SI.com World Cup Europe U.S. More Soccer Soccer

 

Woodgate avoids jail

Leeds defender guilty of affray; Bowyer cleared

Posted: Friday December 14, 2001 8:22 AM
Updated: Friday December 14, 2001 12:35 PM
  Lee Bowyer Lee Bowyer was found not guilty on affray and grievous bodily harm charges. AP

HULL, England -- Leeds footballer Jonathan Woodgate has been sentenced to 100 hours community service after being found guilty of affray in a street attack on an Asian youth.

Woodgate was cleared of causing grievous bodily harm and his teammate and co-defendant Lee Bowyer was found not guilty of affray and grievous bodily harm.

The jury took five days to reach their verdicts at Hull Crown Court on Friday after the first trial was abandoned.

At a press conference Leeds United chairman Peter Ridsdale said that both Woodgate and Bowyer would be made available to manager David O'Leary for team selection.

He said the club had always maintained that if the players had been found guilty of grievous bodily harm they would not have played for the club again.

"Leeds United were not on trial," he stressed.

Bowyer thanked the Leeds' supporters club and his family for their support during case.

"Everyone has stuck by me," he said while leaving court.

 
FACTBOX
LEE BOWYER (cleared of grievous bodily harm and affray) London-born Bowyer, 24, became the country's most expensive teenager when manager Howard Wilkinson paid 2.6 million pounds (US$3.80 million) to bring the 18-year-old goal-scoring midfielder to Leeds United from Charlton Athletic in 1996.

An aggressive box-to-box tackler, he was the club's player of the year for 1999 and 2001 and would no doubt be in England coach Sven Goran Eriksson's World Cup plans but for the trial.

He played in all 38 of his club's Premier League games last season and scored 14 goals. A hamstring injury has limited his appearances recently.

A former youth and under-21 international, he was linked with a step up to the full squad last season but the Football Association ruled him out until the trial was completed.

He began his career as a trainee with Charlton, where he enjoyed star status.

Bowyer is no stranger to controversy. He failed a random FA drugs test in March 1995, testing positive for marijuana, and was subsequently banned from England U-18 duty.

The following year he was caught on video throwing chairs around a McDonald's restaurant.

He scored a last minute winner against Anderlecht in the Champions League the day after the first trial started in Hull. Leeds reached the semifinals of the competition last season.

JONATHAN WOODGATE (guilty of affray, cleared of grievous bodily harm with intent) The 21-year-old defender broke into David O'Leary's Leeds side in the 1998/99 season after impressing in their youth set-up. Teeside-born Woodgate signed for the club as a 13-year-old midfielder and quickly matured into a commanding centre-half. He helped Leeds to FA Youth Cup victory in 1997 and he went on to captain the England under-18 team.

Denied first team opportunites under manager George Graham, he was handed his Premier League debut at Nottingham Forest in October 1998 in new coach O'Leary's second game in charge.

His comfortable performances in Leeds' European campaigns impressed England boss Kevin Keegan, who gave him his first cap against Bulgaria in May.

Woodgate is regarded as one of the country's most promising young players but, like Bowyer, he was ruled out of playing for England by his involvement in the Hull trial.

He visibly aged during the first trial which affected his form. He has started only one game for Leeds since that trial started in February. 

 

The victim's father Muhamad Najeib said he was looking to take further action because "justice has not been done."

He criticized Leeds United for failing to offer any sympathy for his son, who was in hospital for eight days recovering from the attack.

England defender Woodgate and former England under-21 captain Bowyer were accused of taking part in the attack in Leeds city centre which left a 21-year-old student with injuries including a broken nose and cheekbone, a bitemark, and a fractured leg.

The footballers and friends had gone out on a heavy drinking session with friends.

Both were suspended from playing for England while the case was ongoing. Woodgate, worth an estimated US$15 million, played once for England as a teenager in 1999.

Woodgate, 21, and Bowyer, 24, with co-defendants Paul Clifford and Neale Caveney, both 22, had denied causing Sarfraz Najeib grievous bodily harm with intent in January last year.

They also denied the charge of affray.

Caveney was found guilty of affray but cleared of causing GBH and also ordered to do 100 hours community punishment.

Woodgate's friend Clifford was found guilty of causing GBH and affray, and was sentenced to six years in jail by Mr Justice Henriques.

Woodgate, dressed in a smart grey suit, sat with his arms folded and remained impassive except for a slight shrug when he was found guilty of affray.

Bowyer, who was the nation's most expensive teenage footballer when he signed for Leeds in 1996, was allowed to walk free from court.

The prosecution had said that Najeib, of Rotherham, South Yorkshire, and his friends were chased through the city centre following a confrontation outside the Majestyk nightclub in City Square in January last year.

Najeib was caught and beaten unconscious after tripping over.

Woodgate, Clifford and Caveney had told the jury at Hull Crown Court that they had been bystanders and not involved.

Bowyer had told the court he had been jogging near the area and was assaulted before walking back to the Majestyk nightclub without approaching the scene of the fight.

The jury of seven women and five men had taken 22 hours over five days to reach their verdicts.

The maximum sentence that could have been given for affray is three years, the judge said, while GBH can carry a life sentence.

Addressing both Woodgate and Caveney, the trial judge said: "Five young students were caused sheer terror as they were pursued through the streets running for their lives.

"By joining in that chase you were terrifying both them and other law-abiding members of the community."

Woodgate and Bowyer both have histories of violence which the Hull Crown Court jury was not told about.

The first trial was abandoned in April after the British tabloid Sunday Mirror newspaper published a story the judge ruled was prejudicial.

Mr. Justice Poole said the story had created so serious a risk of prejudice to the trial that it was impossible to continue.

The 11-person jury had been deliberating its verdict for 21 hours, in a trial which had cost £8 million (US$11.5 million), when the story was published.

The second trial is estimated to have cost US$10.5 million.

 

Related information
Stories
Jury in Leeds trial retires to consider verdict
'Justice has not been done,' claims victim's father
Two will keep playing, says Leeds chairman
Multimedia
Visit Video Plus for the latest audio and video
Search our site Watch CNN/SI 24 hours a day
Sports Illustrated and CNN have combined to form a 24 hour sports news and information channel. To receive CNN/SI at your home call your cable operator or DirecTV.

 


 
CNNSI