Extra MustardSI On CampusFantasyPhoto GalleriesSwimsuitVideoFanNationSI KidsTNT
Commentary, news, analysis and reader-driven discussions focusing on this year's Stanley Cup playoffs.
11:18 p.m. ET, 4/26/07

Sharks top Wings in soft Game 1

Posted by Michael Farber
You know things are down in Hockeytown when Joe Louis Arena doesn't fill up for a semifinal game. But don't tell that to this fan.
Dave Sandford/Getty Images
DETROIT -- After Mike Grier scored midway through the first period to give the San Jose Sharks a 2-0 lead -- a lead that would hold up -- in Game 1 of their second-round playoff series Detroit Red Wings coach Mike Babcock called a timeout to settled his team.

After 30 seconds, play officially resumed.

Next time, somebody should have informed the Sharks and reminded the Red Wings.

The tedium was the message, a waltz of uninspired hockey between two of the NHL's most dynamic teams. While hardly playing ideally, San Jose wound up playing what amounted to the ideal road game, blocking 18 shots (five by Kyle McLaren) to one for Detroit, keeping the Wings scoring chances to the outside (after Pavel Datsyuk overhandled a point-blank opportunity six minutes in), putting a super line of Joe Thornton, Patrick Marleau and Bill Guerin together late in the second period but quickly abandoning the project, not taking penalties in the third period after killing off three in succession in the second period and generally sucking the oxygen out of Joe Louis Arena, which has been the most rollicking of hockey barns for the past decade but could have been mistaken for the Detroit Public Library at times Thursday night.

San Jose had eight shots in the first 10:09 of the game. During the next 50 minutes or so, San Jose managed only 11 more. But as Sharks coach Ron Wilson sagely noted, most of the quality chances that the Sharks did allow came early in the game. The fast and furious start by both teams -- Thornton made a sweet diagonal pass from the goal line to defenseman Matt Carle for the first goal on San Jose's lone power play and a hard forecheck by Grier on Wings defenseman Mathieu Schneider that gave Grier the opportunity for the second goal, just 24 seconds later -- soon gave way to a labor-intensive exercise that produced little in the way of concrete results.

"That was not how we want to play," Sharks defenseman Craig Rivet said. "We had far too many turnovers against the team that has one of the best transition games. You know, we were almost trying to beat ourselves with sloppy play. We're a team that likes to get the puck deep, have puck protection and wear them down. That's pretty much what they did to us tonight. We didn't play too much in the other team's zone. Even though we shut them out, we can't say this is a game we're really happy with."

The key numbers were the 18 blocked shots and the 18,712 fans, until the ennui of the third period prodded many of them to the exits with five minutes remaining. Joe Louis Arena holds 20,066 although the stretches of empty seats made the crowd seem mildly optimistic. Was this Hockeytown or some Potemkin Village, a façade of a puck city that, at least since Scotty Bowman took over the team in the 1990s, seemed like it could not get enough of the sport. The last time the arena seemed this moribund was when Steve Yzerman was barely old enough to shave. Of course, there were no-shows in the stands during the regular season, but unsold tickets and a game presentation Thursday that failed to match the originality and passion that has come to be associated with the Red Wings truly was shocking.

"That was something I wasn't expecting," Rivet said. "I looked up in the stands and there was a lot of empty seats there. That's really uncharacteristic of Detroit."

The problem is a downturn in the local economy and an upturn in the fortunes of the Tigers, Wings owner Mike Ilitch's other big sports property. Detroit's surprising appearance in the World Series in 2006 became an economic drain on the Wings, who are just another competitor for the sports entertainment dollar here. Without being able to ice a lineup of Hall of Fame players circa 1997 and 1998 due to the constraints of a salary cap, some of the Red Wings glitz is gone. Not that the place is about to become the Meadowlands of Michigan, but if Hockeytown wavers, the NHL must be concerned about traditionally softer markets.

But enough about soft markets. Game 1 was about a soft game. On Saturday afternoon, the Sharks should have their legs and the Red Wings should have their edge. The timeout better be over.

posted by SI.com | View comments |  

Comments:

Posted: 1:00 AM, April 27, 2007   by Boomer
Interesting. When did the NHL playoffs start?
Posted: 6:19 AM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
no need to worry i have faith in red wing d
Posted: 7:50 AM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
The real reasons why the Joe wasn't sold out again last night:

5674) No more Stevie or Shanny.

2) Michigan's economy is practically at rock bottom.

1) Ticket prices are out of this world. Most people couldn't afford these things even if the local economy was booming. LOWER TICKET PRICES!
Don't forget that the Red Wings made their season ticket holders pony up for all of next season to insure playoff tix this year. Coupled with the severe downturn of the Detroit economy and you ahve empty seats.

But what is NJ's excuse??? Plenty of seats still available for the first 2 rounds of the playoffs?
Posted: 8:39 AM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
The NHL must wake up and lower ticket prices across the board for the sport. It's just not economically feasible for a person to pay $100 for a upper row seat for a semi-final game. Pro hockey players make too much money in relation to passion about the sport in this country, and interest will not rebound until ticket prices go down.
Posted: 9:28 AM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
a road win is a road win, you take it anyway you can get it
Posted: 9:48 AM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
The problem in Detroit is the ticket prices. Standing Room only is $77 plus a $5.75 "convenience charge." Then you add $20 for parking and another $40-$50 for drinks/food, and you're looking at almost $150 per person.

The Red Wings payroll dropped from $74 million pre-lockout to $44 million, but ticket prices kept going up. That has to change for the Joe to be filled up.
Posted: 11:31 AM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
the reason the seats were empty is because red wing fans didn't want to see another humiliating loss to the sharks...
Posted: 12:31 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
And how many Cups have the Sharks won? Just wondering.
Posted: 12:58 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
The most surprising thing about game one was the lack of passion by either team after the first 10 minutes of play. There was no "there" there.
Posted: 1:12 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
"And how many Cups have the Sharks won? Just wondering."

As many as the Wings have over the last six years.
Posted: 1:12 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
Give Detroit a break, Farber, the "Big Three" is in the toilet and big corporations are bailing out of Michigan faster than rats off the Titanic. Detroiters love the Wings but ticket prices are out of the question when you don't have a job anymore and can't figure out where you're gonna find one that will pay enough to feed your kids.
Posted: 1:18 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
this isnt a surprise. Detroit only calls itself Hockeytown, they havent filled that arena all year. Look at NJ as well, a good team doesnt insure sold out seats. A good opponent doesnt either, its all about the fans.
Posted: 1:26 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
Sharks are bigger, better, faster, and more talented from top to bottom. Not only will the next game not be sold out, but the wings will be lucky if this series goes 6 games
Posted: 2:21 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
["And how many Cups have the Sharks won? Just wondering."

As many as the Wings have over the last six years.]

Hm, Wings, 2002: 1, Sharks: 0

Nice math, Sharks fan!
Posted: 2:24 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
The Sharks have won their last game in these playoffs. They have awakened the giant and are about to get squashed.

San Jose will not score 2 more goals the rest of this series.

When you put a Detroiter's back to the wall, you better get out of the way.

Good bye San Jose.
Posted: 3:18 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
So true, so true! Sharks will be playing golf after 5. SEEEEEE YA!
Posted: 3:21 PM, April 27, 2007   by Anonymous
"As many Cups as the Wings have won in the last 6 years?"

How many years ago was 2002?
Posted: 10:00 AM, April 28, 2007   by Jake - NH
Did you Detroit fans actually watch the game? The Sharks are going to send the team and it's lackluster fan base packing. They are bigger, younger and deeper. Enjoy the off-season!
divider line
Search