The NFL's alltime rushing leader (and Dancing With the Stars king) won three Super Bowls as a member of the Dallas Cowboys. In 1993 he won the league's MVP, rushing crown (1,486 yards) and Super Bowl MVP, the only player to hit that triple in NFL history.

Runner-up Elgin Baylor.

Worthy of consideration: Mike Bossy, Roger Clemens, Clyde Drexler, Doug Flutie (college), Bobby Layne, Jim Palmer.