Drafted first overall by Ottawa in 1995, he was traded to the Islanders for Redden and won the Calder Trophy in 1996-97. A free-wheeler, he has improved defensively since the Leafs obtained him last season.
Drafted second overall by the Islanders in 1995, he was traded for Berard and has become the anchor of the Senators' backline. He also has improved offensively since last season and through Sunday had nine goals and 19 assists.
The Verdict: In a close call we'll go with the steady Redden, even though Berard could have a higher upside.