 27.

You can vote online at NHL.com until 8 p.m. EST on Tuesday.

So which stars should shine in Sunrise, Fla., on Feb. 2? Without further ado, here are my choices.

Eastern Conference

Centers
1. Mario Lemieux *
2. Joe Thornton
3. Mats Sundin
4. Vincent Lecavalier
5. Olli Jokinen
Honorable mention: Rod Brind'Amour, Saku Koivu, Michael Nylander and Yanic Perreault

Thornton is the best all-around player in the game right now, but Super Mario remains one of the most popular figures in the sport and deserves to start as long as he continues to play. Sundin and Lecavalier both started off strong, but have faded a bit in recent weeks. As impressive as the four honorable mention centers have been, it's hard to justify them making the team ahead of the other five.

Wings
1. Jaromir Jagr *
2. Alexei Kovalev *
3. Marian Hossa
4. Alexander Mogilny
5. Glen Murray
6. Daniel Alfredsson
7. Ilya Kovalchuk
8. Martin St. Louis
Honorable mention: Martin Havlat, Dany Heatley, Jeff O'Neill and Vaclav Prospal

Jagr might not make the top eight if the popular vote were not in effect. Havlat, Hossa and Alfredsson have teamed to make Ottawa a threat to win the East, but Havlat likely will be the odd man out from the Sens' talented offensive trio. Murray, Mogilny and O'Neill continue to fill the net on a frequent basis. Exciting young Thrashers Heatley and Kovalchuk both deserve consideration after playing in the YoungStars Game last year. And the Lightning's electric duo of Prospal and St. Louis are both enjoying career seasons.

Defensemen
1. Brian Leetch *
2. Scott Stevens *
3. Sandis Ozolinsh
4. Sergei Gonchar
5. Tomas Kaberle
6. Dan Boyle
7. Tom Poti
Honorable mention: Adrian Aucoin, Bryan Berard, Nick Boynton, Zdeno Chara, Andrei Markov, Wade Redden and Dick Tarnstrom

Leetch and Stevens will be the starters based on their reputations, but Boyle, Poti and Tarnstrom have emerged as the new guard of offensive defensemen in the East. Kaberle has become the Leafs' best blueliner, while the Bruins and Sens each have a couple of worthy candidates. Boynton, Markov and Redden are putting together fine seasons, but they likely will have to defer to the others and wait for future years to make this squad. Aucoin is also worthy of selection, but not having to be on the ice for 30 minutes might confuse him.

Goaltenders
1. Nikolai Khabibulin *
2. Ed Belfour
3. Martin Brodeur
Honorable mention: Roman Cechmanek, Olaf Kolzig, Patrick Lalime and Kevin Weekes

If Khabibulin can't hold his slim lead over Brodeur in the voting, he is unlikely to make the team as a coaches' selection. The Bulin Wall was robbed of the MVP award in last year's game, when a third-period voting deadline gave the award to Eric Daze prior to the World team beginning their stirring late comeback. Belfour has been sensational recently after a slow start, while Brodeur is having his typical stellar season.

Western Conference

Centers
1. Joe Sakic *
2. Sergei Fedorov
3. Mike Modano
4. Doug Weight
5. Pavol Demitra
Honorable mention: Jason Allison and Patrick Marleau

Sakic is a lock to play in his 11th All-Star Game, but Modano is breathing down his neck in the voting. Recent injuries have beset those two in the past two weeks, but not enough to leave them off the roster. The Blues' duo of Weight and Demitra have both been splendid, as has Czech rookie Petr Cajanek, who centers St. Louis' third line. Peter Forsberg has been a perennial All Star, but nagging injuries and the return to the East-West format may cost him a spot this year.

Wings
1. Bill Guerin *
2. Brett Hull *
3. Markus Naslund
4. Paul Kariya
5. Marian Gaborik
6. Milan Hejduk
7. Cory Stillman
8. Todd Bertuzzi
Honorable mention: Anson Carter, Zigmund Palffy, Geoff Sanderson, Teemu Selanne, Pierre Turgeon and Ray Whitney

Stillman is clearly the surprise among this bunch, but his numbers prove he merits inclusion. The West is loaded at wing with speedy snipers Gaborik, Kariya and Naslund complementing power forwards Guerin and Bertuzzi.

Defensemen
1. Nicklas Lidstrom *
2. Rob Blake *
3. Al MacInnis
4. Sergei Zubov
5. Ed Jovanovski
6. Derian Hatcher
7. Adam Foote
Honorable mention: Keith Carney, Filip Kuba, Derek Morris, Janne Niinimaa, Mathieu Schneider and Martin Skoula

At the very least, the top four here could win a shooting contest. Lidstrom is unquestionably the best blueliner in the world today. Blake's goal total is down, but he is getting off a ton of shots and has been warming up in the past few weeks. MacInnis is causing jaws to drop by playing at such a high level at age 39, especially without his cohort Chris Pronger around to take some pressure off him. Zubov and Jovanovski aren't in the elite level, but they are the best of the second tier. Hatcher has rejuvenated his career after a disappointing 2001-02 season. Carney is playing his best hockey, but players like him, Kuba and Niinimaa just don't do enough on the scoresheet to make an All-Star team, despite their solid efforts on a nightly basis. Foote and Hatcher serve as the representatives for the stay-at-home defenseman crowd.

Goaltenders
1. Patrick Roy *
2. Marty Turco
3. Jocelyn Thibault
Honorable mention: Dan Cloutier, Dwayne Roloson and Jean-Sebastien Giguere

Roy holds a huge lead over Curtis Joseph and is a lock to make his 11th appearance, but Cloutier and Giguere are more deserving. Roloson's numbers are terrific, but he is hurt by the fact that he splits time with Manny Fernandez, and that the Wild play a tight, trapping defensive system that helps his stats. Turco's incredible start to the season makes him the worthy starter, but he wasn't even among the 10 goalies on the Western Conference ballot. He'll have to settle for the backup spot behind Roy and second-period duty in his first All-Star Game appearance.

Jon A. Dolezar covers the NHL for CNNSI.com.

Got a comment, question or scoop for Jon? Click here.


 
Related information
Stories
2003 NHL Eastern Conference All-Star Voting
2003 NHL Western Conference All-Star Voting
Week at a Glance: Stars' Turco flopping his way to the top
NHL 2002-03 All-Star Ballot
Multimedia
Visit Video Plus for the latest audio and video

 


 
CNNSI