Tough call over Terry Bradshaw but Brady gets the top spot for winning in a tougher era. He's 111-34 as a starter, including 14-4 in the postseason and holds the NFL record for the most consecutive wins (10) in the postseason. Plus, well, Gisele.
Runner-up: Terry Bradshaw
Worthy of consideration: John Brodie, Randall Cunningham, Bob Griese, Jim Kelly, Joe Namath, Ken Stabler, Roger Staubach, Doug Williams