2012 - Andrew Luck
QB, Indianapolis Colts (Stanford)
The Colts were lucky enough to replace Peyton Manning with Andrew Luck, the rookie out of Stanford who helped lead Indianapolis to one of the biggest one-season turnarounds in NFL history. The Colts went 2-14 in 2011, but had a memorable 11-5 campaign in 2012, good enough for a wild-card playoff berth.








