SI Vault
 
Bullpen Roulette
Tim Kurkjian
April 04, 1994
In the city that never sleeps, it seems somehow fitting that the Yankees have no closer. They didn't re-sign free agents Lee Smith or Steve Fart after the season, and they pursued but didn't land Oriole free agent Gregg Olson. So New York will open the season with a closer-by-committee approach. "Part of me wants that," says manager Buck Showalter. "When you leave a carrot out there for three guys, it keeps them all sharp. Also, the guys we're looking at might be able to close two innings."
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
April 04, 1994

Bullpen Roulette

View CoverRead All Articles View This Issue

THE LINEUP

LF

Luis Polonia

Average the last four years: .271, .286, .296, .335

3B

Wade Boggs

119 intentional BBs from '87 to '92; four last year

1B

Don Mattingly

Six years as top-fielding 1B ties AL record

DH

Danny Tartabull

Wonder what he could do with 600 healthy at bats?

RF

Paul O'Neill

.311 average in '93 raised his career mark to .268

C

Mike Stanley

10th catcher ever to hit .300, 25 HRs in a season

CF

Bernie Williams

Support player with some tools, little else

SS

Mike Gallego

Versatile Randy Velarde will get playing time here too

2B

Pat Kelly

Raised batting average from .226 to .273 last year

Ace

Jimmy Key

Smartest, craftiest pitcher in American League

Closer

Bob Wickman

Opponents hit .284 against him last season

INSTANT ANALYST

While winning 88 games last year, the Yankees became the first American League team since the 1950 Red Sox to have six .300 hitters (minimum 200 at bats). Five of those six hit at least 50 points above their career averages.

Player

Avg.

AB

1993 H

HR

RBI

Career Avg.

Best Avg. Pre-1993

Wade Boggs

.302

560

169

2

59

.338

.368

Dion James

.332

343

114

7

36

.282

.312

Paul O'Neill

.311

498

155

20

75

.259

.276

Mike Stanley

.305

423

129

26

84

.251

.273

Randy Velarde

.301

226

68

7

24

.248

.272

Jim Leyritz

.309

259

80

14

53

.246

.257

PREDICTED FINISH: THIRD

In the city that never sleeps, it seems somehow fitting that the Yankees have no closer. They didn't re-sign free agents Lee Smith or Steve Fart after the season, and they pursued but didn't land Oriole free agent Gregg Olson. So New York will open the season with a closer-by-committee approach. "Part of me wants that," says manager Buck Showalter. "When you leave a carrot out there for three guys, it keeps them all sharp. Also, the guys we're looking at might be able to close two innings."

Showalter, 37, loves to try to outmanage his opponents, and he often does. Therefore it helps him to have a lot of interchangeable parts—and that's largely what this team is made of—so he can tinker with his lineup and his pitching staff. He's not a robo-manager who uses his closer as a crutch, always bringing him in with the bases empty in the ninth and his team in the lead. Instead, he's the rare strategist who will use his best reliever to get out of a seventh-inning jam.

Overall, New York has enough firepower, potentially the best rotation in the AL East and decent defense, so the Yankees will go as far as their bullpen takes them. Most of the pressure will fall on the three men with the carrot dangling in front of them: righthander Xavier Hernandez, 28, who was acquired in an off-season trade with the Astros; lefthander Steve Howe, 36, who until 1993 was more reliable on the Held than he was off it; and righthander Bob Wickman, 25, who until the middle of last season had spent his entire pro career as a starter.

A spectacular setup man the last two years in Houston, Hernandez had a 2.61 ERA and struck out 101 in 96? innings in '93. But middle relief and closing are two different beasts, says Jeff Reardon, 38, who is second alltime in saves (365) and is trying to make the Yanks as a middle reliever. "Closing is a whole new ball game," says Reardon. "Other closers have had better stuff than me, but they didn't have as much up here [pointing to his head] and in here [guts]." Hernandez throws a sinking, running fastball, a slider and a split-fingered fastball, which is his best pitch. He seldom closed games in Houston because the Astros were paying Doug Jones $2 million to do that.

Relying on Hernandez would seem to be a safer proposition than counting on Howe, who hasn't been the same pitcher since he was suspended in June 1992 after pleading guilty to a charge of attempted possession of cocaine. He was 3-0 with six saves and a 2.45 ERA at the time. When Howe returned to the learn last year, he went 3-5 with a 4.97 ERA, struck out only 19 in 50? innings and spent a month on the disabled list with an ankle injury. There's a real question as to how much he has left.

Wickman, on the other hand, has a lot to offer, and as of last weekend Showalter was leaning toward giving him first crack at the closer's job. Wickman has good stuff, and he's a winner (32-19 in the minor leagues, 20-5 in the majors). He won his first eight decisions last year, then lost three in a row and was sent to the bullpen. In relief, Wickman went 6-0 with four saves after the All-Star break. "Every time we see him," says Oriole pitching coach Dick Bosnian, "he throws great."

[This article contains a table. Please see hardcopy of magazine or PDF.]

1