Sept. 5, 2007
When Barry Bonds hit the 762nd home run of his career, many wondered if that would that be the last home run of Bonds' career. It turned out it would be. But who had caught the ball? Months after making the catch, Rockies fan Jameson Sutton came forward and announced that he would auction off the ball. Game footage, as well as a successful polygraph test corroborated Sutton's claim that he had the real ball. Sutton was hoping for $1 million, but the ball ended up being sold for $376,612.