Posted: Mon April 2, 2012 2:15PM; Updated: Mon April 2, 2012 2:35PM
Avi Creditor

Week 4 Power Rankings: RSL moves up; attendance has fallen

Story Highlights

After Olympic failure, the U.S. U-23s in MLS had mixed performances

MLS attendance in the first few weeks of the season is disappointing

Elements of inconsistency in MLS player-acquisition mechanics

Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Perry Kitchen
U.S. U-23 international Perry Kitchen (right) shrugged off his Olympic disappointment with a strong return to MLS action.
Rob Carr/Getty Images

The U.S. U-23s based in MLS face a return to reality, while decisions on and off the field question consistency. That and more from a wild Week 4 in MLS:

1. U-23s returning at their own paces. This weekend was supposed to be a coronation ceremony for a promising U.S. U-23 men's national team reaching its first goal of 2012. Instead, it was a harsh return to reality, as Mexico and Honduras claimed places in the Olympics while the future U.S. stars tried to turn the page and get back to work for their clubs.

The grieving process takes a different form and unfolds at a different pace for everybody, and one of the long-reaching effects of the highly scrutinized qualifying fiasco will be how lasting of an impact the Canada loss and El Salvador draw has on an impressionable group of young men.

Friday's D.C. United-FC Dallas game was a prime example of that. After logging heavy minutes in all three U.S. qualifying matches, D.C.'s Perry Kitchen and Dallas' Brek Shea returned to their respective starting lineups for their fourth game in eight days. Shea had his moments attacking down the flanks, but he ultimately looked worn out and a step slow and had a glossed-over look as he exited the stadium. Kitchen, meanwhile, embraced the next step, seemingly compartmentalizing the futile qualifying effort and his club duties, putting his head down, powering through and moving on.

"[Shea]'s still tired, and he might be emotionally tired as well," FC Dallas coach Schellas Hyndman noted following his club's 4-1 loss at RFK Stadium. "Kitchen came back and looked like himself. Every player it affects differently."

And that's just it. For some, getting back on the field and not looking back is an essential part of the process. For others, more time will be necessary to heal the wounds.

"It's not been a good week for me, personally," Shea said after going all 90 minutes. "It's hard coming back and trying to flip a switch and play a game. It hasn't been a good week. I'm just trying to get my head clear, get back to playing."

Shea and Kitchen are just two of 14 MLS players on the U-23s coping with the disappointment. Not all were regular starters for their teams before they left for international duty, but for ones that were, this weekend did not necessarily provide an immediate opportunity to move forward.

Incumbent starters Teal Bunbury and Sean Johnson, for example, returned to find their places in the lineup not waiting for them. While C.J. Sapong continues to justify his place in the Sporting Kansas City lineup ahead of Bunbury, Johnson, whose goalkeeping blunder in stoppage time against El Salvador is the lasting image of the qualifying tournament, watched from the bench as young Italian Paolo Tornaghi earned another start for the Chicago Fire. Both players will have to prove themselves, it would appear, just to get back the lion's share of minutes. That's a far cry from packing for London, and it's just another hurdle to clear in the process of accepting the qualification mishap and moving on.

"[Friday's win] still doesn't make up for [the failure to qualify], but it definitely helps," Kitchen said. "This is my focus now."

At some point in the coming weeks, the rest of Kitchen's MLS-based U-23 teammates will hopefully be able to reach that mindset as well.

2. Disciplinary committee's slippery slope. The intentions behind MLS' quest to eliminate potential injury-causing challenges are good and pure, but the league is heading down a slippery slope that ends at the doorstep of Pandora's box.

Wielding its power as a second line of punishment behind league officials, the MLS disciplinary committee issued Houston Dynamo midfielder Adam Moffat an undisclosed fine and one-game suspension late last week for the kind of hard tackle that takes place rather regularly and one that drew on-field discipline in the form of a yellow card. The league deemed Moffat's tackle of Seattle's Osvaldo Alonso -- one in which he came through the Sounders midfielder with an exposed cleat after making contact with the ball -- a "reckless challenge which endangered the safety of his opponent."

The real problem with exerting additional discipline to challenges like Moffat's is that the process is so subjective. There is no black-and-white checklist of what constitutes "reckless" and "endangering," and as a result, there's no possible way to consistently identify non-red-card-drawing tackles that are suspension-worthy. Plenty of hard tackles will go without further discipline, and rightfully so, but it opens the door for criticism and shouts of unbalance. If the league's mandate to protect its players and prevent hard challenges ultimately does that, then it will have been a success, but there's no way for it to proceed without each hard tackle -- i.e. D.C. United defender Brandon McDonald's rather hard challenge on FC Dallas striker Blas Perez -- being questioned and scrutinized going forward.

3. Consistency lacking on and off field. As far as MLS has come over the years, there is still a glaring lack of consistency in appearances, all the way from the playing field to the league's player-acquisition mechanisms.

On the field, two instances in separate games yielded wildly inconsistent decision-making processes.

In Seattle, physical San Jose forward Steven Lenhart initiated contact off the ball, running into defender Marc Burch's leg in the area and drawing a penalty call out of nothing from referee Mark Kadlecik. At the Home Depot Center Sunday night, meanwhile, Chivas USA center back Rauwshan McKenzie paid tribute to WrestleMania by nearly spearing C.J. Sapong to the ground in the area while not meriting a whistle from referee Edvin Jurisevic. Penalty calls or ones that go uncalled often draw the ire of one side in a battle, but those two decisions could not have been on further extremes of the penalty spectrum and still resulted in head-scratching reactions.

Off the field, the league's player-acquiring mechanisms still pique a bit of confusion. The Colorado Rapids were able to sign one-time U.S. forward Kamani Hill this past week, securing his rights through a weighted lottery. Despite having no other competitors in the lottery, Colorado was still forced to forego its rights for future player lotteries for the remainder of the season -- which is standard for the lottery process -- according to league sources. Fair enough.

That would seem fine if not for a similar instance that unfolded in the offseason that yielded a different outcome. The Portland Timbers were able to secure U.S. U-20 midfielder Charles Renken through what MLS deemed the "waiver" process as a result of the Timbers being the only team interested in signing him, therefore forgoing the lottery and allocation order routes. Portland, according to reports, was willing to part with its place in the allocation order to sign Renken, but the club was not required to give it up, essentially signing Renken without any of the ramifications that are in place to make the signings of U.S. internationals a fair battle.

Colorado having to be restricted going forward while Portland is not seems a bit unbalanced, at no fault of either club. They're just working within the system. That the league did not publicly acknowledge that there was even a lottery for Hill, who scored on his debut for the Rapids, makes the situation even murkier. It just goes to show that while progress has been made in the road to fairness, transparency and consistency, there is still work to be done.

4. Attendance figures disappoint. This past week was one the most entertaining and unpredictable of the young MLS season. Unfortunately, it was witnessed live by plenty of empty seats.

Perhaps it was the weather, perhaps it was various spring breaks, perhaps it was fan bases being unsatisfied with the opening few weeks, but crowds of less than 14,000 were announced at D.C. United's Friday night clash with FC Dallas, New York's home match with Montreal, and Sunday's Colorado-Chicago and Chivas USA-Sporting Kansas City bouts. Hundreds of more empty seats marred the stands for the Los Angeles Galaxy's home loss to New England and Philadelphia's scoreless draw with Vancouver -- a match that had the added lure of being Sebastien Le Toux's first game at PPL Park since being traded in the offseason.

If not for the Pacific Northwest skewing the curve (more than 38,000 showed up in Seattle, while more than 20,000 braved the rain in Portland for an early candidate for Game of the Year), this would've been one of the uglier weekends at the ticket turnstiles, and it's a shame, especially for those who missed out on one of D.C.'s best attacking displays in some time and Thierry Henry's first MLS hat trick.

5. Team of the Week

Goalkeeper: Joe Willis (D.C. United)

Defenders: Chris Tierney (New England Revolution), Eric Gehrig (Columbus Crew), Marvell Wynne (Colorado Rapids), Lee Young-Pyo(Vancouver Whitecaps)

Midfielders: Nick DeLeon (D.C. United), Shalrie Joseph (New England Revolution), Kyle Beckerman (Real Salt Lake), Darlington Nagbe (Portland Timbers)

Forwards: Thierry Henry (New York Red Bulls), Maicon Santos (D.C. United)

Week 4 MLS Power Rankings
New Rank Previous Rank Team
1 2 Real Salt Lake (W/L/T: 3-1-0)
It's results like Saturday night's that make RSL perhaps the most difficult team in the league to put away. Facing certain loss in the house of horrors for visitors known as Jeld-Wen Field, reserve Jonny Steele and captain Kyle Beckerman came through to turn no points into three. With integral players returning to full fitness, RSL certainly has the makings of being the best in the West.
2 4 Sporting Kansas City (4-0-0)
Was Sunday's win over Chivas pretty? Far from it, but the franchise formerly known as the Wizards is off to its best start ever, and the formula remains the same: Stout defending + patient possession + invaluable contributions from Graham Zusi = 3 points.
3 1 Seattle Sounders (2-1-0)
Robbed by San Jose goalkeeper Jon Busch and given a raw deal in their own house on Steven Lenhart's penalty, the Sounders tasted defeat for the first time. Not quite how the club wants to enter its first road game of the season. On the plus side, Steve Zakuani went the distance in a 45-minute reserve match Sunday, his first live action since breaking his leg a year ago.
4 5 Houston Dynamo (2-1-0)
Resting easy on the first of two straight bye weeks, the Dynamo saw two players (Colin Clark, Adam Moffat) earn suspensions. Good thing there's time to game plan for the immediate future without both starters.
5 3 Los Angeles Galaxy (1-2-0)
What in the name of starpower is going on in Hollywood? Sure, Landon Donovan was out injured, but the egg the Galaxy's defense laid against the Revolution and Juninho's continued ineffectiveness paired with David Beckham being subbed off for apparent tactical reasons at halftime has to raise eyebrows across the league.
6 6 Vancouver Whitecaps (2-0-2)
No Eric Hassli. No Camilo. No Alain Rochat. And still, the league's worst road team in 2011 finds a way to scrap together a point in Philadelphia against a desperate opponent. Once Barry Robson arrives this summer to add that missing piece to the club's lackluster midfield, the attack may finally reach it's potential, too.
7 7 Colorado Rapids (3-1-0)
The good: midfielder Martin Rivero's debut showcased the latest player with an attacking flair in Oscar Pareja's arsenal, and Marvell Wynne's speed completely neutralized that of Chicago's Dominic Oduro. The bad: Pablo Mastroeni's head injury might be more debilitating than originally thought, and a Rocky Mountain Cup clash at Rio Tinto Stadium awaits this weekend.
8 9 San Jose Earthquakes (3-1-0)
If Vancouver is not the most improved team in MLS, San Jose is. The Quakes contained Seattle's potent attack and have still yet to concede a goal all season in the run of play. We'll find out which improved side is further along when the Caps and Quakes meet at Buck Shaw Stadium in a clash of surprising early-season contenders.
9 12 New York Red Bulls (2-2-0)
Thierry Henry and Kenny Cooper have spearheaded an offensive juggernaut over the last two matches, combining for eight goals in that time, but the club can't afford to have them slow down. Not with Luke Rodgers' visa being denied and Juan Agudelo on the shelf with a torn meniscus. There's reason for optimism at Red Bull Arena, but it should be tempered, especially with integral center back Wilman Conde limping off following the 5-2 thrashing of Montreal.
10 13 D.C. United (1-2-1)
Maicon Santos, Nick DeLeon and Danny Cruz were supposed to play complementary roles for D.C. this season. Instead, the trio combined to lead one of the club's better all-around efforts in some time. That certainly makes up for the continued lack of effectiveness from DPs Hamdi Salihi and Branko Boskovic.
11 8 FC Dallas (1-2-1)
Dallas was without George John and Fabian Castillo, both day-to-day, and Brek Shea will need time to recapture his form after Olympic qualifying, but the all-around display the club showed against D.C. was purely flat. If not for Blas Perez' continued efforts, the Dallas attack would be lost.
12 11 Portland Timbers (1-2-1)
Oh, how Portland will rue those lost points to Real Salt Lake, especially after Darlington Nagbe's double golazo. Just the latest case that no result is complete until the final whistle. At the very least, the Timbers know that they have one of the league's budding stars in tow.
13 14 Columbus Crew (2-1-0)
It's hard what to make of the Crew. Their two wins have come over a 10-man Impact side and a fragile Toronto club that has one eye on the CONCACAF Champions League. The back line is holding tight, and Shaun Francis is emerging as one of the league's premier left backs, but the attack is still far from a polished product.
14 10 Chicago Fire (1-1-1)
Going into Colorado and playing at altitude is never an easy task, but would it have killed Gonzalo Segares to close out on Brian Mullan instead of backing off and giving him more space to cross back to Omar Cummings for the game-breaking goal? Tight games come down to individual moments, and that was the back-breaker for the Fire.
15 16 New England Revolution (2-2-0)
Result of the week goes to the Revs. The unpredictability and movement created by a Benny Feilhaber-less midfield tortured the Galaxy all night, and Saer Sene scoring for a second straight game lends hope up front as well. Second-year center back A.J. Soares' poise against Robbie Keane and Edson Buddle flew under the radar considering the club's attacking display, but it did not go unnoticed.
16 15 Chivas USA (1-3-0)
After four games, this much is clear about the limited Goats: They're going to have to scrap for every goal, but their stacked approach in defense will make life difficult for the opposition.
17 17 Philadelphia Union (0-3-1)
The Union avoided a catastrophe by having Sebastien Le Toux miss his golden chance at a late winner at PPL Park, but the fact remains that the club couldn't put away a Whitecaps side missing three key starters. It's on Freddy Adu and Roger Torres, both of whom missed Saturday's match, to light a creative spark for this underachieving group.
18 18 Toronto FC (0-3-0)
TFC refuses to replicate its CONCACAF Champions League form in league play, and as a result, the Reds are the only pointless team in the league. Barring a stunner in Wednesday's clash with Santos Laguna in Mexico, TFC will have to turn its full focus to league player, where the top objectives must be finding a solution to protect the fragile defense while getting goal-less DP striker Danny Koevermans on a roll.
19 19 Montreal Impact (0-3-1)
Montreal's defensive effort against New York brought new meaning to the word shambolic. Hard to be a competitive expansion team if defenders will shy away from headers in the box, allow Henry to turn and shoot and continue to commit penalties. Life doesn't get any easier, as Montreal faces a daunting week with a midweek clash at RSL followed by a Canadian derby against Toronto FC.
SI Videos
Videos from the Web
Hot Topics: NBA Playoffs NHL Playoffs NFL schedule LaMarcus Aldridge Michael Pineda Phil Jackson Tiger Woods
TM & © 2014 Time Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines and ad choices.
SI CoverRead All ArticlesBuy Cover Reprint